Not so healthy Yellow Watchman Goby

Ldanielle

New Member
View Badges
Joined
Nov 4, 2026
Messages
10
Reaction score
7
Location
Kentucky
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
I ordered a Yellow Watchman Goby, a pistol shrimp and a GSP frag from what I thought was a decently reputable retailer. The shrimp seems fine, the GSP seems ok but had several small things come out when I dipped it. This poor goby tho, I thought initially it was DOA but noticed gill movement so I floated it for 30 mins and then scooped straight into tank per retailer’s instructions. It just floated around the tank like it was dead. So I scooped it back up and put it in a little breeder tank I have inside my tank at the moment. It survived the night so I tried to release back towards the bottom of the tank and it did ok for a few minutes and then just started floating around the tank again like it’s not strong enough to swim maybe. New to the hobby so I’m concerned on how to move forward. The retailer was very nasty when confronted about my shipment so they’re no help. Pics of goby and things that came out of gsp attached
20261114_094207_02F16FA0-73B5-424F-9831-F5EA4CA19FD3.png


20261114_094207_8028AE0A-76E9-4403-AE99-56A32109CB7E.png


20261114_094207_A89A409F-B696-4166-8F04-09EFFFAC8F1B.png


20261114_094207_F3D4E2AE-F531-459F-973D-48EBBF430566.png


20261114_094208_AB9FB2B0-6ADE-4500-B66D-6255342BBA5B.png


20261114_094208_5AB12CFA-582E-4983-9F41-BE59C76C025F.png


20261114_094208_2DBA7230-0C4C-4521-9040-FA0AD6B50A76.png
 
I ordered a Yellow Watchman Goby, a pistol shrimp and a GSP frag from what I thought was a decently reputable retailer. The shrimp seems fine, the GSP seems ok but had several small things come out when I dipped it. This poor goby tho, I thought initially it was DOA but noticed gill movement so I floated it for 30 mins and then scooped straight into tank per retailer’s instructions. It just floated around the tank like it was dead. So I scooped it back up and put it in a little breeder tank I have inside my tank at the moment. It survived the night so I tried to release back towards the bottom of the tank and it did ok for a few minutes and then just started floating around the tank again like it’s not strong enough to swim maybe. New to the hobby so I’m concerned on how to move forward. The retailer was very nasty when confronted about my shipment so they’re no help. Pics of goby and things that came out of gsp attached
20261114_094207_02F16FA0-73B5-424F-9831-F5EA4CA19FD3.png


20261114_094207_8028AE0A-76E9-4403-AE99-56A32109CB7E.png


20261114_094207_A89A409F-B696-4166-8F04-09EFFFAC8F1B.png


20261114_094207_F3D4E2AE-F531-459F-973D-48EBBF430566.png


20261114_094208_AB9FB2B0-6ADE-4500-B66D-6255342BBA5B.png


20261114_094208_5AB12CFA-582E-4983-9F41-BE59C76C025F.png


20261114_094208_2DBA7230-0C4C-4521-9040-FA0AD6B50A76.png
Fish is awefully thin and may be feeding off its liver. If new, I would return it to the store you got it from
 
I ordered a Yellow Watchman Goby, a pistol shrimp and a GSP frag from what I thought was a decently reputable retailer. The shrimp seems fine, the GSP seems ok but had several small things come out when I dipped it. This poor goby tho, I thought initially it was DOA but noticed gill movement so I floated it for 30 mins and then scooped straight into tank per retailer’s instructions. It just floated around the tank like it was dead. So I scooped it back up and put it in a little breeder tank I have inside my tank at the moment. It survived the night so I tried to release back towards the bottom of the tank and it did ok for a few minutes and then just started floating around the tank again like it’s not strong enough to swim maybe. New to the hobby so I’m concerned on how to move forward. The retailer was very nasty when confronted about my shipment so they’re no help. Pics of goby and things that came out of gsp attached
20261114_094207_02F16FA0-73B5-424F-9831-F5EA4CA19FD3.png


20261114_094207_8028AE0A-76E9-4403-AE99-56A32109CB7E.png


20261114_094207_A89A409F-B696-4166-8F04-09EFFFAC8F1B.png


20261114_094207_F3D4E2AE-F531-459F-973D-48EBBF430566.png


20261114_094208_AB9FB2B0-6ADE-4500-B66D-6255342BBA5B.png


20261114_094208_5AB12CFA-582E-4983-9F41-BE59C76C025F.png


20261114_094208_2DBA7230-0C4C-4521-9040-FA0AD6B50A76.png

Welcome to Reef2Reef!

I agree, the fish is dreadfully thin - what happens is that fish don't have much in the way of fat reserves. When they have been starved - either from some health issue, or just not being fed properly through the supply chain, they utilize their liver for food energy. The trouble is, once that happens, the liver is toast and the fish can't recover.

Sorry - but it looks like they sold you a bad fish.....

Jay
 
20261115_115709_1D445434-6EE3-4D01-80E5-3EA602928B03.png

As of today the fish is still alive, still not very strong and getting pushed around by the current so it’s still in the breeder box. Eating pellets occasionally so I’m keeping an eye on it 🤷🏼‍♀️
I purchased the fish online and when I emailed customer service about it they were really rude and basically said they starve and poison their fish for 45 days so that’s what I get 😅
 
20261115_115709_1D445434-6EE3-4D01-80E5-3EA602928B03.png

As of today the fish is still alive, still not very strong and getting pushed around by the current so it’s still in the breeder box. Eating pellets occasionally so I’m keeping an eye on it 🤷🏼‍♀️
I purchased the fish online and when I emailed customer service about it they were really rude and basically said they starve and poison their fish for 45 days so that’s what I get 😅

Feed it multiple small feedings during the day (avoiding uneaten food). This may allow it to build its strength back. It’s stomach is shrunken, so single big feedings won’t work as well.
 
New to the hobby so I’m concerned on how to move forward.
Watchman (Sulphur goby) Paired with a shrimp is a fascinating thing to monitor 😍

No disrespect to you my friend.
There are rules keeping fish!

01, You aren't keeping fish,...you are keeping water!
02, Research
03, Never make impulse purchases
04, Anyone that says trust me, i know what i know what i am talking about, hasn't made mistakes, then they are liars and the ones to avoid! Cash is the only interest for these fckrs
 

TOP 10 Trending Threads

HOW WOULD YOU FEEL ABOUT RECEIVING A FISH OR CORAL AS A HOLIDAY GIFT?

  • I’d love one, as long as it’s a species I chose

    Votes: 17 29.8%
  • I’d trust someone who knows my tank to choose

    Votes: 2 3.5%
  • I’d rather get a gift card and pick it myself

    Votes: 22 38.6%
  • I’d prefer gear or supplies instead

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • Please don’t surprise me with livestock

    Votes: 16 28.1%
  • Other (Post in the comments)

    Votes: 0 0.0%
Back
Top
Home
Post thread…
Market
What's new