steps to avoid arriving at the crossroads:
1. abandon hands off reefing which is only using water actions/param changes/indirect means to control algae. its what we've all been taught. it works terribly.
2. when building a reef, design the rocks for direct access, on your counter one day. That may be inconvenient or nonstandard, you might not get a Saxby wall, you might have to be creative with coral bommies if your tank is huge, but external is external and that's opposite than water-only methods that kill thousands of tanks which started well. scan work threads in the nuisance algae forum here, imagine you have ten years of sps in place and you get algae and you refuse to lose it, whats your next step option? plan ahead. super huge tanks can employ a crank and pulley system where rocks can be lifted up somehow, outside of tank and at least worked in the air, they don't have to just sit there on the bottom of the tank for forty years.
if someone paid you $750,000 to design a reef tank where the rocks could be lifted to the surface and beyond just a bit, could you do that? then make it happen in your own reef which will be worth five grand before you know it.
3. the uglies phase in reefing is the worst advice we circulate. purposefully self-invading any reef is counterproductive; a shocking turn of events. be hand guiding your reef,
when we moved into a new home did we purposefully entertain the uglies in the lawn? did we let dandelions go rampant so they'd eventually starve out? we do that in our reefs though> we circulate info in reefing, from our teachers, that makes us get invaded. plan oppositely is best course. the teachers are getting to also sell bottled cures for profit not by intent but by beneficial coincidence.
4. animals and grazers wont take responsibility for access and can't replace it. access to your rocks on the counter is the best approach we have until a for-cost doser dose a better job. counter surgery allows you to not contact corals with algae attacks, it separates the jobs and forces you to plan for access.
5. in no way are params responsible for GHA problems, like the masses would say. I don't see lots of work in the nuisance algae forum to impress me with param control.
6. Go cure some gha tanks that are not your own in the nuisance algae forum as live time jobs where they post feedback pics on your suggestions. This is the prime way to prevent your own reef from becoming infected by will. you don't have to take on whole reefs at once, that's what water dosers do. You can test model sections of total control...lift out a five pound rock + target and learn to directly control it, on the counter, and put back. when that holds, then upscale to the large tank. Quit farming algae via the uglies and you'll never have an algae problem. any gha tank here can be made gha free overnite, if they choose to.
7. your filthy sandbed: reverse that.
doing opposite of steps 1-7 leads right to the crossroads of loss.
internal locus of control vs external locus of control, the classic conflict. all GHA invasions are psychology well before biology. you either want dandelions or you don't.
the truth is ive been that neighbor. possibly more often than not. but Id never do it in my reef tank I do have standards.