Over sized skimmers

REEF-NOOB__8-)

New Member
View Badges
Joined
Nov 10, 2019
Messages
6
Reaction score
0
What state or country do you live in
California
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
Can it have a negative impact using a over sized skimmer? I have a 75 g with 30g sump could i add a bubble magus 250
 
An oversized skimmer is needed if you carbon dose, but it can also strip out essential nutrients thereby starving the tank.

There are strategies like running the skimmer only several hours a day instead of continuously that would alleviate the potential issue of nutrient depletion.

Other than that, I'd say get the biggest skimmer you can afford/accommodate. It's been very nice to have skimmer rated for 250 gallons on my 125 gallon system :)
 
Sometimes using an overrated skimmer can be a hassle. You might have to fiddle with it more or make adjustments. Sometimes its hard to get the foam production the way you want it and have either overflowing cup or microbubbles in the water. Also depends on the skimmer itself. Underrated is more of a set it and forget it method, but are you removing everything you could? Probably not.
 
Sometimes using an overrated skimmer can be a hassle. You might have to fiddle with it more or make adjustments. Sometimes its hard to get the foam production the way you want it and have either overflowing cup or microbubbles in the water. Also depends on the skimmer itself. Underrated is more of a set it and forget it method, but are you removing everything you could? Probably not.
This is very true. I need to check on my large skimmer periodically to ensure foam is overflowing into the collection cup.

It was very useful, however, in removing the fine aragonite particles from the tank when I first added live sand. It took the skimmer less than 24 hours to make the water crystal clear (and aragonite mud in the collection cup).

The larger skimmer also helps to ensure good aeration when it is running, for what that's worth.
 
The biggest thing with over sizing the skimmer too much is the inconsistent performance from the skimmer. the neck is often too wide and so the skimmer needs to run more wet.
The bad thing is it seems a lot of brands are inconsistent in their sizing. So it is quite possible for one to oversize dramatically. If I could suggest one thing it would be find a brand(s) that you might like and try to find users with a similar size display tank, and skimmer. Ask them what they like and dislike about it, find out their fish bioload and feeding frequency. This could help you choose the proper sized skimmer for your setup.

corey
 
As with all things, 'over sized' can mean different things to different people …. though I suppose if your skimmer holds more volume than your tank we'd probably all agree it's too big! About a year ago, give or take, I swapped a large skimmer 'rated' for a 600-700 gallons system (which is the size of my system) for a very large one 'rated' for 2,000 gallons. Amount of skimmate removed is about the same - suggesting that a large skimmer was unnecessary LOL. The bigger unit is no more difficult to setup and maintain than the prior one was.
 
Simon, out of curiosity - don’t you use a lifereef or beckett? When you upgraded skimmers, did you put a bigger pump on it? I ran a Beckett for awhile and what I liked about it (one of the many things) was that if I upgraded to a slightly larger tank all I needed to do was put a bigger pump on it. If it was a much larger tank then I could hav head GEO build me an extension for the body.


corey
 
Could also add that moving water through the sump would be important to consider. If you prefer a higher turnover rate, you might want the larger skimmer, as well as the opposite consideration. I am pushing 900gph through my 60dt and 30 gallon sump. Kind of high by today's standards, but skimmer rated for 150 gallon heavy stock, still skimming too efficiently, been thinking about running on a timer. I-Tech 200 skimmer for reference.
Cheers
 
Simon, out of curiosity - don’t you use a lifereef or beckett? When you upgraded skimmers, did you put a bigger pump on it? I ran a Beckett for awhile and what I liked about it (one of the many things) was that if I upgraded to a slightly larger tank all I needed to do was put a bigger pump on it. If it was a much larger tank then I could hav head GEO build me an extension for the body.
corey

Corey, good memory ... I’m a marine technical concepts fan and have been running their skimmers for literally decades. Current is a self modified HSA3000. I’ve been swapping between mazzei and Beckett’s for a while now since apparently I cannot make up my mind LOL. Mazzei are less twitchy but don’t perform quite as well.
 
Thanks for the speedy advice everyone. I decided to pass on that skimmer im thinking of going with something a bit smaller. If you guys have any suggestions let me know.
 
I use my skimner to add fresh outside air to my system since I have low ph all the time when the house is closed up so I like an oversized skimmer.
 
I use my skimner to add fresh outside air to my system since I have low ph all the time when the house is closed up so I like an oversized skimmer.

Scorpius, how much of a difference in pH did you notice after using a larger skimmer?
 
I tend to run skimmers rated for a much larger system. I feed heavy, both fish and corals. I like everyone to be fat and happy. Also when you decide to add a frag tank to the system ( which I think everyone does eventually), you won't have the added cost of needing a new skimmer;). You can always turn off the skimmer if it's doing to good of a job, you can't make a smaller one work harder.
 

TOP 10 Trending Threads

WHAT DO YOU ALWAYS RUN OUT OF AT THE WORST TIME?

  • Salt mix

    Votes: 17 18.7%
  • Fish or coral food

    Votes: 5 5.5%
  • Test kits or reagents

    Votes: 9 9.9%
  • Filter media or replacement fleece

    Votes: 5 5.5%
  • RO/DI filters or supplies

    Votes: 14 15.4%
  • Fragging and repair supplies, like glue or epoxy

    Votes: 10 11.0%
  • I keep a backup of everything

    Votes: 24 26.4%
  • Other (Post in the comments)

    Votes: 7 7.7%
Back
Top
Home
Post thread…
Market
What's new