- Joined
- Feb 7, 2024
- Messages
- 5
- Reaction score
- 1
- Location
- turkey
- What state or country do you live in
- Other International
I'm having trouble with my sandbed, which is leaching phosphates and KH. Some people have suggested that I remove the sand, but I'm a bit concerned about this. Currently, there is no sand stock left in my country, so for now, I can only remove it, not replace it.
(There is no excessive algae growth or cyano at the moment. Even if I don't clean the glass for a week, I don’t see any algae growing on it.)
I tested the salt mix with fresh RODI water, so the salt can't be the culprit:
When I checked phosphate levels 1.5 months ago, I couldn't believe the test results and assumed the test kit had expired. Then, 2 weeks ago, my friend tested it and found that it was above 3 ppm.
The first thing I suspected was the RODI cartridges—I hadn't changed them for a year and a half (yeah, I forgot!
). The carbon cartridge was probably saturated and leaching phosphate. I immediately replaced it after seeing the results.
Then, I ran a GFO reactor and did a 20% water change every day for 3 days. It seemed to work—phosphate levels dropped to 0.5 ppm (tested with two different kits, three times, just to be sure). So, I removed the GFO from the tank.
The next morning, I tested PO4 again, and it was back between 1–3 ppm. The only thing left to suspect is the sandbed leaching phosphate. I've always been concerned about the sand because I never knew the brand when I bought it 2 years ago—my LFS gave it to me from an unbranded sack.
(Currently, the tank has only mushrooms and some Favia corals, all my SPS and Euphyllia corals are died. A full reset is not an option at the moment.)
Thanks!
Current Parameters:
- Phosphate: 1–3 ppm
- Nitrate: 10 ppm
- KH: 10–12 (even though I do a 10–15% water change every 3 days with 8 KH salt)
(There is no excessive algae growth or cyano at the moment. Even if I don't clean the glass for a week, I don’t see any algae growing on it.)
I tested the salt mix with fresh RODI water, so the salt can't be the culprit:
- Phosphate: 0 ppm
- Nitrate: 0 ppm
- KH: 7.9 ppm
Background:
When I checked phosphate levels 1.5 months ago, I couldn't believe the test results and assumed the test kit had expired. Then, 2 weeks ago, my friend tested it and found that it was above 3 ppm.
The first thing I suspected was the RODI cartridges—I hadn't changed them for a year and a half (yeah, I forgot!
). The carbon cartridge was probably saturated and leaching phosphate. I immediately replaced it after seeing the results.Then, I ran a GFO reactor and did a 20% water change every day for 3 days. It seemed to work—phosphate levels dropped to 0.5 ppm (tested with two different kits, three times, just to be sure). So, I removed the GFO from the tank.
The next morning, I tested PO4 again, and it was back between 1–3 ppm. The only thing left to suspect is the sandbed leaching phosphate. I've always been concerned about the sand because I never knew the brand when I bought it 2 years ago—my LFS gave it to me from an unbranded sack.
My Questions:
- What should I do after removing the sandbed?
- How can I maintain phosphate and nitrate stability without a sandbed?
(Currently, the tank has only mushrooms and some Favia corals, all my SPS and Euphyllia corals are died. A full reset is not an option at the moment.)
Thanks!
Last edited:

, it's not ethical.