Phosphate Spikes & Persistent High KH – Sandbed removal?

papaya

New Member
View Badges
Joined
Feb 7, 2024
Messages
5
Reaction score
1
Location
turkey
What state or country do you live in
Other International
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
I'm having trouble with my sandbed, which is leaching phosphates and KH. Some people have suggested that I remove the sand, but I'm a bit concerned about this. Currently, there is no sand stock left in my country, so for now, I can only remove it, not replace it.


Current Parameters:​

  • Phosphate: 1–3 ppm
  • Nitrate: 10 ppm
  • KH: 10–12 (even though I do a 10–15% water change every 3 days with 8 KH salt)

(There is no excessive algae growth or cyano at the moment. Even if I don't clean the glass for a week, I don’t see any algae growing on it.)


I tested the salt mix with fresh RODI water, so the salt can't be the culprit:
  • Phosphate: 0 ppm
  • Nitrate: 0 ppm
  • KH: 7.9 ppm

Background:​


When I checked phosphate levels 1.5 months ago, I couldn't believe the test results and assumed the test kit had expired. Then, 2 weeks ago, my friend tested it and found that it was above 3 ppm.


The first thing I suspected was the RODI cartridges—I hadn't changed them for a year and a half (yeah, I forgot! 😅). The carbon cartridge was probably saturated and leaching phosphate. I immediately replaced it after seeing the results.


Then, I ran a GFO reactor and did a 20% water change every day for 3 days. It seemed to work—phosphate levels dropped to 0.5 ppm (tested with two different kits, three times, just to be sure). So, I removed the GFO from the tank.


The next morning, I tested PO4 again, and it was back between 1–3 ppm. The only thing left to suspect is the sandbed leaching phosphate. I've always been concerned about the sand because I never knew the brand when I bought it 2 years ago—my LFS gave it to me from an unbranded sack.


My Questions:​


  • What should I do after removing the sandbed?
  • How can I maintain phosphate and nitrate stability without a sandbed?

(Currently, the tank has only mushrooms and some Favia corals, all my SPS and Euphyllia corals are died. A full reset is not an option at the moment.)


Thanks!
 
Last edited:
I'm having trouble with my sandbed, which is leaching phosphates and KH. Some people have suggested that I remove the sand, but I'm a bit concerned about this. Currently, there is no sand stock left in my country, so for now, I can only remove it, not replace it.


Current Parameters:​

  • Phosphate: 1–3 ppm
  • Nitrate: 10 ppm
  • KH: 10–12 (even though I do a 10–15% water change every 3 days with 8 KH salt)

(There is no excessive algae growth or cyano at the moment. Even if I don't clean the glass for a week, I don’t see any algae growing on it.)


I tested the salt mix with fresh RODI water, so the salt can't be the culprit:
  • Phosphate: 0 ppm
  • Nitrate: 0 ppm
  • KH: 7.9 ppm

Background:​


When I checked phosphate levels 1.5 months ago, I couldn't believe the test results and assumed the test kit had expired. Then, 2 weeks ago, my friend tested it and found that it was above 3 ppm.


The first thing I suspected was the RODI cartridges—I hadn't changed them for a year and a half (yeah, I forgot! 😅). The carbon cartridge was probably saturated and leaching phosphate. I immediately replaced it after seeing the results.


Then, I ran a GFO reactor and did a 20% water change every day for 3 days. It seemed to work—phosphate levels dropped to 0.5 ppm (tested with two different kits, three times, just to be sure). So, I removed the GFO from the tank.


The next morning, I tested PO4 again, and it was back between 1–3 ppm. The only thing left to suspect is the sandbed leaching phosphate. I've always been concerned about the sand because I never knew the brand when I bought it 2 years ago—my LFS gave it to me from an unbranded sack.


My Questions:​


  • What should I do after removing the sandbed?
  • How can I maintain phosphate and nitrate stability without a sandbed?

(Currently, the tank has only mushrooms and some Favia corals, all my SPS and Euphyllia corals are died. A full reset is not an option at the moment.)


Thanks!
Are there aragonite rocks in the aquarium and if so, might they be leaching phosphate?
 
Are there aragonite rocks in the aquarium and if so, might they be leaching phosphate?
There is only Aquaforest rock in the tank. I bought it brand new.
 
Dry rock can definitely leach some phosphates just like the sand could.

I would just continue using gfo to gradually bring it down and not worry too much about it.

From memory, denitrification + gradual dissolving of aragonite material will increase alk (assuming nothing is utilizing it). Your number for that is not an issue and could even be a testing error in my opinion.
 
Dry rock can definitely leach some phosphates just like the sand could.

I would just continue using gfo to gradually bring it down and not worry too much about it.

From memory, denitrification + gradual dissolving of aragonite material will increase alk (assuming nothing is utilizing it). Your number for that is not an issue and could even be a testing error in my opinion.
But the AF rocks have been in the system for 2 years. I haven’t made any changes or added any additives since then.

And no, it can't be the test error. 4 different people tested it with 3 different kits. Every result was the same.
 
Aragonite (rocks or sand) will bind phosphate and maintain it in equilibrium. Export of phosphate by gfo or LC from the water will cause the release of phosphate from where it is bound on the aragonite so that the numbers rebound after treatments to remove P from a tank.

I think you are chasing numbers for no good reason? If the corals you have are fine then lowering P is not needed?

Same as removing sand. If you like the sand keep the sand. Otherwise, if you want to remove the sand, sell it to someone in your country who wants it. The local shortage in supply might make it worth a lot of money or frags on the local reef market?
 
Aragonite (rocks or sand) will bind phosphate and maintain it in equilibrium. Export of phosphate by gfo or LC from the water will cause the release of phosphate from where it is bound on the aragonite so that the numbers rebound after treatments to remove P from a tank.

I think you are chasing numbers for no good reason? If the corals you have are fine then lowering P is not needed?

Same as removing sand. If you like the sand keep the sand. Otherwise, if you want to remove the sand, sell it to someone in your country who wants it. The local shortage in supply might make it worth a lot of money or frags on the local reef market?
I’m trying to lower PO4 because I’ve lost nearly half of my corals. The health of the remaining corals isn’t good either. Their growth rate has significantly dropped and almost reversed; I can see the bare skeleton on the edges of some of the Favia and Chalice corals.


I’m not someone who makes frequent changes, as I know stability is key. But I believe this tank won’t get good unless I make some changes.


Why should I sell leaching sand 😂, it's not ethical.
 
Last edited:
I’m trying to lower PO4 because I’ve lost nearly half of my corals. The health of the remaining corals isn’t good either. Their growth rate has significantly dropped and almost reversed; I can see the bare skeleton on the edges of some of the Favia and Chalice corals.





I’m not someone who makes frequent changes, as I know stability is key. But I believe this tank won’t get good unless I make some changes.


Why should I sell leaching sand 😂, it's not ethical.

You could consider removing the sand, and treat it outside the aquarium. Meanwhile, you can slowly bring down the PO4 in the aquarium . You might find that you still have a phosphate problem. Watch out though for a possible ammonia spike after the sand removal. I assume you have fish.
 
But the AF rocks have been in the system for 2 years. I haven’t made any changes or added any additives since then.

And no, it can't be the test error. 4 different people tested it with 3 different kits. Every result was the same.
The longer any calcium carbonate stays in a system the more phosphate gets bound to it.

With 2 years in a running system that rock is certainly a source of elevated phosphates assuming phosphates were not well controlled prior. As you lower phospates in the water, the rock and the sand will leach out to an equilibrium without fail.

As far as testing accuracy is concerned, something has to be happening for alk to rise if it's not a testing error.
Either it's being added (supplements) or it's a by product of some type of nitrification going on(or carbon dosing)/effect of gradual dissolving of calcium carbonate somewhere that out paces consumption.
 

TOP 10 Trending Threads

HOW WOULD YOU FEEL ABOUT RECEIVING A FISH OR CORAL AS A HOLIDAY GIFT?

  • I’d love one, as long as it’s a species I chose

    Votes: 19 28.8%
  • I’d trust someone who knows my tank to choose

    Votes: 2 3.0%
  • I’d rather get a gift card and pick it myself

    Votes: 24 36.4%
  • I’d prefer gear or supplies instead

    Votes: 2 3.0%
  • Please don’t surprise me with livestock

    Votes: 19 28.8%
  • Other (Post in the comments)

    Votes: 0 0.0%
Back
Top
Home
Post thread…
Market
What's new