- Joined
- Jul 31, 2021
- Messages
- 84
- Reaction score
- 72
- Location
- Fairfax, Virginia
- What state or country do you live in
- Virginia
Re-make Star Wars III (Jedi) with that thing as Jabba
Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
Any cuc in the refugiums? I started to have same issues then in one of my 30 gallon refugiums added 2 big turbos, few trochus, and a handful of blue leg crabs. Turbos and trouchus keep the walls clean while the blue legs climb the macros and eat the detritus, etc. off it. Or maybe the abundance of pods do most the work? Either way no issues since. Just a thought…The refugia ran great with ulva for about a year or longer, then began to get cyano then the gha.
I recently put a bunch of chaeto in it and that seems to be growing well, but there is also substantial gha in the refugium.
I ran various ATS setups for years, and a refugium for many years, sometimes one or the other, often both. Split lighting cycles, reverse and coincident at various times.
I can’t correlate direct cause and effect to nuisance algae in the display.
Two experienced, knowledgeable reef aquarists stating that trying to outcompete GHA with a refugium or a ATS hasn't been the simple equation that so many suggest it can be.The refugia ran great with ulva for about a year or longer, then began to get cyano then the gha.
I recently put a bunch of chaeto in it and that seems to be growing well, but there is also substantial gha in the refugium.
And even the most sophisticated, and expensive algae reactor may have negilgable effect managing GHA.I used to run Pax Bellum ARID units on 3 systems. Two grew clean Chaeto, one would always foul with GHA. I was unable to reach a conclusion if they reduced algae in the display or not.
Just saw this. I am sorry for your loss. I will save sounding clever and technically savy about hair algae for another time.I’m gutted to even post such a disaster picture, and was hoping I might never have to if the sea hares did their job, but here is the sickening mess:
![]()
This is what it looked like just 5 months ago:
![]()
Probably this has been discussed before, but have you tried fluconazole treatment yet?
I looked for research on the optimal photoperiod a few years ago. This is what I found.I’m experimenting with lighting my refugia 24/7 to see if I can force more growth there and less in the display.
In my last tank I experimented with 24/7 and did not see much difference compared to 12-18 h on, but also did not have an algae problem in the display then.
I looked for research on the optimal photoperiod a few years ago. This is what I found.
https://link.springer.com/content/pdf/10.1007/BF01609886.pdf
Research was conducted by P. Kornmann in 1969, with additional observations published in 1970 in Helgoländer Wissenschaftliche Meeresuntersuchungen (now Helgoland Marine Research).
Study: Regularities of Growth and Development in Chaetomorpha darwinii
The researchers examined how individual cells of Chaetomorpha darwinii grew and divided under controlled lighting conditions.
Key findings
1. Growth followed the light–dark cycle. Under a 14-hour light / 10-hour dark schedule, cells elongated more rapidly during illumination than during darkness.
2. Growth continued in darkness. Cell elongation slowed during the dark period but did not stop completely.
3. Cells behaved synchronously. Cells near the growing tips of the algal filaments exhibited remarkably similar responses to changes in illumination.
4. Cell division was examined separately. The researchers documented the formation of new cross-walls and found that division time depended substantially on cell diameter.
What does this tell us about 24-hour lighting?
The study establishes that Chaetomorpha growth responds to the daily light–dark cycle.
However, it does not demonstrate that a dark period is necessary or beneficial for maximum growth.
It also doesn't establish whether continuous illumination produces more biomass over 24 hours than a shorter photoperiod.
Relevance to reef aquariums
For nutrient export, the important measurement is total biomass produced and harvested, not simply how rapidly cells elongate during daylight.
The study provides no direct comparison of nutrient removal under 12-, 18-, and 24-hour lighting schedules.
This research doesn't provide a scientific reason to avoid 24-hour lighting for Chaetomorpha linum. Nor does it establish that continuous lighting is optimal.