Caveat: I am in the critical stages of a massive Dino battle in a mature tank. I have not won but I have researched. So take this for what it’s worth.
Over the last 8 months, I have oscillated between algae, cyano, and dinos and the dinos are currently winning. Badly. I’ve lost most of my coral colonies, including some that have grown in my tank for more than 5 years. Heartbreaking to say the least.
What I have learned from the experience and extensive research:
1. Everything alive wants to live and will fight to the death to do so. That seems obvious when you write it but it’s easily forgotten when you look at your beautiful coral covered with ugly dinos and wonder why nothing works. Why won’t the dinos die and stay dead? They're ugly!
2. Number 1 applies to even a single cell.
3. Every tank with animals, plants, and water from the ocean has autotrophic (denitrifying) bacteria, heterotrophic (scavenging) bacteria, cyano, diatoms, dinos, parasitic organisms, pods, etc., worms, etc., other things, etc. that all live by numbers 1 and 2.
4. Every organism has evolved to thrive within its niche.
5. None of them care what we want.
Understanding 1-5 above, we can then understand that most, if not all, pest problems in our tanks are a result of an unwanted organism outcompeting a wanted organism.
So leverage #4 and shift the niche.
Dinos are both photosynthetic and heterotrophic. They get energy from light and from other organisms they “eat.” That makes them particularly hard to eradicate. You can certainly kill all you can see but they come back. Forget starving them out. They’ll be the last to lose. The prevailing theory is to support heterotrophic organisms that don’t trash our tanks. In other words, trade good bacteria for bad and make a niche environment that sustains the good. That last part is often overlooked
Tomorrow, I am going to launch a new campaign in my tank. It will take time and more patience than I have. It’s the Elegant Corals protocol (Google it, it’s on reef2reef and Facebook). I’m confident it works in the short term because it shifts the environment to favor autotrophic and heterotrophic bacteria and fills the environment with them so they can out complete. Reading the threads it looks like a lot of people have early success only to see the dinos or algea, or cyano resurge stronger than ever. Nature abhors a vacuum, so that is to be expected. The key is once you are winning, shift the environment again to favor what you don’t hate.
I am really hoping to find that people lose because they quit when they appear to win and the dinos appear to be gone rather than recognizing that the dinos are never (never) really gone and they need to now cultivate something beneficial to take their place and keep them in check. That’s phase 2 of the Elegant Corals protocol where you are deliberately cultivating good heterotrophic and autotrophic bacteria in sufficient numbers to outcompete the dinos and hold them in check. Look it up. From the forums and the Facebook support group it seems few know about Phaes 2. I selfishly hope that’s true. If so, it gives me hope for a big win.
Remember 1-5 above and good luck to us all!