I'm continually puzzled by high-priced aquarium LEDs that put out lower PAR than a standard black box. I totally get that spectrum matters too, but I don't see anything terribly unusual here either (mix of blues and whites).
What am I missing? This question applies to more than this specific light, although this is a good example of it.
Are there any black boxes that actually compete with the premium lighting options?
As you mentioned, spectrum matters, and I don't think that's something to just be glossed over. Also Red Sea (and other similar light manufacturers) offers additional attributes which are genuinely valuable:
1. implied reliability from a reputable manufacturer,
2. customer service if something does go wrong with the light or you need assistance with troubleshooting,
3. attractive form of the lighting unit as well as the subjectively more appealing lighting qualities (shimmer, etc.)
4. integrated wi-fi with a dedicated mobile app
5. guidance from the company and industry on how to actually implement the light successfully
6. on/off, ramp up/down, and cycle programming
I'm just getting into this hobby so my insights may be lacking, but I've done a bunch of research and it seems the value premium lighting offers can absolutely be worth the investment for many in the hobby. With that said, I do admit that black boxes can "get the job done".
Premium lighting does not seem to be a requirement, but it does certainly add incremental value beyond the most basic options.