Setting up sump in a (Canadian) garage

  • Thread starter Thread starter Bitflip
  • Start date Start date
  • Tagged users Tagged users None

Bitflip

Community Member
View Badges
Joined
Nov 7, 2022
Messages
38
Reaction score
24
Location
Canada
What state or country do you live in
Canada
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
Hello,

I'm looking at setting up a 100-150 gallon display in my living room on a wall where my garage is on the other side, it lands exactly next to a large tub and my RO system. To make maintenance easy I'm considering running the plumbing through the wall and put the sump in the garage.

I'm in Canada, the garage is heated to about 40F (5C) and during the summer it gets to about 77F (25C). I could put some insulation around the sump but likely not above the top. My main concern is my garage does not have any air circulation, in the winter if would bring sub-zero air in, additionally there could be some humidity, but I do have a air dehumidifier, which send air water down the drain.

We don't park car in the garage, I also don't play with nasty chemical/paint either. I start the snowblower once in a while, but can vent by leaving the garage door open longer.

Does a sump, consume lots of oxygen (is lack of airflow a big concern)? Any other elements I should consider?

Having the tank out of the living would make maintenance a breeze... Thanks!
 
Does a sump, consume lots of oxygen (is lack of airflow a big concern)? Any other elements I should consider?
In a (presumably) two car garage, you’ve got several thousand cubic feet of air! I assume you’ll be going in there at least once a week? If so, stagnant air shouldn’t be a substantial issue!


I could put some insulation around the sump but likely not above the top.
the insulation is going to be a must… 40F is going to be challenging to combat…

I’m already imagining a walk in closet for the sump/RODI mixing station which is heavily insulated!

Here’s my thinking:

— you’ll be running a skimmer in this sump, correct?

— if so, it will likely be consuming roughly 250gph of air, or around 30ft3/hour!

— you cannot realistically be pumping that much 40F (cold) air into your system’s water without problems…

— so, why don’t you plumb your skimmer’s air inlet to pull air from inside the house, which then vents inside the insulated walk-in closet… this will create positive air pressure in the closet… a passive air vent between closet and living space would provide the positive pressure with a place to go!

Essentially, I’m proposing sharing air between a heavily insulated walk-in sump closet in the garage, and the room the display tank lives in!
 
In a (presumably) two car garage, you’ve got several thousand cubic feet of air! I assume you’ll be going in there at least once a week? If so, stagnant air shouldn’t be a substantial issue!



the insulation is going to be a must… 40F is going to be challenging to combat…

I’m already imagining a walk in closet for the sump/RODI mixing station which is heavily insulated!

Here’s my thinking:

— you’ll be running a skimmer in this sump, correct?

— if so, it will likely be consuming roughly 250gph of air, or around 30ft3/hour!

— you cannot realistically be pumping that much 40F (cold) air into your system’s water without problems…

— so, why don’t you plumb your skimmer’s air inlet to pull air from inside the house, which then vents inside the insulated walk-in closet… this will create positive air pressure in the closet… a passive air vent between closet and living space would provide the positive pressure with a place to go!

Essentially, I’m proposing sharing air between a heavily insulated walk-in sump closet in the garage, and the room the display tank lives in!
Thanks! That good insight! I don't currently have a skimmer so I don't think of it. Do all skimmer have a air inlet which can be connected to a hose?

I can also heat up the garage to a warmer temperatures to mitigate problem. Currently I heat it to prevent the water pipe from freezing.
 
Do all skimmer have an air inlet which can be connected to a hose?
Typically, yes! At least every skimmer I’ve ever worked with! — it should be noted that the diameter of the tubing may need to be increased by one size for longer plumbing runs of remote skimmer air intake tubing! (To mitigate frictional flow loss and maintain factory performance!)

I can also heat up the garage to a warmer temperatures to mitigate problem. Currently I heat it to prevent the water pipe from freezing
This might crank up your heating bill unnecessarily high; garage doors are notoriously poorly insulated!

I think the long term heating cost savings would offset the initial cost of building a insulated sump closet in a corner/along a wall!

— though, if you also want to turn the garage into a game room/etc… the whole garage winter heating bill could be justified! It’s all a matter of your end goals, really!

(Last thought, it’s worth considering heating system malfunction/failure… if the full garage is heated; this could potentially lead to a system crash during heater failure!)
 
Thanks! That good insight! I don't currently have a skimmer so I don't think of it. Do all skimmer have a air inlet which can be connected to a hose?

I can also heat up the garage to a warmer temperatures to mitigate problem. Currently I heat it to prevent the water pipe from freezing.
Assuming all the other garage walls are insulated, you could also frame out the actual garage door section with wall and exterior door to turn it into a conditioned space.
 
Almost a year later; did you end up doing your garage sump? If so, any lessons?
 
Also, laying landmines around garage to ensure bears cannot approach it seems to be the smartest option. Did you follow this SMART IDEA?
 
Almost a year later; did you end up doing your garage sump? If so, any lessons?

Hello!

Sorry for the late response. I did go ahead with a sump in my garage. I would say if someone has the option they should very seriously consider it.

Pro:
Keep the mess outside the house!
- mixing salt, water change
- give you extra space!
- keep the moisture outside the stand
- roller mat stinks, keep the smell outside the house
- I already had a tub and Rodi there

Cons:
If you use your garage for cars, painting maybe reconsider it. My car are electric so it's fine!
Winter require more heater. I was fine with 3x 250w (700w) total. I had a few days with all 3 running.
Plumbing is more complex, I had a sound of running water but that seems to have gone away with the biofilm.
My return pump are also under powered. There is too much head pressure for the extra height and 1/2in tubing.

Overall:
I insulated the 4 sides and bottom using R20 insulation. My garage is heated so it's a none issue, I keep the garage around 5C, heaters will do the rest.

In the summer the garage is warmer than the house (AC). Which means the heaters rarely kick on. There are likely some savings here to make up a bit for the winter.

Garage also has less CO2 than the house when 4 people are home.

Finally for me, the space, keeping the mess and smell away are huge plus.
1150.jpg


PXL_20260907_225726147.jpg
 
Also, laying landmines around garage to ensure bears cannot approach it seems to be the smartest option. Did you follow this SMART IDEA?
Any other day I would have told you we don't have bears in the city. But yesterday my camera caught one for the first time is 20 years 😲
 

TOP 10 Trending Threads

HOW WOULD YOU FEEL ABOUT RECEIVING A FISH OR CORAL AS A HOLIDAY GIFT?

  • I’d love one, as long as it’s a species I chose

    Votes: 26 24.5%
  • I’d trust someone who knows my tank to choose

    Votes: 9 8.5%
  • I’d rather get a gift card and pick it myself

    Votes: 43 40.6%
  • I’d prefer gear or supplies instead

    Votes: 2 1.9%
  • Please don’t surprise me with livestock

    Votes: 26 24.5%
  • Other (Post in the comments)

    Votes: 0 0.0%
Back
Top
Home
Post thread…
Market
What's new