Starfish?

[Be102]

This might be completely nothing and just a random starfish.. But I just recently saw this guy despite never seeing before. Only new addition to tank in months was a carpet anemone that was dipped. Any ideas?

 

[Reefhabit]

Its an Asterina Star. They just about appear in every reeftank. I've never had issue with them bothering any of my corals but I have seen then eat unhealthy or dying zoas and star polyps. They can get introduced from just the liverock or livesand.

 

[Diesel]

You dipped a Carpet nem?!?!?!
Can I ask what you dipped it in and how long?

 

[Be102]

Its an Asterina Star. They just about appear in every reeftank. I've never had issue with them bothering any of my corals but I have seen then eat unhealthy or dying zoas and star polyps. They can get introduced from just the liverock or livesand.

Thank you!

 

[Be102]

You dipped a Carpet nem?!?!?!
Can I ask what you dipped it in and how long?

Yes actually. I wasn't really sure if I could or could not.. so I just went for it cause It was my first one and didn't know any better. It didn't seem to really mind the dip honestly rather than him detaching from the littler rock he came with and tried attaching to the bottom of the bucket through the drip acclimation. I dipped it in CoralRx for about maybe 5-10 minutes?

 

[Diesel]

Yes actually. I wasn't really sure if I could or could not.. so I just went for it cause It was my first one and didn't know any better. It didn't seem to really mind the dip honestly rather than him detaching from the littler rock he came with and tried attaching to the bottom of the bucket through the drip acclimation. I dipped it in CoralRx for about maybe 5-10 minutes?

Well, you're a lucky guy.
A anemone is a invert and not considered a coral.
Corals are ok to dip but inverts have a nerve system that will be damaged by the iodine in the dips and can be deadly.
Maybe you're lucky and eased of the total amount you had to use or the time frame, any ways never do it again.
Next time use a fresh water dip and QT for a week to be safe to remove parasites and bacteria.
A anemone never carries any pest as these will be stung and would not survive long term.

 

[Reefhabit]

Well, you're a lucky guy.
A anemone is a invert and not considered a coral.
Corals are ok to dip but inverts have a nerve system that will be damaged by the iodine in the dips and can be deadly.
Maybe you're lucky and eased of the total amount you had to use or the time frame, any ways never do it again.
Next time use a fresh water dip and QT for a week to be safe to remove parasites and bacteria.
A anemone never carries any pest as these will be stung and would not survive long term.

Aren't they all in the class Anthozoa which are all inverts? Ive never dipped healthy anemones before but I always dip ricordeas and other mushrooms using Melafix.

 

[Diesel]

Aren't they all in the class Anthozoa which are all inverts? Ive never dipped healthy anemones before but I always dip ricordeas and other mushrooms using Melafix.

Correct but over the years and that been a lot I have never heard that some one killed a mushroom or ricordia when dipped.
And yes IMO they don't need to be dipped either.
Now Anemones is a different story, ppl still dip their $800 carpet and find it weird that within 24 hrs it rolls over and melts away......... you wonder :(

 

[Be102]

Well, you're a lucky guy.
A anemone is a invert and not considered a coral.
Corals are ok to dip but inverts have a nerve system that will be damaged by the iodine in the dips and can be deadly.
Maybe you're lucky and eased of the total amount you had to use or the time frame, any ways never do it again.
Next time use a fresh water dip and QT for a week to be safe to remove parasites and bacteria.
A anemone never carries any pest as these will be stung and would not survive long term.

Thank you for this. Lesson learned! So happy it all worked out well. It came from Petco which I definitely did not trust to add into my tank just hoping for the best. Are freshwater dips for only anemones? I have a few corals coming in on Friday and was just planning on dipping them. I am one of the people who unfortunately does not have a quarantine tank set up just yet for my tank :/

 

[Reefhabit]

Thank you for this. Lesson learned! So happy it all worked out well. It came from Petco which I definitely did not trust to add into my tank just hoping for the best. Are freshwater dips for only anemones? I have a few corals coming in on Friday and was just planning on dipping them. I am one of the people who unfortunately does not have a quarantine tank set up just yet for my tank :/

Its always a good idea to dip new corals. If your worried about introducing unwanted critters I find that melafix works best for me. If you're worried about disease or infection an iodine based dip will work fine but I only use melafix these days and it works great.

 

[Diesel]

Thank you for this. Lesson learned! So happy it all worked out well. It came from Petco which I definitely did not trust to add into my tank just hoping for the best. Are freshwater dips for only anemones? I have a few corals coming in on Friday and was just planning on dipping them. I am one of the people who unfortunately does not have a quarantine tank set up just yet for my tank :/

No corals ain't good on fresh water.
Corals need to be dipped and QT as if you dip the only thing you kill is the pest on the corals, the eggs will survive and will end up as pest in your DT.
FYI, I use as 80% of the reef community Bayer to dip, its a liquid pest control meant for lawn and garden.
It's more effective than every other dip out there and one bottle last you almost a life time

 

[Be102]

No corals ain't good on fresh water.
Corals need to be dipped and QT as if you dip the only thing you kill is the pest on the corals, the eggs will survive and will end up as pest in your DT.
FYI, I use as 80% of the reef community Bayer to dip, its a liquid pest control meant for lawn and garden.
It's more effective than every other dip out there and one bottle last you almost a life time

How is this used? Is it something you use every time you add something new to the tank? Will it be safe for just corals or fish as well? Does it have difficult dosing methods?

 

[Be102]

Its always a good idea to dip new corals. If your worried about introducing unwanted critters I find that melafix works best for me. If you're worried about disease or infection an iodine based dip will work fine but I only use melafix these days and it works great.

Do you use Melafix on fish and inverts / corals? Do you do it every time you add something new?

 

[Diesel]

How is this used? Is it something you use every time you add something new to the tank? Will it be safe for just corals or fish as well? Does it have difficult dosing methods?

Let me find the thread on this Bayer.

 

[Diesel]

Do you use Melafix on fish and inverts / corals? Do you do it every time you add something new?

Use only on corals, not on fish or inverts.

 

[Diesel]

Here you go, this is one of many.

http://reef2reef.com/threads/bayer-insecticidal-coral-dip.244803/

You can do a search yourself if you use the search option on the top right side search box and enter "bayer dip"

 

[Be102]

Here you go, this is one of many.

http://reef2reef.com/threads/bayer-insecticidal-coral-dip.244803/

You can do a search yourself if you use the search option on the top right side search box and enter "bayer dip"

Thank you for this. Will make sure to read up on it and to ask any questions :rolleyes: Thanks for your help.