TRYING TO RAISE pH BY REDUCING CO2 FROM CALCIUM REACTOR

  • Thread starter Thread starter Dr. Jim
  • Start date Start date
  • Tagged users Tagged users None
(I deleted my statement by mistake)
Dr. Jim said:
I am thinking that the higher the alk of the effluent, the less volume will be needed. So, the less volume added, the less CO2 added.


I think I understand what you are saying.....I probably didn't word my statement properly. I believe you are considering a perfect chemical reaction with CO2 where there is no excess CO2 being introduced. If we can assume that the Deltec is introducing excess CO2, it is that excess CO2 that I am talking about and trying to reduce. So, if we can assume there is excess CO2 in the effluent, it would follow that the lower the volume introduced, the lower the amount of excess CO2 would be added.
Any CO2 dissolved in the effluent is already showing in its pH. Only undissolved bubbles wouldn’t register.

Less effluent can mean less CO2, but higher KH alone doesn’t mean less CO2 is reaching the tank. You would need higher KH at a higher effluent pH.
 
Last edited:
I have thought about this quite a bit since last week. I don't think that anything will matter with this design. It is the size of the co2 bubble and surface area contact/exposure that is the issue. If you can move less effluent through the reactor, then there is more contact time; probably a wash. You have to restrict co2 and not have free access to make it more efficient. Otherwise, the seawater will snatch up more co2 than what is needed to dissolve media.

As you know, I have never used this design, but isn't there a risk of ARM turning to mush with too slow of flow and that much access to co2? I have had ARM get mushy at much below 6.6, or so. I dunno.

How did your indoor co2 end up? I guess that it was fine since you are back to the CaRx?

In the end, this reactor is both reliable and easy, so probably reasonable that is is not efficient. Nobody gets all three in a choose-two triangle, right? My korallins where reliable and efficient, but not super easy until you learned how to tune them. Some setups are not any of these if they rely on a cheap/hobby pH controller since, while they are easy when starting, the probes drift and fail making them not easy, reliable or efficient over time.
I'm sorry if I made you lose sleep over this, jda. 😁 ...but thank you!
You mentioned bubble size a few times. The Deltec has a chamber of CO2 gas and water trickles thru media in this chamber, so there really aren't any bubbles. I think the main issue is having excess CO2 entering the tank.
I had a VarioS-4 skimmer pump kicking around so I put that in the sump (first compartment with the skimmer) so it is producing tons of bubbles and both it and the protein skimmer are drawing in outside air at around 1500L/Hr. I built a platform for the gallon of A.R.M. so it sits out of the water on a funnel. Tubing leads from the funnel into the Varios pump. This setup raised the pH by about 0.2. And, yes, I'm familiar with the mush that results from A.R.M. I'll see what happens.

CO2 Monitor: Outside--430; In aquarium room-- fluctuates, 460 -560.

I wouldn't say I'm "back" to the CaRx, I never really left it, just cut its production in half to reduce excess CO2 introduction and started 2-Part to make up for the lower alk and Ca. Plan was to try this first, then consider swapping media to Reborn to see if this might allow a lower volume of effluent (and therefore, less excess CO2).

BUT, all of this has come to a temporary standstill while I investigate a GHL pH probe and a digital pH meter that aren't agreeing with each other! They were agreeing with each other perfectly for months and were low at 7.6-7.9 (which prompted this thread), until I just recalibrated them. Now, they disagree by 0.5 pH and I have to figure out which is correct. It is possible that my pH is actually fine (according to a new GHL probe I got today), but this discussion on ridding excess CO2 from the Deltec has been helpful and interesting, so thank you all.

This all started because about 20 new SPS frags haven't budged in 8 months (since I moved) and I was thinking the low pH was the culprit. If it is not the pH, (which I will figure out after further trouble-shooting the probe and meter), I still need to figure out the cause(s) for the slow SPS growth and will post elsewhere. (Thoughts: toxins from tons of sponges; LED's....I've always been a halide guy but can't get good halides anymore!)
 
All of this mess is why I can never bring myself to set one up. I understand how they work, but don’t trust one to work the way I want it to, without the pitfalls of one design or another.

But, I get it too. Some people wouldn’t eat a hot dog if they knew how they were made, I know how they are made and still eat them. So maybe one day I will migrate to CARX.
 
All of this mess is why I can never bring myself to set one up. I understand how they work, but don’t trust one to work the way I want it to, without the pitfalls of one design or another.
Well, if you get to a point where you are adding tons of alk and Ca which can get expensive, the concept of a CaRx makes sense. But, all the conventional ones (GEO) I used over the past 20+ years were a pain. Adjusting a bubble counter, effluent, and going thru pH probes was a lot of work as I think you are alluding to. If it turns out that I determine the excess CO2 with the Deltec is not causing a problem, then I would say the Deltec is a game changer! Plug and play. Once one gets thru the initial learning curve, you just increase or decrease the L/day to suit your alk requirement. The design is ingenious! The big question becomes: Is the excess CO2 -- pH lowering effect -- really that big of a problem.
That's what I'm working on now. If I determine my new GHL probe is accurate, then my pH is fine after all. The new probe measured 8.42 today, 3 hrs before lights out. But, again, the digital handheld disagrees (7.9) so I have to figure out which is correct.
 
You mentioned bubble size a few times. The Deltec has a chamber of CO2 gas and water trickles thru media in this chamber, so there really aren't any bubbles. I think the main issue is having excess CO2 entering the tank.

There is a bubble of co2 in the reactor that is maintained by the float valve. That is what I mean by a bubble. The size (surface area), specifically, where it appears big enough to never be limiting when it needs to limit to be efficient.

Segal's Law of pH equipment really does suck!

Household co2 under 600 is going to be fine. Over 800 and the tank pH can really start to drop fast. There are people reading this who never open a window and have a new, tight home whose indoor co2 can be 1500+.

I used a pro grade hand held pH pen/meter. They seem to be more reliable over the long haul than anything that was continuously in the tank. I got one one that truly was used in labs (not a hobby grade sold as lab grade like in the aquarium hobby). Could have sent a few more kids to college with all of the pH probes and meters and controllers that I tried to get to work in this hobby before I swore them off for good. I cannot recommend a good handheld unit that a pro would use, but they are expensive.

I grew acropora and clams out of the tank with night time pH around 7.8 and day time at 8.0. I got better growth once we moved to Colorado and could keep the windows open and was 8.1 to 8.4, but it was not a ton more. I did max out every other variable with waste products near NSW levels (po4 and no3), lot of available building blocks (aminos, traces, N, P, etc.) through heavy fish feeding and metal halides. I always did run a fuge that grew chaeto which I had to purge about every month to six weeks (dosed a lot of iron). Radium still makes MH bulbs and if you need m80 ballasts, PM me since I have thirty of forty of them still.

All of this mess is why I can never bring myself to set one up. I understand how they work, but don’t trust one to work the way I want it to, without the pitfalls of one design or another.

But, I get it too. Some people wouldn’t eat a hot dog if they knew how they were made, I know how they are made and still eat them. So maybe one day I will migrate to CARX.

Surprised that never had one in all the years. They take a bit of a learning curve, but once you figure out how to balance a few variables, they are super easy, rock solid, safe and easy. Too many screw it up trying to use a pH monitor and probe when you don't need one and should not even go down that road. A simple and cheap Tunze regulator and a reactor with a good, solid pump (like Eheim) and it can run untouched save for once or twice a year and can tell if they are working right with a glance at the bubble window and effluent rate. Never have to test tank pH and only have gone a few years only testing tank alk. Stick with the mechanical stuff (no probes) and it does not fail. Nothing could be easier or more reliable, IMO. Never heard of a CaRx crashing a tank, but kalk and 2 part has - even if something fails, it is too slow to do any damage unless you just never check.
 
My other objection is the thumb screws or other cave man era access. Why not simple cam and groove clamps, cammed bolts or some other one step lid?

One day maybe, but it may mean building my own.
 
Last edited:
Passing the effluent over more media will allow you to get the most out of the CO2 you are adding, but it does not eliminate the pH reducing effect of the CO2 that is added.

Sending it through a skimmer may or may not allow more CO2 to blow off. Its now a high alk fluid so holds more CO2.
Suggest to add a second chamber (with media) or use a bigger chamber. It will help.
 

TOP 10 Trending Threads

HOW WOULD YOU FEEL ABOUT RECEIVING A FISH OR CORAL AS A HOLIDAY GIFT?

  • I’d love one, as long as it’s a species I chose

    Votes: 19 28.4%
  • I’d trust someone who knows my tank to choose

    Votes: 2 3.0%
  • I’d rather get a gift card and pick it myself

    Votes: 25 37.3%
  • I’d prefer gear or supplies instead

    Votes: 2 3.0%
  • Please don’t surprise me with livestock

    Votes: 19 28.4%
  • Other (Post in the comments)

    Votes: 0 0.0%
Back
Top
Home
Post thread…
Market
What's new