What is causing my corals to not grow?!

Is there a way to lower Magnesium ? Other than just stopping putting it in? Mine was extremely high for no reason I am aware of . I was using Fritz high Alk salt

Water changes are the only way aside from lowering salinity, though testing is not very accurate and it may not be as high as you think.
 
I was also going to ask about carbon. Reason being is I recently went through something similar, corals really struggling, almost dying (even pulsing xenia totally shrunk). Tested every possible water parameter and all looked good. I came to realize it was toxins in the water coming from dino's. As soon as I upped my carbon and started changing it every few days, I noticed instant rebound in the corals since the carbon was soaking up the toxins. That gave me some breathing room to deal with the dino's. After about 2 weeks I won the battle with the dinos and everything is super happy now. Point of all this... try increasing your carbon amount and changing it frequently. See if that helps. If it does, then you definitely have something toxic making its way into your system, either from some pest or by other means TBD.
 
I was also going to ask about carbon. Reason being is I recently went through something similar, corals really struggling, almost dying (even pulsing xenia totally shrunk). Tested every possible water parameter and all looked good. I came to realize it was toxins in the water coming from dino's. As soon as I upped my carbon and started changing it every few days, I noticed instant rebound in the corals since the carbon was soaking up the toxins. That gave me some breathing room to deal with the dino's. After about 2 weeks I won the battle with the dinos and everything is super happy now. Point of all this... try increasing your carbon amount and changing it frequently. See if that helps. If it does, then you definitely have something toxic making its way into your system, either from some pest or by other means TBD.
I agree. And to add to that leathers often excrete toxins that can irritate and stunt other corals as well. I’ve found carbon is pretty important particularly in a system with leathers.
Also op needs to bring that alk down as well. Any time I’ve had alk that high my corals were less than happy.
 
Does polyp labs sell a different kind of carbon?
I watched the video about their product. They have a much more refined manufacturing process blasting with steam at 1,000 degrees resulting in a much higher absorption adsorption area on theirs , compared to others who don't state any numbers as to that just claims
 
WC with salts that not contain raised levels of Mg Fritz High Alk seems to target higher concentrations.

I will correct my post #33 with the note that is important that no salt with elevated Ca, Mg or alkalinity (dKH) is used. Red Sea blue bucket it one of these salts that is good to use in a "reset"- There is others but it is important is that they create natural values

Sincerely Lasse
Thank You on a different note I wanted to tell you about a notification which you may know about regarding Hanna regent H177425 . There is a recall . If yours was bought between April 1 26 - May 26 26 Lot # 1352 - 1250 return it . It also says if yours is white its ok if grey gray do not
 
My corals actually thrive at the moment. I think I am in the sweet spot. I have learned the basics and not over complicate it. I did buy top end lights and keep water parameters stable. My biggest issue now is coral warfare. I place coral too close not allowing enough space for growth and sweeping tentacles.
 
23578.jpg

Here are my parameters.

I don't know why but my corals will not grow whag so ever. I hit a point where NOTHING is growing and things are even dying.

Even easy corals like pulsing xenia, waving hand xenia, torches, kenya tree, leathers, zoas, and torches won't grow! The only thing that actually is growing well is green hair mushroom.

My candy canes are losing tissue and my leathers are starting to fall apart.

I am so desperate to fix this. Even my macro algae won't grow!!!
1.0 is very high phosphates. What is your nitrate level
 
I strongly advice you to stop dosing kh, mag and Ca. My tank respond very badly to high alk and probably yours too.

If you dose organic carbon stop that too. And remove the gfo and macro algae in the sump! All of that is creating a very stressful environment for your corals. Keep it simple. Add things slowly if needed later.

Macro algae may be consuming all available nitrogen.

Many people have lost coral just by adding GFO. And this is just one of the things you’re doing.

after removing all mentioned above, just do water changes …
 
I watched the video about their product. They have a much more refined manufacturing process blasting with steam at 1,000 degrees resulting in a much higher absorption adsorption area on theirs , compared to others who don't state any numbers as to that just claims
The problem with absorption is that the area there it happens need to be free from too much bacterial film. I get much more active time with my GFO after that I add filter wadding before my GFO and change the flow direction in the reactor from bottom to top to top to bottom. This is also the reason why I think that a bag with GFO in the sump does not work very well if you do not take up and rinse it every day.

My experiment with adding fast organic carbon (ethanol) to my GFO reactor (see my build thread) also shows that it exacerbates the problem of bacterial film growing on the medium.

Sincerely Lasse
 
Last edited:
Thanks I plan to and have run it exclusively in my Fluval Canister filter which has 3 layers of foam one of which is very dense . To clean it every day would be a real chore . How long would you run that before cleaning ?

Regards : Wally
 
The problem with absorption is that the area there it happens need to be free from too much bacterial film. I get much more active time with my GFO after that I add filter wadding before my GFO and change the flow direction in the reactor from bottom to top to top to bottom. This is also the reason why I think that a bag with GFO in the sump does not work very well if you do not take up and rinse it every day.

My experiment with adding fast organic carbon (ethanol) to my GFO reactor (see my build thread) also shows that it exacerbates the problem of bacterial film growing on the medium.

Sincerely Lasse
On a different note did you read my response regarding Hana media ?
 
I strongly advice you to stop dosing kh, mag and Ca. My tank respond very badly to high alk and probably yours too.

If you dose organic carbon stop that too. And remove the gfo and macro algae in the sump! All of that is creating a very stressful environment for your corals. Keep it simple. Add things slowly if needed later.

Macro algae may be consuming all available nitrogen.

Many people have lost coral just by adding GFO. And this is just one of the things you’re doing.

after removing all mentioned above, just do water changes …
I appreciate your advice . Now I am Completely Torn two people who's experience and Education was focused entirely on Marine Biology and Coral health one has a masters the other a PHD . both said the same as you. Another Member encouraged me to read an article ( actually a video ) defending Carbons use . Lasse uses it as well No insult but It is always a stickler with me not knowing the background of people here . You write as though you have education in the field but you don't state it. I wish people would because I don't know if peoples statements are Opinion Experience or from Education / Research. Would you mind telling me which? I already keep track of people who I like to listen to and Respect their opinion regardless of the situation . I would not mind adding you to that list
 
I appreciate your advice . Now I am Completely Torn two people who's experience and Education was focused entirely on Marine Biology and Coral health one has a masters the other a PHD . both said the same as you. Another Member encouraged me to read an article ( actually a video ) defending Carbons use . Lasse uses it as well No insult but It is always a stickler with me not knowing the background of people here . You write as though you have education in the field but you don't state it. I wish people would because I don't know if peoples statements are Opinion Experience or from Education / Research. Would you mind telling me which? I already keep track of people who I like to listen to and Respect their opinion regardless of the situation . I would not mind adding you to that list
Also I dont know what you mean by " Dosing " Carbon do you mean as in Vodka type of thing? I am talking about just media for filtration ie Removing negative chemicals
 
23578.jpg

Here are my parameters.

I don't know why but my corals will not grow whag so ever. I hit a point where NOTHING is growing and things are even dying.

Even easy corals like pulsing xenia, waving hand xenia, torches, kenya tree, leathers, zoas, and torches won't grow! The only thing that actually is growing well is green hair mushroom.

My candy canes are losing tissue and my leathers are starting to fall apart.

I am so desperate to fix this. Even my macro algae won't grow!!!
I feel that pain. My numbers are solid but I only have two visibly growing,my Alveapora and my Leather Toadstool. I have a 32 Gallon BioCube and I'm also certain my stock lighting is part of the problem. My tank is also only 8 months old.
 

TOP 10 Trending Threads

WHAT KIND OF REEFING DEAL ARE YOU HOPING TO PICK UP THIS BLACK FRIDAY?

  • A whole new aquarium or complete system

    Votes: 3 13.0%
  • Lighting, pumps, or other major equipment

    Votes: 3 13.0%
  • Controllers, testing, dosing, or automation gear

    Votes: 2 8.7%
  • Dry goods and restocks, like salt, media, or food

    Votes: 2 8.7%
  • Corals! Must...Have...CORALS!!!

    Votes: 5 21.7%
  • Fish or other livestock

    Votes: 1 4.3%
  • Rock, sand, or other aquascaping supplies

    Votes: 1 4.3%
  • I’m browsing, but don’t have a specific target

    Votes: 4 17.4%
  • I’m not shopping for reef deals this year

    Votes: 1 4.3%
  • Other (Post in the comments)

    Votes: 1 4.3%
Back
Top
Home
Post thread…
Market
What's new