What is causing my corals to not grow?!

Also I dont know what you mean by " Dosing " Carbon dosing as in Vodka type of thing? I am talking about just media for filtration ie Removing negative chemicals
FWIW -
Organic carbon = vodka, sugar, vinegar and many other carbon compounds of organic origin.
Inorganic carbon = CO2, CO3, HCO3 and so on
Activated carbon = carbon in form of charcoal or similar carbonized products


I use organic carbon (in my case vodka) mostly for my denitrification process in my reverse flow DSB. I do not use activated carbon at all. No experiences with that at all.

Sincerely Lasse
 
On a different note did you read my response regarding Hana media ?
yes - and I will check my batches later on

Sincerely Lasse
 
This was right sfter water change. Here is the trend in my values. I just tested mag for the first time and i was dosing 3 part aquaforest 1+2+3+ ehich i stopped for a bit and did not see any difference. I started again and things seemed tk get worse. I am using IO salt and rught sfter a water change things look SOOO GOOD for a day or 2 before back to baseline.
Those Alk swings are fairly extreme. It’s been my experience that significant fluctuations in Alk and salinity are very problematic. I hope you figure out the problem. My only advice, if possible, see if you can maintain more consistent levels.
 
I feel that pain. My numbers are solid but I only have two visibly growing,my Alveapora and my Leather Toadstool. I have a 32 Gallon BioCube and I'm also certain my stock lighting is part of the problem. My tank is also only 8 months old.
Don't jump the gun . I thought had a lighting problem so upped it , and now have lost another while a different one is thriving even more
 
23578.jpg

Here are my parameters.

I don't know why but my corals will not grow whag so ever. I hit a point where NOTHING is growing and things are even dying.

Even easy corals like pulsing xenia, waving hand xenia, torches, kenya tree, leathers, zoas, and torches won't grow! The only thing that actually is growing well is green hair mushroom.

My candy canes are losing tissue and my leathers are starting to fall apart.

I am so desperate to fix this. Even my macro algae won't grow!!!
23578.jpg

Here are my parameters.

I don't know why but my corals will not grow whag so ever. I hit a point where NOTHING is growing and things are even dying.

Even easy corals like pulsing xenia, waving hand xenia, torches, kenya tree, leathers, zoas, and torches won't grow! The only thing that actually is growing well is green hair mushroom.

My candy canes are losing tissue and my leathers are starting to fall apart.

I am so desperate to fix this. Even my macro algae won't grow!!!
1st you need a nitrate reading 2nd your Alk is to high compared to PH at that level you should be around 8.2-8.3 your phosphate level could be fine depending on the nitrate level however you are at the very top of what phosphate should be wouldnt hurt to bring that down mag should be a lower around 1350-1450 also keep in mind higher Alk also requires higher nutrient.
 
Update for everyone: i replaced my carbon and stopped all dosing. I also added Phosguard and am doing a 5% water change daily (so far changed about 20 gallons). I looked at my tds meter on my RODI and it was saying 0 tds 1 and 0 tds 2. I looked that up and apparently thats impossible to i figured its not calibrated well. I borrowed a TDS meter (portable pen) and I am not 100% sure it is calibrated but it read my tap water to be 300 and my water after the RO was 170. After DI i got 17. I took apart my RO membrane and placed it back and my post RO numbers went down to 7!! My DI went down to 0 but after running my filter for a bit it went back up to 3 and im not sure why right now. I tested some filtered water (filled after recorded the 0 tds) and the TDS in the water can was about 200!! I have no idea why it' that high.
I will maybe take a water sample to my local fosh store to see if they can test my tds but what do you guys think? Could this be causing all the issues?
 
Update for everyone: i replaced my carbon and stopped all dosing. I also added Phosguard and am doing a 5% water change daily (so far changed about 20 gallons). I looked at my tds meter on my RODI and it was saying 0 tds 1 and 0 tds 2. I looked that up and apparently thats impossible to i figured its not calibrated well. I borrowed a TDS meter (portable pen) and I am not 100% sure it is calibrated but it read my tap water to be 300 and my water after the RO was 170. After DI i got 17. I took apart my RO membrane and placed it back and my post RO numbers went down to 7!! My DI went down to 0 but after running my filter for a bit it went back up to 3 and im not sure why right now. I tested some filtered water (filled after recorded the 0 tds) and the TDS in the water can was about 200!! I have no idea why it' that high.
I will maybe take a water sample to my local fosh store to see if they can test my tds but what do you guys think? Could this be causing all the issues?
No Idea . Is your meter connected properly . Mine has never acted that way . Assuming you have changed your DI media . I would buy a new inline meter
 
Please post nitrates and phosphate levels. Also I agree with bringing alk down to 8 and mg to 1350. With your current levels you’re running a very high level and I’ve never had good luck up that high.
I am in agreement here. I think your Alk and Mag are too high, especially for what you are currently keeping, which does not require much of those elements.

Also, I would be curious to see what your nitrates are in relation to your phosphates. I have had phosphates of .10 before with nitrates reading zero, and all my corals either bleached or did not grow until I fixed my nitrate to between 5-10.

Also, with most of your corals being softies, sometimes they can create slime warfare and disturb the whole tank. When I started in the hobby back in the 90s, this was the only coral available to keep at the time. Whenever I had this problem with sofies, I would run a high-quality carbon for a few hrs to a day to clean up the water colony.
 
No Idea . Is your meter connected properly . Mine has never acted that way . Assuming you have changed your DI media . I would buy a new inline meter
It is connected right but it probably need to be calibrated!
 
I appreciate your advice . Now I am Completely Torn two people who's experience and Education was focused entirely on Marine Biology and Coral health one has a masters the other a PHD . both said the same as you. Another Member encouraged me to read an article ( actually a video ) defending Carbons use . Lasse uses it as well No insult but It is always a stickler with me not knowing the background of people here . You write as though you have education in the field but you don't state it. I wish people would because I don't know if peoples statements are Opinion Experience or from Education / Research. Would you mind telling me which? I already keep track of people who I like to listen to and Respect their opinion regardless of the situation . I would not mind adding you to that list
Hello! My background is not on science. My advice to you is based on 25 years of reefing experience. I'm kind of stubborn and committed the same mistakes more than once to prove to myself what the cause was.

I added GFO to reduce PO4 more than once and all times coral died or remained closed for a long period; I increased KH believing that it would increase coral growth and experienced stressed corals; I added refugium to reduce NO3/ PO4 and had a tank crash.. I learned the hard way.

In fact, it happened recently with high KH. I was travelling and for some reason the KH consumption reduced and KH increase up to 9.5. I could only watch the KH slowly increase thru my Apex but do nothing as my dosing pumps are controlled via bluetooth only. I lost 2 SPS and others were either closed or not fully expanding polyps.

I resolved many issues with tanks in the past just by turning dosing pumps off or removing chemical media.

I'm not saying GFO, refugium, carbon dosing or GAC are not good. But it must be used with care and are not suit to every tank.

I had a softies tank in the past and it responded the best when I stopped adding stuff and just did water changes without bothering with test results. Corals will grow once they find stability.
 
Hello! My background is not on science. My advice to you is based on 25 years of reefing experience. I'm kind of stubborn and committed the same mistakes more than once to prove to myself what the cause was.

I added GFO to reduce PO4 more than once and all times coral died or remained closed for a long period; I increased KH believing that it would increase coral growth and experienced stressed corals; I added refugium to reduce NO3/ PO4 and had a tank crash.. I learned the hard way.

In fact, it happened recently with high KH. I was travelling and for some reason the KH consumption reduced and KH increase up to 9.5. I could only watch the KH slowly increase thru my Apex but do nothing as my dosing pumps are controlled via bluetooth only. I lost 2 SPS and others were either closed or not fully expanding polyps.

I resolved many issues with tanks in the past just by turning dosing pumps off or removing chemical media.

I'm not saying GFO, refugium, carbon dosing or GAC are not good. But it must be used with care and are not suit to every tank.

I had a softies tank in the past and it responded the best when I stopped adding stuff and just did water changes without bothering with test results. Corals will grow once they find stability.
Agreed. I prefer the natural way as much as possible and only use GFO and even carbon as a supportive process only when I am present so that I can control, as much as possible, the outcome. I am not suggesting this is the best approach, but after decades of mistakes, often repeated mistakes, I have found a combo of maintenance-free automation and hands-on husbandry that works for my situation.
 
Hello! My background is not on science. My advice to you is based on 25 years of reefing experience. I'm kind of stubborn and committed the same mistakes more than once to prove to myself what the cause was.

I added GFO to reduce PO4 more than once and all times coral died or remained closed for a long period; I increased KH believing that it would increase coral growth and experienced stressed corals; I added refugium to reduce NO3/ PO4 and had a tank crash.. I learned the hard way.

In fact, it happened recently with high KH. I was travelling and for some reason the KH consumption reduced and KH increase up to 9.5. I could only watch the KH slowly increase thru my Apex but do nothing as my dosing pumps are controlled via bluetooth only. I lost 2 SPS and others were either closed or not fully expanding polyps.

I resolved many issues with tanks in the past just by turning dosing pumps off or removing chemical media.

I'm not saying GFO, refugium, carbon dosing or GAC are not good. But it must be used with care and are not suit to every tank.

I had a softies tank in the past and it responded the best when I stopped adding stuff and just did water changes without bothering with test results. Corals will grow once they find stability.
Unlike you I have approached it with physical changes . I adjusted lighting and flow with success. I removed all the media as requested , with no results . I now ,and I forget who actually made me aware of this brought to my attention that not all carbon is created equal. I bought some but have yet to try it . It is made by Polyp lab
 
Agreed. I prefer the natural way as much as possible and only use GFO and even carbon as a supportive process only when I am present so that I can control, as much as possible, the outcome. I am not suggesting this is the best approach, but after decades of mistakes, often repeated mistakes, I have found a combo of maintenance-free automation and hands-on husbandry that works for my situation.

It's curious that folks don't think of things like lanthanum or GFO and supplementing as natural, when, in fact, there is almost no process that we use that is not happening in the ocean. :)
 
It's curious that folks don't think of things like lanthanum or GFO and supplementing as natural, when, in fact, there is almost no process that we use that is not happening in the ocean. :)
So I did a little searching do you mean Lanthanum Chloride ? Looks like a very extreme measure to take right ? or wrong ?
 
I got 1500 on a Salifert test
1500 actually isn't as terrible as you think it is. What is your bio look like as far as corals? Are you running a true mixed Reef with a mixture or does it favor one type of coral over another such as SPS dominant LPS dominant soft Coral dominant? I slightly overdosed a few days ago and my magnesium hit 1500 and without any kind of water change or additional interference for me it was back down to 1440 within a week. My tank consumes 5.625 PPM calcium daily and about 0.79 dkh daily. With all that being said if you don't have much in the way of SPS or LPS then I agree with others about backing off of alkalinity supplementation. Now on the other hand if you have a mature Reef filled with a variety of corals then alkalinity and calcium supplementation can become mandatory. Feel free to @ me any time. Here's a screenshot of my Facebook, if you want send me a friend request. Really same can be said about anyone from this group just mentioned Reef to Reef in your request that way I don't spam you and block LOL



Screenshot_20260726_113530_Facebook.jpg

 
So I did a little searching do you mean Lanthanum Chloride ? Looks like a very extreme measure to take right ? or wrong ?
I'm not sure if I'd consider it anymore extreme than other measures. It has the same basic function - bind phosphates for easier removal. It can potentially be dangerous to the tank inhabitants if dosed incorrectly but so can most of what we dose to our tanks.
 
1500 actually isn't as terrible as you think it is. What is your bio look like as far as corals? Are you running a true mixed Reef with a mixture or does it favor one type of coral over another such as SPS dominant LPS dominant soft Coral dominant? I slightly overdosed a few days ago and my magnesium hit 1500 and without any kind of water change or additional interference for me it was back down to 1440 within a week. My tank consumes 5.625 PPM calcium daily and about 0.79 dkh daily. With all that being said if you don't have much in the way of SPS or LPS then I agree with others about backing off of alkalinity supplementation. Now on the other hand if you have a mature Reef filled with a variety of corals then alkalinity and calcium supplementation can become mandatory. Feel free to @ me any time. Here's a screenshot of my Facebook, if you want send me a friend request. Really same can be said about anyone from this group just mentioned Reef to Reef in your request that way I don't spam you and block LOL



Screenshot_20260726_113530_Facebook.jpg

Thank you for the reply and offer I had a mixture but keep losing them some are doing well others ae not. I use high alk salt made by Fritz . I tried a box of lower alk so about 8 water changes done weekly. but did not see any difference. I am adding , and setting my lights at various levels slowly and observing . I have not had a significant change yet. I am not on facebook but will contact you .
 
1500 actually isn't as terrible as you think it is. What is your bio look like as far as corals? Are you running a true mixed Reef with a mixture or does it favor one type of coral over another such as SPS dominant LPS dominant soft Coral dominant? I slightly overdosed a few days ago and my magnesium hit 1500 and without any kind of water change or additional interference for me it was back down to 1440 within a week. My tank consumes 5.625 PPM calcium daily and about 0.79 dkh daily. With all that being said if you don't have much in the way of SPS or LPS then I agree with others about backing off of alkalinity supplementation. Now on the other hand if you have a mature Reef filled with a variety of corals then alkalinity and calcium supplementation can become mandatory. Feel free to @ me any time. Here's a screenshot of my Facebook, if you want send me a friend request. Really same can be said about anyone from this group just mentioned Reef to Reef in your request that way I don't spam you and block LOL



Screenshot_20260726_113530_Facebook.jpg

when are you marrying Lindsay?
 

TOP 10 Trending Threads

HOW WOULD YOU FEEL ABOUT RECEIVING A FISH OR CORAL AS A HOLIDAY GIFT?

  • I’d love one, as long as it’s a species I chose

    Votes: 18 29.5%
  • I’d trust someone who knows my tank to choose

    Votes: 2 3.3%
  • I’d rather get a gift card and pick it myself

    Votes: 23 37.7%
  • I’d prefer gear or supplies instead

    Votes: 1 1.6%
  • Please don’t surprise me with livestock

    Votes: 17 27.9%
  • Other (Post in the comments)

    Votes: 0 0.0%
Back
Top
Home
Post thread…
Market
What's new