Its seems youre very pro live rock and pests looking at your other posts and see them as part of the ecosystem. For the most part id agree with you, my 15+year old 265g has aiptasia, bubble algae, invasive palys, and more. To be honest none of them have kept the reef from thriving. But you know what will? Nudibranchs, flatworms, bugs, etc. They will decimate colonies no matter what fish and inverts you have that eat pests. Ive dealt with montipora eating nudis, and ever since then everythings been quarantined. Losing all my 5-8 year old monti colonies one after another is quite painful and not something i want to go through again.
Live rock certainly makes things easier on start up and establishes a health biome very fast. I am by no means saying it doesnt work, but i certainly dont want to embrace any pests coming in. Ive setup tanks both with live rock and dry and both ways can be equally successful but dry does take more effort.
I believe most of the failures from new hobbyists come from rushing into things. Even with live rock if you are inexperienced you will most likely have difficultly keeping a thriving reef right off the bat. These hobbyists spend a ton of money of what their lfs tells them to, do everything theyre supposed to but throw coral and fish in immediately. Then when discouraged by the death of their new live stock thats usually when they come in here for help and saying this hobby is hard. And i would agree, compared to keeping other animals reefing is quite difficult.