Zoa ID/ Agave ir not?

[Laker32]

I picked this paly up in a trade without seeing it first and I was told it was an Agave. It doesn't have the distinctive neon eye that all PE polyps have. What is this?

 

[Norcalreefer]

can you get a better pic? Does not look like it to me, but maybe it's just not colored up yet?

 

[TulsaTye]

Sorry, but not an Agave!

 

[ZoaCollector]

That could possibly be Agave. It looks like it needs some coloring up. Give it some time atleast it looks healthy


Sent Via the R2R Forum APP

 

[Laker32]

This originally came from a reputable seller who has a colony of Agaves. It's not the greatest pick, but it either has the neon eye or it doesn't. It may need to color up a bit, but I don't see the eye coming back?

 

[11purewater]

Does it have the watermelon pattern underneath?

 

[secretreefer]

has the right patterning and black oral disk. Looks like one to me from what i can see.

 

[Tenor]

has the right patterning and black oral disk. Looks like one to me from what i can see.

+1 need color up

 

[Laker32]

This guy that I traded had 2 polyps and it looks like he gave me the one he didn't want. He sent me a bad pic of the other polyp that he is going to switch out with me and the neon eye is glowing. Yes it has the watermelon markings. I guess there are PE polyps that loose there eye, or never had it. Thanks for all the replys.

 

[joshporksandwich]

Looks like one to me.