It’s a shame if this has been buried as a very quick google search l, and so many multi-chips are now available covering virtually every wavelength from 330nm right up to 1050nm and there completely customizable as well from certain manufacturers... way beyond my diy skills but really interested to learn more
WELL while typing my soapbox below jda posted and is 100% correct (well bit less, being nice..;)).. See below..
One correction though is modern diodes are a) now more efficient (less heat)
and b)more heat resistant on chip BUT goes to the "quality" chip thing..
He's right that.. well starting w/ visible spectrum some of those old chips were less efficient than MH's (or as he stated equal).
times change.. outputs are pusing 2x the efficiency of MH's and add in the better "delivery geometry" (less loss bouncing in and out of tubes/reflectors of a 360 degree point light source) even moreso...
I do caution people about judging 10 year old diodes against moden equivalents though some of those Chinese COB's may be the same as in the old days..
Things like Bluacro "pucks" LEDGroupbuy or Kessil multichips and a handful of other quality "assemblies" are much better than the "original" multichips.
As to heat.. well there is more than one kind of heat.. ;)
........................................................................
Here is the "catch" though.
1) Generally not the best chips on those boards which moves DIY'ers into other directions (low Lumen/watt)
2) Heat can be an issue as well as UV/violet/blue "browning" of the err lenses on board and other heating.
3) Making them look "pretty" is challenging
4) Not as cost effective as one would believe esp. since modern LEd's offer lots of "programming" like WiFi Bluetooth options..though this cost also includes the whole chain from heat sinks to drivers/power supplies.
Actually you would be surprised how easy they are to build..
Kind of comes back to my little "project "above.. Sort of a rebellion from the "kitchen sink" diode approach..
If you note the costs.. it's not cheap but uses sort of state of the art diodes..well one level of them..
Oh and it's really "daylight" centric for the most part w/ 1 "actinic" channel, 1 white..
the orig. Royal blue/10000k-ish LEd's were, for the most part successful IF one understands watts..
Prob. was trying to sell 50W as equiv to 250W MH.. BIG mistake in PR..
Probably plenty of successful tanks (from an owners view, maybe not from some purests vision) still running Royal blue/white diodes out there..
also gets back to the ORIG. thread.. What about the spectrum.. ;)
As to wavelengths..
Which are wants.. which are needs.. which make small difference.. which make large differences..
Which encourage growth.. which encourage fluorescent pigments.. which encourage regular pigments..which look the best..
ect..ect
That's almost an impossible challenge considering the number of species and 100's of different environments.
Yes no "UV" in most but "exactly" what does that do?
No IR to speak of.. same issue . "exactly" what does that mean.
One could add "when" does it matter as well........
From my limited point of view there are no "important" wavelengths missing in LED's till one defines EXACTLY what is important..
and how important...
and honestly, from what I've seen (not done) even those are a stretch..
You're dealing w/ a fairly "plastic" organism that is capable of adjusting to its light environment ..to a certain degree.
fw aquatics and terrestrials do the same..
From that point of view, light within reason, is probably the least important factor...
Defining what is "correct" is an individual choice not a mob pick..
to be honest, and I have this same discussion on fw sites, start w/ a vision of what YOU want it to look like, regardless of say how fast it grows..or which corals like it or don't.
Now that also isn't for everyone either some do want "the ultimate" of err something.. Fine but don't forget that costs in a LOT of time and patience.
This may sound like some vote for mediocrity but not really.
Just puts you ahead of the tank not the tank ahead of you.
With that.. LED, MH, t5 combo of any or all make it your choice..They all "work" AFAICT..
Just my 1 cent worth of "philosophy".....