- Joined
- Oct 1, 2017
- Messages
- 3,116
- Reaction score
- 2,586
Oh. You sell scrubbers. Makes sense nowThis is rubbish.
No odour, good or bad from my scrubber or any other I'm familiar with.
No splashing, falling water.
Stop making stuff up.
Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
Oh. You sell scrubbers. Makes sense nowThis is rubbish.
No odour, good or bad from my scrubber or any other I'm familiar with.
No splashing, falling water.
Stop making stuff up.
Agreed. Precisely sized is more than a stretch. While I can see working out a formula for flow vs screen size for optimal growth. Or amount and/or color of light. Sizing is a guide at best. Which you can then dial in with testing and adjusting photo time, as long as it’s not too undersized, and before you strip out to much causing damage to cycleI think "precisely sized" is a stretch. I have heard of the vague sizing/cube rule you are referring to but there are so many variables with our systems/setups it is more like a guideline.
That you say it's hard to size. I have never heard that before or experienced it in fact it seems easier to size than a fug and takes up less space IME. However, each to their own.What issues?
If you are talking about nutrients being too low, think about it the way you would think about dosing. If your alk is too high reduce alk dosing amount. If your nutrients get lower than the level you would like then reduce the photoperiod of the ATS.
Same here even my wife doesn't complain of any smell.Oh. You sell scrubbers. Makes sense now
Here is a really good video about scrubbers..
my take; i run triton, and tried time and time again to grow chaeto but it kept dying. i had massive issues with green hair algae, it alost took over the DT, and even in the refugium, the GHA would grow over the chaeto and make the sump a mess, so i new i could grow GHA with no issues lol. Triton results stated not enough iron which probably lead to the chaeto dying.
I got fed up buying chaeto and i didn't want to my chaeto/nutriant control reliant on how much iron i had in my water. I did loads of research and couldn't believe that my biggest issue GHA could actually by my saviour!! its been staring me in the face all this time, so i decided a scrubber was better for me.
I had a AI prime fuge light and a cheap grow light so i decided to make my own scrubber. it works really well and about 3 weeks in the screen is growing algae nicely. give it 3 more weeks and i'll be able to tell with my perameters if the screen works better or not, as i've had issues with phosphate averaging 0.1 and nitrate 15-25.
Algae scrubber seem easier to work/maintain, keep the sump clean from algae and better nutriant export....
Not when he's talking facts.Oh. You sell scrubbers. Makes sense now
I understand what you mean. I just meant it is harder to size due to many variables. It is not as easy as sizing a return pump.That you say it's hard to size. I have never heard that before or experienced it in fact it seems easier to size than a fug and takes up less space IME. However, each to their own.
Same here even my wife doesn't complain of any smell.
Not sure why anybody would want to compare sizing a scrubber with a return pump but hey oh.I understand what you mean. I just meant it is harder to size due to many variables. It is not as easy as sizing a return pump.
Sorry my bad, I obviously misread that about sell.My post that you quoted says sell, not smell. A much more previous post brought up smell and noise associated with scrubbers. Not sure how one can claim it does not. Not saying it’s as bad as a skimmer cup, but it’s there and it’s real.
Not bashing scrubbers in any way. They are a great tool and certainly have their place. Just sharing info
Yeah. The noise I bring up is not the water exiting the scrubber, but noise of water falling off algae once it grows in clumps on screen. Instead of rolling down to bottom as it does when screen is cleaner.Sorry my bad, I obviously misread that about sell.
I say no smell as there is no appreciable smell from the scrubber certainly outside the cabinet and little if any within it. Also no noise, my scrubber water exits below the waterline so no splashing can be heard in fact my sump is really silent and certainly nothing within my cabinet can be heard outside of it, my wife would be the first to complain if it was.
I have more water volume and space now I have a scrubber with my D-D 1500s sump. Granted the water volume taken up bI’ve had both, both work great but the refugium is much easier and adds water volume to the DT. Cheato likes high flow and tumbling it works best. once it grows to the point it stops tumbling trim It back. If my space was limited I’d go back to ATS.
In fact I have no less water volume but much more space in the sump of my D-D 1500s pro sump that a refuge would take up. I have space for a calcium reactor etc thatvwould have been taken up by a fuge.I’ve had both, both work great but the refugium is much easier and adds water volume to the DT. Cheato likes high flow and tumbling it works best. once it grows to the point it stops tumbling trim It back. If my space was limited I’d go back to ATS.
Nope no noise from the water coming off the algae. Good modern designs should not emit much if any noise at all. As said my wife does not notice any noise and she sits about 2 meters from the tank and scrubber. If there was she would certainly let me know about it I can assure you.Yeah. The noise I bring up is not the water exiting the scrubber, but noise of water falling off algae once it grows in clumps on screen. Instead of rolling down to bottom as it does when screen is cleaner.
Nope no noise from the water coming off the algae. Good modern designs should not emit much if any noise at all. As said my wife does not notice any noise and she sits about 2 meters from the tank and scrubber. If there was she would certainly let me know about it I can assure you.
Cleaning the screen maybe gives a little smell but when you take cheato out isn't there also? When people talk about ATSs being smelly I doubt they are referring to when you clean the screen but in general or why mention it.Not sure how design works around the smell or noise. Do you not smell it when cleaning screen? Maybe design helps contain it. Can’t work around gravity. Algae grows, water falls off algae instead of rolling down to bottom. This is my undeniable experience.
At least you can’t say that ats needs less maintenance. Since you already posted 4 days growth