Here is a really good video about scrubbers..
my take; i run triton, and tried time and time again to grow chaeto but it kept dying. i had massive issues with green hair algae, it alost took over the DT, and even in the refugium, the GHA would grow over the chaeto and make the sump a mess, so i new i could grow GHA with no issues lol. Triton results stated not enough iron which probably lead to the chaeto dying.
I got fed up buying chaeto and i didn't want to my chaeto/nutriant control reliant on how much iron i had in my water. I did loads of research and couldn't believe that my biggest issue GHA could actually by my saviour!! its been staring me in the face all this time, so i decided a scrubber was better for me.
I had a AI prime fuge light and a cheap grow light so i decided to make my own scrubber. it works really well and about 3 weeks in the screen is growing algae nicely. give it 3 more weeks and i'll be able to tell with my perameters if the screen works better or not, as i've had issues with phosphate averaging 0.1 and nitrate 15-25.
Algae scrubber seem easier to work/maintain, keep the sump clean from algae and better nutriant export....