Algae scrubber vs Algae reactor...

Stege_saurus

Active Member
View Badges
Joined
May 22, 2019
Messages
458
Reaction score
296
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
I'm deciding on which route I want to go and which one is best for my tank, but I'm stuck unfortunately. Which would be better for a 75g (30g sump)?

Right now I don't have a huge bio load but as time goes on it will increase
 

Peace River

Thrive Master
View Badges
Joined
Apr 29, 2014
Messages
22,392
Reaction score
169,010
Location
USA
Rating - 100%
1   0   0
I'm sure others will chime in and there is likely a wide range of opinions. In my experience, I have a name brand algae reactor and multiple name brand algae scrubbers and I have had better long term results with an algae scrubber.
 

exnisstech

Grumpy old man
View Badges
Joined
Feb 11, 2019
Messages
12,433
Reaction score
19,893
Location
Ashland Ohio
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
I've never used a reactor I always just placed chaeto in a chamber of the sump and ran it as a fuge. I'm happy with the scrubber on my latest build. The tangs love it also. No more dried nori, now they get fresh algae and love it.

PXL_20240727_161253879.jpg


PXL_20240727_161535555.jpg
 

VintageReefer

10K Club member
View Badges
Joined
Nov 16, 2023
Messages
14,382
Reaction score
26,748
Location
USA
Rating - 100%
2   0   0
I'm deciding on which route I want to go and which one is best for my tank, but I'm stuck unfortunately. Which would be better for a 75g (30g sump)?

Right now I don't have a huge bio load but as time goes on it will increase
I have a 75 with sump and 10+ years experience with scrubbers. I will confidently say a scrubber is superior

A scrubber will grow turf. A reactor will grow Chaeto.

Turf > cheato for nutrient control
Scrubber > reactor for many reasons but main one is it allows the growth of turf
 
Last edited:
OP
OP
Stege_saurus

Stege_saurus

Active Member
View Badges
Joined
May 22, 2019
Messages
458
Reaction score
296
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
I've never used a reactor I always just placed chaeto in a chamber of the sump and ran it as a fuge. I'm happy with the scrubber on my latest build. The tangs love it also. No more dried nori, now they get fresh algae and love it.

PXL_20240727_161253879.jpg


PXL_20240727_161535555.jpg
For whatever reason, I never have luck with chaeto. Regardless of nutrient levels and dosing and lights it always does on me. I've given it more chances than I should but still no luck.
 
OP
OP
Stege_saurus

Stege_saurus

Active Member
View Badges
Joined
May 22, 2019
Messages
458
Reaction score
296
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
I have a 75 with sump and 10+ years experience with scrubbers. I roll confidently say a scrubber is superior

A scrubber will grow turf. A reactor will grow Chaeto.

Turf > cheato for nutrient control
Scrubber > reactor for many reasons but main one is it allows the growth of turf
On my previous build I had a scrubber plumbed at the end of my drain and it worked fairly well most of the time. I don't want to build one into my drain this go around so I was thinking of doing a DIY option. Do you have any pics of your scrubber that you wouldn't mind sharing?
 
OP
OP
Stege_saurus

Stege_saurus

Active Member
View Badges
Joined
May 22, 2019
Messages
458
Reaction score
296
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
I'm sure others will chime in and there is likely a wide range of opinions. In my experience, I have a name brand algae reactor and multiple name brand algae scrubbers and I have had better long term results with an algae scrubber.
That's interesting . I've had some luck with a scrubber but never used a reactor and was curious.
 

exnisstech

Grumpy old man
View Badges
Joined
Feb 11, 2019
Messages
12,433
Reaction score
19,893
Location
Ashland Ohio
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
For whatever reason, I never have luck with chaeto. Regardless of nutrient levels and dosing and lights it always does on me. I've given it more chances than I should but still no luck

I've had decent luck with chaeto but I have had it not do well in some tanks. I've heard of dosing iron to help but I never bothered. If it grew fine if not oh well. I didn't use chaeto for nutrient control but more to provide a habitat for little creatures to populate.
 
OP
OP
Stege_saurus

Stege_saurus

Active Member
View Badges
Joined
May 22, 2019
Messages
458
Reaction score
296
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
I've had decent luck with chaeto but I have had it not do well in some tanks. I've heard of dosing iron to help but I never bothered. If it grew fine if not oh well. I didn't use chaeto for nutrient control but more to provide a habitat for little creatures to populate.
Ahh I see. I guess I didn't think of that
 

VintageReefer

10K Club member
View Badges
Joined
Nov 16, 2023
Messages
14,382
Reaction score
26,748
Location
USA
Rating - 100%
2   0   0
On my previous build I had a scrubber plumbed at the end of my drain and it worked fairly well most of the time. I don't want to build one into my drain this go around so I was thinking of doing a DIY option. Do you have any pics of your scrubber that you wouldn't mind sharing?
There is no comparison when it comes to ease of installation and performance. The Surf by Santa Monica is a perfect design. It floats in your sump. No plumbing needed. It connects to an air pump. I can reccomend one for 30$ that’s powerful and silent. It’s 1000par of 440nm led growing a 2” thick brick of algae. It’s silent and can not leak or overflow, it’s completely contained inside the sump. When the lid is on there is no light spill and it’s quiet.

I reccomended this one to Exnisstech and his results are great and here he is on his own showing it off

I use the surf 2, he uses the surf 4 I believe.
ADC78D2B-9777-4C62-8CEF-13AD1EFFACFB.jpeg
72BD56F4-D04D-4349-85E7-8D71F36D640C.jpeg

3970255E-B0D1-4A45-98CF-DD61CAC72774.jpeg


04A27C50-86F8-4BB1-B9FE-E83972AF7253.jpeg
 

Peace River

Thrive Master
View Badges
Joined
Apr 29, 2014
Messages
22,392
Reaction score
169,010
Location
USA
Rating - 100%
1   0   0
There is no comparison when it comes to ease of installation and performance. The Surf by Santa Monica is a perfect design. It floats in your sump. No plumbing needed. It connects to an air pump. I can reccomend one for 30$ that’s powerful and silent. It’s 1000par of 440nm led growing a 2” thick brick of algae. It’s silent and can not leak or overflow, it’s completely contained inside the sump. When the lid is on there is no light spill and it’s quiet.

I reccomended this one to Exnisstech and his results are great and here he is on his own showing it off

I use the surf 2, he uses the surf 4 I believe.
ADC78D2B-9777-4C62-8CEF-13AD1EFFACFB.jpeg
72BD56F4-D04D-4349-85E7-8D71F36D640C.jpeg

3970255E-B0D1-4A45-98CF-DD61CAC72774.jpeg


04A27C50-86F8-4BB1-B9FE-E83972AF7253.jpeg
Interesting. I have a Santa Monica and an IceCap scrubber. The IceCap is messier, but I have had better results and used it for a long period of time. I may need to take another look at the Santa Monica.
 

VintageReefer

10K Club member
View Badges
Joined
Nov 16, 2023
Messages
14,382
Reaction score
26,748
Location
USA
Rating - 100%
2   0   0
Interesting. I have a Santa Monica and an IceCap scrubber. The IceCap is messier, but I have had better results and used it for a long period of time. I may need to take another look at the Santa Monica.
This surf 2 is 11 years old

I just had to replace the foam on it from worms boring holes in it. The foam piece was inexpensive and SM shipped fast.

I had my leds blow out from a power surge during a storm, SM gave me a hefty discount on a replacement upgraded lid/led piece. Out of warranty by 9 years, failure was not the products fault, and still they hooked me up and took about 50% off the price of the part I needed.

This scrubber is the only filtration that runs my tank…aside from live rock/sand

C36EB0FE-6ED2-4098-AF30-AE0835CCDFA8.jpeg
522CE71E-4929-4D14-90C5-987348EDF7E8.jpeg
46A51988-AE40-484A-9D6B-3D2F148A9241.jpeg
BF50EDF3-C95D-4FC6-987B-5B09B8586A2E.jpeg
 
OP
OP
Stege_saurus

Stege_saurus

Active Member
View Badges
Joined
May 22, 2019
Messages
458
Reaction score
296
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
This surf 2 is 11 years old

I just had to replace the foam on it from worms boring holes in it. The foam piece was inexpensive and SM shipped fast.

I had my leds blow out from a power surge during a storm, SM gave me a hefty discount on a replacement upgraded lid/led piece. Out of warranty by 9 years, failure was not the products fault, and still they hooked me up and took about 50% off the price of the part I needed.

This scrubber is the only filtration that runs my tank…aside from live rock/sand

C36EB0FE-6ED2-4098-AF30-AE0835CCDFA8.jpeg
522CE71E-4929-4D14-90C5-987348EDF7E8.jpeg
46A51988-AE40-484A-9D6B-3D2F148A9241.jpeg
BF50EDF3-C95D-4FC6-987B-5B09B8586A2E.jpeg
Not gonna lie, that's quite impressive. Both the tank and the warranty situation. I really love companies like that. I'm definitely gonna be looking into them now. Thank you!
 

Gtinnel

10K Club member
View Badges
Joined
Mar 20, 2020
Messages
22,312
Reaction score
30,867
Location
Charleston, WV
Rating - 100%
1   0   0
It connects to an air pump. I can reccomend one for 30$ that’s powerful and silent

I have wanted an algae scrubber for a while but have never had space for one. I’m considering making some changes in my sump that would allow me to fit one of the SM Surf scrubbers. I was looking at the Surf4 or 4x and was curious what you would recommend for an air pump?
 

VintageReefer

10K Club member
View Badges
Joined
Nov 16, 2023
Messages
14,382
Reaction score
26,748
Location
USA
Rating - 100%
2   0   0
@Gtinnel

Surf 2 series - 8 watt
Surf 4 series - 12 watt


69EB563A-E2A5-4D9C-BE64-303E6E02167C.jpeg


I have been through several air pumps in 10 years of running the surf. I find they last 6 months to 3 years. (Don’t buy eheim air pumps!)
I can’t speak to the longetivity on this one, but it is both the quietest and strongest one I’ve encountered. Price is good also. It feels solid and appears well made. Turn the control dial up to max, then back off slightly and it’s completely silent. Also it’s the only one that doesn’t buzz like a bees nest if something comes in contact with the outer shell
 

Gtinnel

10K Club member
View Badges
Joined
Mar 20, 2020
Messages
22,312
Reaction score
30,867
Location
Charleston, WV
Rating - 100%
1   0   0
@Gtinnel

Surf 2 series - 8 watt
Surf 4 series - 12 watt


69EB563A-E2A5-4D9C-BE64-303E6E02167C.jpeg


I have been through several air pumps in 10 years of running the surf. I find they last 6 months to 3 years. (Don’t buy eheim air pumps!)
I can’t speak to the longetivity on this one, but it is both the quietest and strongest one I’ve encountered. Price is good also. It feels solid and appears well made. Turn the control dial up to max, then back off slightly and it’s completely silent. Also it’s the only one that doesn’t buzz like a bees nest if something comes in contact with the outer shell
Thanks. I’m was actually looking at an Alita air pump. The one you recommended is much more affordable.
 

VintageReefer

10K Club member
View Badges
Joined
Nov 16, 2023
Messages
14,382
Reaction score
26,748
Location
USA
Rating - 100%
2   0   0
Thanks. I’m was actually looking at an Alita air pump. The one you recommended is much more affordable.

Surf 2 wants a pump at least 5 LPM - and the 8w I suggest is 10 LPM

Surf 4 wants at least 10 LPM - and the 12w I suggest is 16 LPM

Both these pumps pair up well with the corresponding surfs.

Glad I could save you some bucks also. Use it and buy a coral and consider it from me!
 

mjszos

Well-Known Member
View Badges
Joined
Sep 7, 2021
Messages
864
Reaction score
2,733
Location
Chicago, IL
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
Surf 2 wants a pump at least 5 LPM - and the 8w I suggest is 10 LPM

Surf 4 wants at least 10 LPM - and the 12w I suggest is 16 LPM

Both these pumps pair up well with the corresponding surfs.

Glad I could save you some bucks also. Use it and buy a coral and consider it from me!

I've been looking into the SM scrubbers, but I have a hard time understanding their sizing guide. Is it really as simple as the amount of food you're feeding? I have a 100G DT + 50G Sump and only feed 1 cube per day (may get up to 2 once it's more stocked). It seems crazy to me that the Surf 2 would be sufficient, but that's their claim.

Any thoughts?
 

TOP 10 Trending Threads

ON A SCALE FROM 1-10, HOW MUCH DO YOU LOVE REEFING?

  • 10 - It's one of the things I love most in life!

    Votes: 30 30.6%
  • 9

    Votes: 13 13.3%
  • 8

    Votes: 21 21.4%
  • 7

    Votes: 20 20.4%
  • 6

    Votes: 2 2.0%
  • 5 - I enjoy it, but I could live without it if I had to.

    Votes: 9 9.2%
  • 4

    Votes: 1 1.0%
  • 3

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • 2

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • 1 - I'm not sure why I am still in this hobby...

    Votes: 2 2.0%
Back
Top