So I used this term in a thread that had a young tank attempting SPS while dosing cal/alk and reef ab+, but its a phenomenon I stand by. Its a trend I've noticed as a reef store employee and full time aquarium installation/maintenance guy. I likely interact with more totally new people in the hobby than most, where as most users on this forum are likelier to interact with more seasoned reefers, or at least more determined ones that would not call upon me for advice or service. The common thread amongst many of the perpetual problem tanks was almost always looking over the value of good maintenance, and choosing to buy products instead.
The ones I'd see the most are: dosing alkalinity/calcium into a tank with just a couple frags at most, dumping in coral foods of any type to "avoid low nutrients," and then dumping in vibrant when the tank hits nasty algae at the 6-12 month mark, which half the time plunges the tank into chaos.
I do not necessarily think that
BRS is intentionally misleading people for the sake of profits, and I think their intentions are for the betterment of the hobby (and to obviously make money, but it is a business, not a charity, and that is something I do not hold against them in the least). That said, they make reefing SEEM so easy and straight forward from their videos, and it is often times the only resource people getting into the hobby use, because it is presented in a way that it is the only resource needed.
So newer reefers (often impatiently) start up a new tank and start rushing things and start hitting (at least what they may perceive as) issues, well luckily, their only resource has a forum to tell them that 0 nitrate reading needs to be fixed! and look at that, a professional video by them to at least somewhat support that! Oh no, my alkalinity was 10.5 3 days ago, now its 10.0, nevermind I tested at different times in the day and that is within my test kits margin of error,
BRS Pharma needs to be added ASAP since there is so much consumption I have swings! This is the sort of stuff I see constantly on their forums, and would run into daily working the LFS. It leads so many new hobbyists to spending a ton in their first year to have a bare bottom tank full of dinos and a wake of dead corals.
BRS themselves have even made video series on some fool proof reefing methods which ended up being failures in their own admission, but dozens of frustrated new reefers chimed in and lamented all the money and time they spent pursuing those methods, only to ultimately fail.
I know this is a touchy subject, some will agree, some will disagree, but this is my opinion from my experiences with hobbyists online, in stores, and at reef shows. Again, I don't think
BRS is necessarily at fault, it is a byproduct of what they created, its just something that I so frequently see with new reefers frustrated at their set ups that just wont balance and mature. I love going through everyone elses and opinions and seeing others' perspectives as well.
TL;DR Keep your hands out of your tank, do your water changes.