I ran a fluval 206 on my 20 gallon long. It was the main filtration for its 6 month lifespan until I upgraded to a 75 dt with 20 sump. Now I use it as a wet vac of sorts to clean the sump and dt.
I have to say, the water was pristine, but I cleaned the 206 every weekend during my waterchange, and swapped carbon out every 3 weeks. You absolutely have to stay on top of it... but it only takes five minutes to rise the media off in change water and wipe down the plastic once you get the hang of it.
Without a skimmer, I would put a paper towel flat on the water surface every few days and that cleaned up the oil slick.
Sump beats canister hands down, but when it's not an option... waddyagonnado :)
Edit: oh you could do a hang on back filter lol, but I think canister beats that as long as its cleaned religiously.