Can't beat my Aiptasia outbreak

Dr. Peter Venkman

Active Member
View Badges
Joined
Mar 18, 2021
Messages
162
Reaction score
169
Location
Michigan
What state or country do you live in
Michigan
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
So ever since the late spring I've been battling aiptasia. It just keeps coming and coming and coming. No matter what I do, it comes back. Right now every rock I have is covered in them. My glass has dozens... everything. I don't see any in my sump, but I'm sure they are there too. I Just don't know what to do anymore. I've been reefing for 20 years, but I've never had this issue. I'm thinking of taking all my live rock and sand out, throwing it away and leaving the tank a few hours with no water and then starting again with new sand and rock. Is this pretty much my only option at this point?
 
I haven't been 'lucky' enough to battle aiptasia (but I'm sure it's coming eventually). I'm dealing with GHA right now. Maybe @JoJosReef can give you some tips.

What have you tried so far?
 
another solution would be to get 1 or 2 adult Australian Stripey fish. They will devour Aiptasia and are also really cool fish (and mostly reef safe). I also have aiptasia and have been spot eradicating for years - the Stripey was hopefully my last issue with this.
 
another solution would be to get 1 or 2 adult Australian Stripey fish. They will devour Aiptasia and are also really cool fish (and mostly reef safe). I also have aiptasia and have been spot eradicating for years - the Stripey was hopefully my last issue with this.
nice tip, haven't heard of those cool looking fish. What makes them potentially not reef safe/.
 
Spent years battling, tried everything.
Added a Copperband, 100% gone in a week.
Cohabitates well with 4 full size tangs and others.
Been clean ever since.
Best addition ever. IMG_0256.jpeg
 
I had great results with true peppermint. Have a pair that keeps my DT spotless even though my sump and overflow is covered with aip.
Have you ever had them go after anything else?
 
Have you ever had them go after anything else?
No, I've heard anecdotally that they go after the soft polyps when they starve but never observed any in my tank. I've seen them jump and grab food out of the water column when I broadcast feed, and even be jerks that take the food that my acans trapped in their heads, but never eating the polyp themselves.
 
A real scourge. I haven't been able to rid the tank of them. Peppermint, only have one and haven't seen improvement. Berghia, think my wrasses kill them off too quickly despite adding them at night. Hoping a copperband does the trick.

Manual killing has been the best for me so far but it's a slog. I boil water and shoot it at isolated Aips with a feeding pipette, as long as they are away from coral. The others I use kalk paste to the mouth.
 
A real scourge. I haven't been able to rid the tank of them. Peppermint, only have one and haven't seen improvement. Berghia, think my wrasses kill them off too quickly despite adding them at night. Hoping a copperband does the trick.

Manual killing has been the best for me so far but it's a slog. I boil water and shoot it at isolated Aips with a feeding pipette, as long as they are away from coral. The others I use kalk paste to the mouth.
You'll need more than 1 peppermint if you are battling a large infestation. Just think about the biomass involved, one peppermint can eat maybe 1 or 2 heads of aip per day if you get lucky if it doesn't eat anything else, but realistically they are scavengers than also eat ur fish food and coral food. Just 1 is not going to outpace the rate of new aip growth.

I had 3 in my 65G during the initial stage of the outbreak and it took about a month to see majority clearing up. Then I gave 1 away to a local reefer and kept the 2 as maintainance. They left the aip population in check for the past 2 years away from the DT. Sump and plumbing, on the other hand, is like an aip forest lol.

Also make sure you have a true pepper. There are a lot of different species that all are colloquially named peppermint. Some are unintentional misidentifications by the fishstore clerk so not always nefarious, so you'd want to look at an id chart and ID them urself in the store. Wurdemanni or boggessi are what you want.
 
I used to get stressed out over aiptasias but no more! Just get a CBB, Kleine Butterfly, or filefish and they’ll munch these nasty aiptasias down and keep them down! The Klein may not be 100% reef safe (may eat zoas) but that’s a very small price to pay. Good luck!
 
I had a really bad Aiptasia outbreak, but I got rid of them all in about two weeks with a butterflyfish (Chaetodon capistratus). I was getting babies on the glass every couple of days, and every square inch of rockwork was covered too. This guy even ate the large ones. I did use kalk paste on the largest stumps that had the tentacles eaten off. I also have a filefish, but it would only go for the small/tiny aiptasia. If the Klein or CBB has the same behavior as the 4-eye, I'd say any of these butterfly fish is a good choice for a neglected outbreak like you describe. The 4-eye picks at the Gorgonia polyps, so I'm not sure what coral would actually work for them. It was probably the best $20 I've ever spent to get rid of the Aiptasia. The thing with Aiptasia is, you can't ignore it. It can get out of hand really quickly and become a huge problem.
 
another solution would be to get 1 or 2 adult Australian Stripey fish. They will devour Aiptasia and are also really cool fish (and mostly reef safe). I also have aiptasia and have been spot eradicating for years - the Stripey was hopefully my last issue with this.
My Australian stripy is an aptasia slayer, in about 60 mins of going in the tank all visible aptasia was gone, and there was a lot of small to medium sixes ones in rock and glass in the tank. Note he is eating algae off the sand and rocks as well and leaves other coral alone.

He’s a bit of a pig and have to feed more food so the other fish get any. But he’s doing his job well. He is specifically a Western Australia stripy not sure if you can get that specific outside of Australia when buying these, but having done chemical, and shrimp based methods he blitzed it in minute!!
 

Attachments

  • IMG_2198.jpeg
    IMG_2198.jpeg
    185.8 KB · Views: 113
My Australian stripy is an aptasia slayer, in about 60 mins of going in the tank all visible aptasia was gone, and there was a lot of small to medium sixes ones in rock and glass in the tank. Note he is eating algae off the sand and rocks as well and leaves other coral alone.

He’s a bit of a pig and have to feed more food so the other fish get any. But he’s doing his job well. He is specifically a Western Australia stripy not sure if you can get that specific outside of Australia when buying these, but having done chemical, and shrimp based methods he blitzed it in minute!!
mine is still a smallish juvenile and hasn't started yet on the aiptasia but i was told once he is bigger he'll dig in. So far he hasn't touched any of my lps/sps or softies.
 
So ever since the late spring I've been battling aiptasia. It just keeps coming and coming and coming. No matter what I do, it comes back. Right now every rock I have is covered in them. My glass has dozens... everything. I don't see any in my sump, but I'm sure they are there too. I Just don't know what to do anymore. I've been reefing for 20 years, but I've never had this issue. I'm thinking of taking all my live rock and sand out, throwing it away and leaving the tank a few hours with no water and then starting again with new sand and rock. Is this pretty much my only option at this point?
My peppermint shrimp cleaned out the small ones. I’d include them in remedy
 
nice tip, haven't heard of those cool looking fish. What makes them potentially not reef safe/.
I haven't heard from anyone who has one that it wasn't reef safe but google and some websites say reef say with caution... so i guess you never know for sure until you put one in. The upside is that they are voracious eaters with no fear so would be easy to get out of your tank if it turned out to be a coral eater
 
mine is still a smallish juvenile and hasn't started yet on the aiptasia but i was told once he is bigger he'll dig in. So far he hasn't touched any of my lps/sps or softies.

Yes, think mine is full size so could be an age thing. All the LFS near me all have these in their frag tanks so must be fairly coral safe.
 

TOP 10 Trending Threads

HOW WOULD YOU FEEL ABOUT RECEIVING A FISH OR CORAL AS A HOLIDAY GIFT?

  • I’d love one, as long as it’s a species I chose

    Votes: 26 24.5%
  • I’d trust someone who knows my tank to choose

    Votes: 9 8.5%
  • I’d rather get a gift card and pick it myself

    Votes: 43 40.6%
  • I’d prefer gear or supplies instead

    Votes: 2 1.9%
  • Please don’t surprise me with livestock

    Votes: 26 24.5%
  • Other (Post in the comments)

    Votes: 0 0.0%
Back
Top
Home
Post thread…
Market
What's new