I definitely like the idea of trace elements in the Cal Rx. Although, if you are doing weekly 10% water changes wouldn't the trace elements in the water change be more than sufficient while using 2 part? I also like the fact that a calcium Rx keeps all the levels consistent instead of the constant rise and fall. Consistency seems to be key in this hobby imho. I am currently using BRS 2 part but have been considering the change. It seems that PH may be a tad overrated at times. Once again as long as there is not large swings everything generally seems fine. I know a few reefers with 7.7-7.9 ph that are Sps dominated and there tanks are amazing.