DIY real ocean live rock

  • Thread starter Thread starter reef’r
  • Start date Start date
  • Tagged users Tagged users None

reef’r

Well-Known Member
View Badges
Joined
Apr 2, 2023
Messages
916
Reaction score
534
Location
reef’d
What state or country do you live in
Florida
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
So I was reading through a live rock thread on here while sitting in front of my new 80 gallon build. The great debate of live vs dry running through my head and then had a thought. If one was to buy some dry Marco, toss it in a mesh bag and run it out into the gulf and drop it, how long would it really take before you could go back and get it, bring it home and use it as your very own DIY live rock? Sounds like a pretty cool experiment anyway and one I’ll likely try
 
So I was reading through a live rock thread on here while sitting in front of my new 80 gallon build. The great debate of live vs dry running through my head and then had a thought. If one was to buy some dry Marco, toss it in a mesh bag and run it out into the gulf and drop it, how long would it really take before you could go back and get it, bring it home and use it as your very own DIY live rock? Sounds like a pretty cool experiment anyway and one I’ll likely try
That seems like a really cool experiment. I would think 6 months would be a good starting point time wise
 
Just an estimation. It also depends on how mature you’d like it to be. In 2 months I’m sure you could consider it “live” meaning full of all the nitrifying bacteria to start your aquarium. I’d think if you wanted more life than that ( macro algae, coralline, sponges, feather dusters, etc.) it would take a bit longer. There are variables as well like depth, location and such. You could always check on it as it soaks. Pulling pieces after different times to see the effect on biodiversity would be really cool too.
 
So I was reading through a live rock thread on here while sitting in front of my new 80 gallon build. The great debate of live vs dry running through my head and then had a thought. If one was to buy some dry Marco, toss it in a mesh bag and run it out into the gulf and drop it, how long would it really take before you could go back and get it, bring it home and use it as your very own DIY live rock? Sounds like a pretty cool experiment anyway and one I’ll likely try
Or you could just buy the maricultured marco rock and save some effort?
https://marcorocks.com/marcorocks-maricultured-live-rock-ships-overnight/
 
Dumb question, but are there any hitchhikers in the gulf where you live which could potentially be harmful to the fish that you’ve acquired from around the world? Would you be able to quarantine the rock with a bunch of sacrificial fish, first to ensure the safety of your tank?
 
Dumb question, but are there any hitchhikers in the gulf where you live which could potentially be harmful to the fish that you’ve acquired from around the world? Would you be able to quarantine the rock with a bunch of sacrificial fish, first to ensure the safety of your tank?
With any ocean sourced live rock there’s a chance of hitchhikers some may be undesirable but likely not harmful
 
Dumb question, but are there any hitchhikers in the gulf where you live which could potentially be harmful to the fish that you’ve acquired from around the world? Would you be able to quarantine the rock with a bunch of sacrificial fish, first to ensure the safety of your tank?
Yes always a risk even buying live rock from the big companies. Things like high salinity dips I’ve heard do a pretty good job and removing some undesirables from the rock
 
Most of the live rock sellers from the gulf seem to mention "years".
That'd be if you're trying to get more than just bacteria for cycling.

I'd think 1-2 months would be sufficient for cycling a new tank but seems like there's easier ways to get there.

Would be a fun experiment though.
Hope you don't get caught pulling it back out and have to try to prove to the authorities that it's yours!
...just kidding?
 
Hope you don't get caught pulling it back out and have to try to prove to the authorities that it's yours!
...just kidding?
Haha! The law states that even if you put it there it is not yours to take. Florida is very specific on this, don’t know about other states?
 
Could, however $400 for 20 lbs is absolutely insane
I'd say it's more sane to spend $400 to start your tank off right than it is to spend the same amount on a protein skimmer for your tank. As far as protein skimmers go, people can make their own and be just as good as the fancy manufactured ones. Same goes for algae scrubbers.

For my next tank I will be purchasing live rock rubble to seed dry marco rock in a stock tank. (so same idea, just less effort needed on my part) lol
 
Haha! The law states that even if you put it there it is not yours to take. Florida is very specific on this, don’t know about other states?
What if you drop your Pet Rock you've had since you were a kid?
You can't pull it back out?
...that was stupid,,, sorry
 
400$ to save a year or 2 of waiting for your rock to come out like theirs..
And totally worth it.

I started my tank with fake rock, and fake rock SUCKS. You do not have a mature tank with nitrifying bacteria alone and a few pods. A stable and reliable tank requires all kinds of things we don't even fully understand. But all those things we dont understand come from the ocean in live rock and not BRS in a dry box or a bottle.

I had to start a mud refugium with mud and sand from the florida keys to make my fake rock into live rock, and it took 2 years. Do I have pests? Yup! But nothing to any degree where I am in a panic or where my corals are under onslaught. Newsflash - the ocean has pests too. The ocean also has the cure for them too...under the same roof.

It all depends on what you want. If you want white rocks with frags on it for 6 months until it crashes and cashes out, start with fake rocks. If you want a system that lasts many years and continues to evolve, start with live rock.

Dead rock is a great way to start a dead system. Live rock is a great way to start a live system. 🤘😁

There's a sad irony in calling a pile of dead white rocks a reef. A reef is a cradle of evolution. Not a frag stand.

**The preceding post is the sole opinion of its author based on the real world experience of the author with both fake and live rock.**
 
I’m a live rock fan. Started my current tank with dry rock and slowly pulled most of it out and added in live rock. I have plenty of rubble and rock to seed my new tank. Just thought in the mean time while I get this tank set up, buying dead rock at a fraction of the cost and dropping it in the ocean for a couple months would be a win win. Yes I know the live Marco rock is supposed to be amazing, same with TBS and GLR but I simply don’t want to pay the premium. Is it definitely worth it, absolutely
 
Could, however $400 for 20 lbs is absolutely insane
Not really!
Consider all the money you spend on your system. $400 is nothing to get a system up and running with corals added in a few week.
Not sure where you get the $400 from but it's irrelevant, imo.
My 15g nano cube is 4 months old with 37 mixed reef coral.
Started with lfs tank breakdown live rock.
Think of live rock as an investment like all the other quality equipment you run.
You can have this or fight the uglies. Your choice.
20250307_133622.jpg
20250709_122131.jpg
Screenshot_20250802_085931_Chrome.jpg
 
Well, this is literally what Tampa Bay Saltwater does; drop rocks into the Gulf, then pull them up teeming with life. Unfortunately, you would need permits to do this legally yourself. I believe the process takes between 6 to 18 months or so for the rocks to become fully "live". I think it makes more sense to just buy ocean mariculture rocks and sand from TBS. Even a little live rock can go a long way to seeding dry rocks with beneficial critters, micro and macro.
 

TOP 10 Trending Threads

HOW WOULD YOU FEEL ABOUT RECEIVING A FISH OR CORAL AS A HOLIDAY GIFT?

  • I’d love one, as long as it’s a species I chose

    Votes: 19 28.4%
  • I’d trust someone who knows my tank to choose

    Votes: 2 3.0%
  • I’d rather get a gift card and pick it myself

    Votes: 25 37.3%
  • I’d prefer gear or supplies instead

    Votes: 2 3.0%
  • Please don’t surprise me with livestock

    Votes: 19 28.4%
  • Other (Post in the comments)

    Votes: 0 0.0%
Back
Top
Home
Post thread…
Market
What's new