DIY real ocean live rock

  • Thread starter Thread starter reef’r
  • Start date Start date
  • Tagged users Tagged users None
Never used TBS but am a fan of @Gulf Live Rock. I will be using another 50lbs of premium for my new growout sysyem.
150lbs for my 150. Zero to 1 year.
20240430_135424.jpg
20250730_134605.jpg
 
I miss the good ol days which wasn't really that long ago. This is what I used to start my first tank and eventually seed a bunch of dry rock over the years.
Screenshot_20241031-223722~2.png

Screenshot_20241031-223628.png



I started two tanks with all dry rock in the display but filled the sumps with live rock and never had nuisance algae. I keep a brute full of rock in the basement so I can insta cycle a tank if needed.
 
Not really!
Consider all the money you spend on your system. $400 is nothing to get a system up and running with corals added in a few week.
Not sure where you get the $400 from but it's irrelevant, imo.
My 15g nano cube is 4 months old with 37 mixed reef coral.
Started with lfs tank breakdown live rock.
Think of live rock as an investment like all the other quality equipment you run.
You can have this or fight the uglies. Your choice.
20250307_133622.jpg
20250709_122131.jpg
Screenshot_20250802_085931_Chrome.jpg
20lbs of live Marco is $389 according to their website.
 
20lbs of live Marco is $389 according to their website.
Quite a difference between the 2 price wise. I will stick with GLR.
 
Never used TBS but am a fan of @Gulf Live Rock. I will be using another 50lbs of premium for my new growout sysyem.
150lbs for my 150. Zero to 1 year.
20240430_135424.jpg
20250730_134605.jpg
The
Quite a difference between the 2 price wise. I will stick with GLR.
yes I just checked GLR and it’s far better priced. Making it a more viable option
 
Not really!
Consider all the money you spend on your system. $400 is nothing to get a system up and running with corals added in a few week.
Not sure where you get the $400 from but it's irrelevant, imo.
My 15g nano cube is 4 months old with 37 mixed reef coral.
Started with lfs tank breakdown live rock.
Think of live rock as an investment like all the other quality equipment you run.
You can have this or fight the uglies. Your choice.
20250307_133622.jpg
20250709_122131.jpg
Screenshot_20250802_085931_Chrome.jpg
400 dollars is a few frags. 🤣
 
As mentioned, legalality is a huge concern. However, those with the permits are typically placing rock every so often. Perhaps if you made a scape you like (or even just had the rocks you want) you may be able to pay them to place them and then harvest them. 🤷
 
I miss the good ol days which wasn't really that long ago. This is what I used to start my first tank and eventually seed a bunch of dry rock over the years.
Screenshot_20241031-223722~2.png

Screenshot_20241031-223628.png



I started two tanks with all dry rock in the display but filled the sumps with live rock and never had nuisance algae. I keep a brute full of rock in the basement so I can insta cycle a tank if needed.

Transportation was cheaper and space wasn't a premium as it is today. Nothing you don't already know but moving stuff from A to B is incredibly expensive. Still one can get a 10, 15, 25 pound box of live rock to seed a system with not much cost.

It really does not take up that much of the reefing budget. People are paying $400 USD on a 1/4" freshly cut frag and 5x as much for a single head of a fancy color morph LPS.
 
As mentioned, legalality is a huge concern. However, those with the permits are typically placing rock every so often. Perhaps if you made a scape you like (or even just had the rocks you want) you may be able to pay them to place them and then harvest them. 🤷

Permits are not that easy to come by these days, if at all.
 
If you do it, don’t get caught

Without a doubt. Even collecting NSW can be a challenge if not done properly. Like pulling water out of a marine refuge or state park.

I’d personally skip the hassle and start with TBS rock and/or sand

100% behind this. And if the budget isn't there hit up a LFS and buy some from them to seed. Heck, even rubble from any of the three main players is worth the money and most will ship that via UPS/FedEx.
 
Permits are not that easy to come by these days, if at all.
I guess I should have clarified. I meant contacting a current permit holder (like GLR, TBS, or others) and see if they’d place his rock on their site for a couple months or whatever he wants then they give it back.
 
Do you want to be labeled a poacher? Better leave it to the permit holders.
They have permits for their commercial operations pertaining to the amount that they are pulling from the water every year. By amount I mean the actual weight of the rock, I’m sure the permits outline other things as well. I’m an outdoorsman and hunt and fish the state of Florida year round and have the licensing to do so. By purchasing those licenses the state gives you permission to use its public lands and waters and inside those lands and waters there are some protected areas where the rules may be a little different, kinda like how you can’t touch a wild mangrove but can cut down a 300 year old oak tree at the bat of an eye. So as long as your in public waters, and not retrieving anything over any type of weight limit regulation there might be, are harvesting some sort of sea critter illegally in the process I really don’t see how you can face legal trouble? Or be labeled a poacher lol
 
I think it would be a cool experiment to run, and I do think longer waiting the better results. Like others, you could just by pass the experiment and go purchase the rocks. TBS is where I'll get new rocks and whatnot if I ever get a second tank up and running. However, the fun is the experiment. I'd just do it to do it, and see what happens. Maybe get several different bags going and go check them out every 2, 4, 6, 8, 10, 12 months and do a comparison.
 

TOP 10 Trending Threads

HOW WOULD YOU FEEL ABOUT RECEIVING A FISH OR CORAL AS A HOLIDAY GIFT?

  • I’d love one, as long as it’s a species I chose

    Votes: 19 28.4%
  • I’d trust someone who knows my tank to choose

    Votes: 2 3.0%
  • I’d rather get a gift card and pick it myself

    Votes: 25 37.3%
  • I’d prefer gear or supplies instead

    Votes: 2 3.0%
  • Please don’t surprise me with livestock

    Votes: 19 28.4%
  • Other (Post in the comments)

    Votes: 0 0.0%
Back
Top
Home
Post thread…
Market
What's new