Does Anyone Know what this is and how to fix it?

Capalot

New Member
View Badges
Joined
Aug 8, 2026
Messages
3
Reaction score
2
What state or country do you live in
Rhode Island
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
Hi I am a new reefer and just started my fishless cycle with ammonium chloride and Fritz Turbo start 900. I have passed the ammonia stage and I am waiting on Nitrites to drop to 0. Today I found these White strings coming from all of my dry rock. Can anyone help me figure out what it is and if there is a way to get rid of it? I started with CaribSea live sand and dry rock. Below are my current levels according to my API and Salifert tests. I know API sucks but its all that I have at the moment.
Salinity: 1.024
DKH: 9
PH: 7.8
Ammonia: 0
Nitrite: 5
Nitrate 10
Calcium: 350
Magnesium: 1350
Phosphate: 0
IMG_1378.jpg
 
If you are just starting up your tank you will soon enter what is known as "the ugly phase". Depending on how the tank was set up, this phase can pass more quickly or take a few months. Usually you will start seeing brown "dust" all over the substrate, which are microalgae known as diatoms. Then a green hair algae (GHA) follows where the entire rockscape will be covered in GHA. Once the GHA dies, coralline algae (the algae that gives reef rock their typical red/pink/purple color) will start to grow. If you want to introduce corals the safest approach is to do so after the ugly phase, but many people decide to try it early.

Right now it looks like you have a less common start to the ugly phase, and instead of diatoms you see chrysophytes. They come in various shapes and can sometimes grow these "worm-like" filaments, but it's not a certain giveaway, we would need a microscope to verify. Both microalgae (diatoms and chrysophytes) use silicates that new substrate introduces into the tank or that might not have been fully filtered out by the Reverse Osmosis / Deionization (RO/DI) filtration system. As long as you make sure the water you use for your tank is properly deionized, both diatoms and chrysophytes will vanish on their own, but you will have to wait a few weeks. This process is totally normal and expected, I wouldn't worry about it.

To verify that the water is properly deionized, you need a "Total Dissolved Solids" (TDS) meter that can detect down to 1 ppm TDS. In some countries it is more common to measure the conductivity of the RO/DI water in µS/cm. Either way, both devices should display 0 for freshly made RO/DI. If RO/DI is sitting too long exposed to air (and therefore CO₂), the readings will increase. This doesn't make the water bad or unsuited for reef tank use, but it's important to measure freshly made water or the readings might be off. There are very useful "inline TDS meters" that can be directly connected to your RO/DI system's outlet if you are making your own RO/DI water. Once it shows 1 or 2ppm you need to replace the deionization resin that should be located in the very last filter cartridge(s) of your system. The other filters can usually be used much longer.

Edit:
You don't need to worry about nitrite, in comparison to freshwater nitrite is not dangerous in saltwater at realistically achievable levels. Your nitrate test will also display wrong readings while nitrite is present.
 
Last edited:
Upvote 0
Need a better image for my old eyes.

Guessing either some worm or possibly a colonial hydroid, but both are inconclusive swags based upon non-focused possibilities? Interesting what you got from live sand introductions. Please improve the pictures if you can? Are these white things soft or hard?
 
Upvote 0
If you are just starting up your tank you will soon enter what is known as "the ugly phase". Depending on how the tank was set up, this phase can pass more quickly or take a few months. Usually you will start seeing brown "dust" all over the substrate, which are microalgae known as diatoms. Then a green hair algae (GHA) follows where the entire rockscape will be covered in GHA. Once the GHA dies, coralline algae (the algae that gives reef rock their typical red/pink/purple color) will start to grow. If you want to introduce corals the safest approach is to do so after the ugly phase, but many people decide to try it early.

Right now it looks like you have a less common start to the ugly phase, and instead of diatoms you see chrysophytes. They come in various shapes and can sometimes grow these "worm-like" filaments, but it's not a certain giveaway, we would need a microscope to verify. Both microalgae (diatoms and chrysophytes) use silicates that new substrate introduces into the tank or that might not have been fully filtered out by the Reverse Osmosis / Deionization (RO/DI) filtration system. As long as you make sure the water you use for your tank is properly deionized, both diatoms and chrysophytes will vanish on their own, but you will have to wait a few weeks. This process is totally normal and expected, I wouldn't worry about it.

To verify that the water is properly deionized, you need a "Total Dissolved Solids" (TDS) meter that can detect down to 1 ppm TDS. In some countries it is more common to measure the conductivity of the RO/DI water in µS/cm. Either way, both devices should display 0 for freshly made RO/DI. If RO/DI is sitting too long exposed to air (and therefore CO₂), the readings will increase. This doesn't make the water bad or unsuited for reef tank use, but it's important to measure freshly made water or the readings might be off. There are very useful "inline TDS meters" that can be directly connected to your RO/DI system's outlet if you are making your own RO/DI water. Once it shows 1 or 2ppm you need to replace the deionization resin that should be located in the very last filter cartridge(s) of your system. The other filters can usually be used much longer.

Edit:
You don't need to worry about nitrite, in comparison to freshwater nitrite is not dangerous in saltwater at realistically achievable levels. Your nitrate test will also display wrong readings while nitrite is present.
thank you for the detailed reply! after searching up chrysophytes, i am sure this is what they are. I did use a bulk reef aupply RODI 5 stage unit with a tds meter and the meter showed 0 ppm output. Now looking back I believe i washed the dry rock with tap water a few days before starting the tank. It may be a possibility that some tap water didnt full dry and may be the root cause of this. I have a Nicrew Nava reef 65 light for incoming corals but I have had it off most of the time. Should I keep the light on to help fight this or just let it be like you said? Thanks again!
 
Upvote 0
thank you for the detailed reply! after searching up chrysophytes, i am sure this is what they are. I did use a bulk reef aupply RODI 5 stage unit with a tds meter and the meter showed 0 ppm output. Now looking back I believe i washed the dry rock with tap water a few days before starting the tank. It may be a possibility that some tap water didnt full dry and may be the root cause of this. I have a Nicrew Nava reef 65 light for incoming corals but I have had it off most of the time. Should I keep the light on to help fight this or just let it be like you said? Thanks again!
Silicates are really hard to remove even with ion exchange resin, so some silicate nearly always comes through. You will also always have diatoms in your tank even if they have to take silica from your tank's glass. 😂
Their numbers will be limited though, and you won't notice them.

During the first months you will see a lot of different weird outbreaks that would be really annoying in established tanks, but are completely harmless in new tanks. So I suggest you just enjoy observing and embracing all the weird stuff that will be growing in your tank.
I can highly recommend getting a used microscope to observe everything in detail. This helps a little bit to pass the time until your tank becomes a thriving reef, and it helps with the identification of certain organisms. 😉

Regarding the lights: I don't think it matters much. Light will help with all sorts of algae growth, so it might make the tank look "worse", but it will grow anyway once your corals arrive and you need to have the lights on. If you already ordered corals, it might become difficult to provide stable nutrient (nitrate & phosphate) parameters once algae growth really takes off, considering your test is already incapable of detecting any phosphate (pretty normal for young tanks). It will be challenging to provide nutrients to your corals without simply feeding algae, so if your corals don't seem to be doing great, you might have to open another thread and get some advice on proper ammonia and phosphate dosing.
 
Upvote 0

TOP 10 Trending Threads

HOW WOULD YOU FEEL ABOUT RECEIVING A FISH OR CORAL AS A HOLIDAY GIFT?

  • I’d love one, as long as it’s a species I chose

    Votes: 19 27.9%
  • I’d trust someone who knows my tank to choose

    Votes: 2 2.9%
  • I’d rather get a gift card and pick it myself

    Votes: 26 38.2%
  • I’d prefer gear or supplies instead

    Votes: 2 2.9%
  • Please don’t surprise me with livestock

    Votes: 19 27.9%
  • Other (Post in the comments)

    Votes: 0 0.0%
Back
Top
Home
Post thread…
Market
What's new