Established Anthias Gasping at Surface, Other Fish Unaffected

Wandering Albatross

Well-Known Member
View Badges
Joined
Oct 1, 2024
Messages
888
Reaction score
430
Location
Whidbey Island, WA
What state or country do you live in
Washington
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
Wish it was a good morning. I have/had 3 disbar and 3 purple queen anthias. They've been in the tank for weeks/over a month. Eating well, very active, and save for the occasional posturing, no aggression between them. Several days ago, with no prior warning, one of the disbars started swimming upside down and sideways in circles. Weakly enough to be thrown by the flow they used to play in, and kept getting stuck on the powerheads. He'd also gasp and throw himself around at the surface, not quite jumping but close. After having to turn off nearly every powerhead in the tank to keep it from getting shredded further, I sumped it, hoping it would have a chance to recover if there was underlying aggression I wasn't seeing that was stressing it and keeping it in a less flow-y environment. Before sumping it took a 30min aeriated bath in a general pre-quarantine solution I had leftover that is complementary with every delivery from that vendor. At that point, with no physical signs of illness on the body, other than the shredded fins from being caught on every powerhead in my tank and gasping, I expected he wouldn't make it. He was lost sometime over the night. Another of the disbars is now showing the same signs, also with no warning or abnormal behavior prior, he's sumped for his safety, but not looking good, poking his head clean out of the water gasping. Purple queens are unaffected, remaining disbar is currently unaffected, all other tankmates also unaffected. I thought maybe uronema, as I also have 6 of the 7 blue/green chromis, and at one point a couple of those did get uronema, and all recovered but one. That was months ago, and none of them have been sick since. The chromis that was lost showed very distinct red lesions on his side, as did several that were ill during that time.

I'm not sure what to do for them at this point, no one else is currently affected, but the ones I lost went from fine to gone within roughly 24 hours. It makes it harder to narrow down when there was no abnormal behavior prior. After uronema I thought swim bladder because of the abnormal swimming sideways and upside down, as I've had 2 blennies affected by swim bladder/ internal issues in the past. At this point I'm stumped, any ideas? Something anthias specific, like when some wrasse just seem to lose their mind and die for no reason?

Blessings
 
Wish it was a good morning. I have/had 3 disbar and 3 purple queen anthias. They've been in the tank for weeks/over a month. Eating well, very active, and save for the occasional posturing, no aggression between them. Several days ago, with no prior warning, one of the disbars started swimming upside down and sideways in circles. Weakly enough to be thrown by the flow they used to play in, and kept getting stuck on the powerheads. He'd also gasp and throw himself around at the surface, not quite jumping but close. After having to turn off nearly every powerhead in the tank to keep it from getting shredded further, I sumped it, hoping it would have a chance to recover if there was underlying aggression I wasn't seeing that was stressing it and keeping it in a less flow-y environment. Before sumping it took a 30min aeriated bath in a general pre-quarantine solution I had leftover that is complementary with every delivery from that vendor. At that point, with no physical signs of illness on the body, other than the shredded fins from being caught on every powerhead in my tank and gasping, I expected he wouldn't make it. He was lost sometime over the night. Another of the disbars is now showing the same signs, also with no warning or abnormal behavior prior, he's sumped for his safety, but not looking good, poking his head clean out of the water gasping. Purple queens are unaffected, remaining disbar is currently unaffected, all other tankmates also unaffected. I thought maybe uronema, as I also have 6 of the 7 blue/green chromis, and at one point a couple of those did get uronema, and all recovered but one. That was months ago, and none of them have been sick since. The chromis that was lost showed very distinct red lesions on his side, as did several that were ill during that time.

I'm not sure what to do for them at this point, no one else is currently affected, but the ones I lost went from fine to gone within roughly 24 hours. It makes it harder to narrow down when there was no abnormal behavior prior. After uronema I thought swim bladder because of the abnormal swimming sideways and upside down, as I've had 2 blennies affected by swim bladder/ internal issues in the past. At this point I'm stumped, any ideas? Something anthias specific, like when some wrasse just seem to lose their mind and die for no reason?

Blessings
What foods are you feeding them and can you post pics under bright white light intensity of the remaining ones?
Gasping at the surface often suggests insufficient/low oxygen and can stem from water issue or gill issues.
If not already add air stone.
How are you testing the water despite tank being aged a little?
Are filters running properly, and not slowed down or component stopped running which can often be overlooked?
Assure salinity level has not dropped
 
What foods are you feeding them and can you post pics under bright white light intensity of the remaining ones?
Gasping at the surface often suggests insufficient/low oxygen and can stem from water issue or gill issues.
If not already add air stone.
How are you testing the water despite tank being aged a little?
Are filters running properly, and not slowed down or component stopped running which can often be overlooked?
Assure salinity level has not dropped
They get a mix of frozen mysis, pellets, and eggs 3x a day.
The surface is churning across the entire 5x2 area, skimmer is skimming well. Powerheads get brushed every other day or so, as I'm at the tail end of a cyano outbreak and the leftovers sometimes plug up the powerheads. Other fish aren't gasping which was why I ruled out oxygen for the tank as a whole.
Tests are mostly red sea for the main params, sailfert for cal, mag, and a backup for alk, as I've had odd readings from red sea while stabilizing alk which I attributed to testing error or kit failure.
I tested salinity this morning and it's still holding a pretty steady 1.025 and change. Seems to hold better there than at 1.026.
I'll try to get a pic if they'll hold still, they all used to cruise the tank as a group, both trios together. They get cranky when I fuss with the lights.
 
Yeah, soon as I turned down the blues everyone dove for cover and refused to take the white pics lol. These are what I got before that.
 

Attachments

  • IMG_1572.jpeg
    IMG_1572.jpeg
    159.9 KB · Views: 49
  • IMG_1573.jpeg
    IMG_1573.jpeg
    122.3 KB · Views: 46
  • IMG_1574.jpeg
    IMG_1574.jpeg
    149 KB · Views: 72
  • IMG_1572.jpeg
    IMG_1572.jpeg
    159.9 KB · Views: 59
Yeah, soon as I turned down the blues everyone dove for cover and refused to take the white pics lol. These are what I got before that.
I see nothing in form of disease as you noted and I do see Cyano , which suggests high or elevated nitrate levels and often when cyano develops. there is a likelihood of inadequate water flow, overfeeding, overstocking quickly need for skimming/skimmer, and lack of water changes
 
Having 2 fish dying (that are susceptible to uronema ) with others being healthy - in a tank where 6 /7 fish died of uromena. Suggest it MAY be playing a role. uronema lives best in tanks that are somewhat dirty (your water looks somewhat cloudy to me). Uronema has specific symptoms usually - and one can see the infection. So - I wonder about aggression that you aren't seeing. I also wonder If the whirling etc is merely a weak fish being blown by the current. If not this suggests more of a neurolologic issue - possibly a virus.

PS- Usually, jumping at the surface repeatedly suggest a problem in the tank - whether low Oxygen or something else. It usually though, would affect all fish not just the anthias. Hope this helps
 
Having 2 fish dying (that are susceptible to uronema ) with others being healthy - in a tank where 6 /7 fish died of uromena. Suggest it MAY be playing a role. uronema lives best in tanks that are somewhat dirty (your water looks somewhat cloudy to me). Uronema has specific symptoms usually - and one can see the infection. So - I wonder about aggression that you aren't seeing. I also wonder If the whirling etc is merely a weak fish being blown by the current. If not this suggests more of a neurolologic issue - possibly a virus.

PS- Usually, jumping at the surface repeatedly suggest a problem in the tank - whether low Oxygen or something else. It usually though, would affect all fish not just the anthias. Hope this helps
Only 1 of the 7 chromis with uronema died, the other 6 are alive and chunky, sorry must have worded that poorly. The spinning fish was at least trying to swim sometimes, he just kept going in these odd oblong sideways/upside down circles. The first one even stopped twice for about 45 seconds and would swim perfectly normal in their shared cave, then be back to freaking out up in the water column. I've never observed nipping, shoving, or chasing from any of my anthias. Closest was when 2 would go shoulder to shoulder and posture, but they never made contact, and left no ripped fins or missing scales. They'd all 3 swim in formation after like nothing happened. I'm just confused that it happened one after the other, I'd think a tank-wide problem would affect everyone.
 
I see nothing in form of disease as you noted and I do see Cyano , which suggests high or elevated nitrate levels and often when cyano develops. there is a likelihood of inadequate water flow, overfeeding, overstocking quickly need for skimming/skimmer, and lack of water changes
As rough as it looks, it's actually fading and doing eons better than it was. Been dancing the line between beating back the comparatively easier cyano, and preventing dinos from clawing their way back. Been a bit of a fight while waiting for the coralline to establish itself. I've been careful with my skimmer cause I've accidently over skimmed on several occasions and ended up with dinos coming back. I also have been dosing both live phyto and microbacter, which the latter has been known to cause temporary cloudiness. The sifter gobies are probably contributing to the cloudy water too, they're still working the finer particles out.

I'll retest and run a water change, see if nitrates have risen outside their normal levels. I thought we were doing good when the cyano started retreating and getting replaced with the light and much nicer film algae the grazers all like. I doubt it'll help the currently afflicted disbar at this point, but if something is in there it might help the others before they get it.
 
As rough as it looks, it's actually fading and doing eons better than it was. Been dancing the line between beating back the comparatively easier cyano, and preventing dinos from clawing their way back. Been a bit of a fight while waiting for the coralline to establish itself. I've been careful with my skimmer cause I've accidently over skimmed on several occasions and ended up with dinos coming back. I also have been dosing both live phyto and microbacter, which the latter has been known to cause temporary cloudiness. The sifter gobies are probably contributing to the cloudy water too, they're still working the finer particles out.

I'll retest and run a water change, see if nitrates have risen outside their normal levels. I thought we were doing good when the cyano started retreating and getting replaced with the light and much nicer film algae the grazers all like. I doubt it'll help the currently afflicted disbar at this point, but if something is in there it might help the others before they get it.
I totally get your concerns. Do a few daily water changes 2-3 gals each day to reduce higher levels slowly and do this over 5 days:
I recommend to reduce white light intensity or even turn them off for 3-5 days. Add liquid bacteria daily for a week during the day at 1.5ml per 10 gallons. Add Hydrogen peroxide at night at 1ml per 10 gallons. Add a pouch of chemipure Elite which will balance phos and nitrate and keep them in check.

After the 5 days, add a few snails such as cerith, margarita, astrea and nassarius plus 6-8 blue leg hermits to take control.
 
I totally get your concerns. Do a few daily water changes 2-3 gals each day to reduce higher levels slowly and do this over 5 days:
I recommend to reduce white light intensity or even turn them off for 3-5 days. Add liquid bacteria daily for a week during the day at 1.5ml per 10 gallons. Add Hydrogen peroxide at night at 1ml per 10 gallons. Add a pouch of chemipure Elite which will balance phos and nitrate and keep them in check.

After the 5 days, add a few snails such as cerith, margarita, astrea and nassarius plus 6-8 blue leg hermits to take control.
I have a dozen or so snails I see regularly and a couple crabs that love it, and they do work on it, they are just taking their sweet time. The tangs will pick at some of the cyano I found, and the sifter goby grinds it up and seems to eat it too. Used to have dino strings over cyano on the sand and back wall. I'm not sure what started really helping, or if it was just time, but I went from scraping the back wall every other day to keep it down, to hardly seeing any on the walls at all. The cyano was mostly gone, the dinos in that spot, and even the gha that popped up during the worst of the battle didn't come back. Just a very fine, even, nearly impossible to see film algae which I don't take issue with. The sand is also looking much better, even in the lower flow areas as the goby works his way around the rockwork in a circle. With how well he's done so far, I think once he gets it caught up, it won't get out of hand again. Maybe from stirring in a lower flow area, maybe he's actually eating it, maybe he's eating what feeds it, not sure, but he's helping the sandbed immensely. It's really just the rocks at this point and scraping the occasional floating chucks that haven't dissolved yet from the pumps. I'll draw up some more saltwater for a few more back to back water changes and see if I can't find some hydrogen peroxide. I get a little nervous adding chemicals or anything that has an -oxide to a closed system, especially when some of the medications and/or algae treatments have mixed reviews on being invert-safe.
 
I have a dozen or so snails I see regularly and a couple crabs that love it, and they do work on it, they are just taking their sweet time. The tangs will pick at some of the cyano I found, and the sifter goby grinds it up and seems to eat it too. Used to have dino strings over cyano on the sand and back wall. I'm not sure what started really helping, or if it was just time, but I went from scraping the back wall every other day to keep it down, to hardly seeing any on the walls at all. The cyano was mostly gone, the dinos in that spot, and even the gha that popped up during the worst of the battle didn't come back. Just a very fine, even, nearly impossible to see film algae which I don't take issue with. The sand is also looking much better, even in the lower flow areas as the goby works his way around the rockwork in a circle. With how well he's done so far, I think once he gets it caught up, it won't get out of hand again. Maybe from stirring in a lower flow area, maybe he's actually eating it, maybe he's eating what feeds it, not sure, but he's helping the sandbed immensely. It's really just the rocks at this point and scraping the occasional floating chucks that haven't dissolved yet from the pumps. I'll draw up some more saltwater for a few more back to back water changes and see if I can't find some hydrogen peroxide. I get a little nervous adding chemicals or anything that has an -oxide to a closed system, especially when some of the medications and/or algae treatments have mixed reviews on being invert-safe.
Problem with cleaner crew is the cyano grows faster than they can consume it and reason for the 5 day plan I mentioned which will drastically slow it down
Peroxide is readily available at walmart and grocery stores
 
I have dosed a lot of H2O2 for different reasons. The only negative reactions I have ever had were Zola’s and Palys closing up when it first hits them and peppermint shrimp which seem to be extra sensitive to it. I actually had a couple die before I saw the connection.
 
I have dosed a lot of H2O2 for different reasons. The only negative reactions I have ever had were Zola’s and Palys closing up when it first hits them and peppermint shrimp which seem to be extra sensitive to it. I actually had a couple die before I saw the connection.

All Lysmata shrimp are very sensitive to H2O2, probably other shrimp as well.
 
Wish it was a good morning. I have/had 3 disbar and 3 purple queen anthias. They've been in the tank for weeks/over a month. Eating well, very active, and save for the occasional posturing, no aggression between them. Several days ago, with no prior warning, one of the disbars started swimming upside down and sideways in circles. Weakly enough to be thrown by the flow they used to play in, and kept getting stuck on the powerheads. He'd also gasp and throw himself around at the surface, not quite jumping but close. After having to turn off nearly every powerhead in the tank to keep it from getting shredded further, I sumped it, hoping it would have a chance to recover if there was underlying aggression I wasn't seeing that was stressing it and keeping it in a less flow-y environment. Before sumping it took a 30min aeriated bath in a general pre-quarantine solution I had leftover that is complementary with every delivery from that vendor. At that point, with no physical signs of illness on the body, other than the shredded fins from being caught on every powerhead in my tank and gasping, I expected he wouldn't make it. He was lost sometime over the night. Another of the disbars is now showing the same signs, also with no warning or abnormal behavior prior, he's sumped for his safety, but not looking good, poking his head clean out of the water gasping. Purple queens are unaffected, remaining disbar is currently unaffected, all other tankmates also unaffected. I thought maybe uronema, as I also have 6 of the 7 blue/green chromis, and at one point a couple of those did get uronema, and all recovered but one. That was months ago, and none of them have been sick since. The chromis that was lost showed very distinct red lesions on his side, as did several that were ill during that time.

I'm not sure what to do for them at this point, no one else is currently affected, but the ones I lost went from fine to gone within roughly 24 hours. It makes it harder to narrow down when there was no abnormal behavior prior. After uronema I thought swim bladder because of the abnormal swimming sideways and upside down, as I've had 2 blennies affected by swim bladder/ internal issues in the past. At this point I'm stumped, any ideas? Something anthias specific, like when some wrasse just seem to lose their mind and die for no reason?

Blessings

Without the typical vertical lesions on their sides, I would doubt that this is Uronema. I read through this, but may have missed it - does the tank have good aeration, not just water circulation? Anthias have very high oxygen requirements, and maybe the O2 was borderline low for them.
 
Without the typical vertical lesions on their sides, I would doubt that this is Uronema. I read through this, but may have missed it - does the tank have good aeration, not just water circulation? Anthias have very high oxygen requirements, and maybe the O2 was borderline low for them.
I have the surface rolling steadily, the gyre pushes 4000-some-odd gph, pointed up towards the surface. If it were any higher the initial waves would probably touch the screen cover.

I also skim off and on during the day as needed, usually I run the skimmer overnight to catch anything that might break up into the water column at night. There is a second gyre on the opposing end, pointed down to push all that oxygenated water down towards the sand. Several other pumps push that water all over the place. I also have a fuge and a surface-agitating much smaller powerhead in the sump for flow around said fuge area. The tank also happens to be situated partially under a ceiling fan that I normally have running in the summer if that helps.

Everything is running full power, I can't imagine how even after all that the oxygen could be low for one fish at the time, then after a few days be low for another, without affecting anyone else. The gasping made me consider that oxygen was an issue, but I thought it would be more widespread. And these guys have been in for a while, totally active and healthy.
 
All Lysmata shrimp are very sensitive to H2O2, probably other shrimp as well.
I have penderson cleaners, a cleaner, harlequins, pithos, porcelain, and a couple baby blue leg hermit crabs, and a clam.
 
What about cyanide collection? Where were they sourced?
Saltwaterfish.com. Where they get them from, I don't know. Only that they were healthy and active for over a month and are going one by one with no warning.
 
I have the surface rolling steadily, the gyre pushes 4000-some-odd gph, pointed up towards the surface. If it were any higher the initial waves would probably touch the screen cover.

I also skim off and on during the day as needed, usually I run the skimmer overnight to catch anything that might break up into the water column at night.
I think this is at least part of your problem. The algae and bacteria in your tank use oxygen as well. The jumping at the surface suggests that - I would not turn your skimmer off and on - do you have a good reason to do so? And I think part of the problem you say you skim off and on during the day 'as neeeded' - by the time 'its needed' there is going to be a lower oxygen concentration. I would just set it and leave it alone - unless you have a good reason to do so. Your water (at least in the pictures) looks cloudy - perhaps thats just the photo.

The best way to get rid of cyano IME is to syphon it off late in the afternoon when it's at max growth - and replace that water with fresh (that usually will be a couple gallons. It a week or so it should be much improved. Based on your earlier comments you may be feeding/supplementing too much?
 
Saltwaterfish.com. Where they get them from, I don't know. Only that they were healthy and active for over a month and are going one by one with no warning.

That seems a bit too long for it to be residual cyanide poisoning.
 

TOP 10 Trending Threads

HOW DO YOU HANDLE HOLIDAY DECORATING AROUND YOUR REEF?

  • I decorate the tank or stand

    Votes: 1 4.5%
  • I decorate AROUND the tank or stand

    Votes: 4 18.2%
  • I add one small seasonal touch but keep it very basic

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • I take a holiday photo, but don’t decorate the space

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • I leave the reef area as it is

    Votes: 13 59.1%
  • We don’t decorate for the holidays

    Votes: 4 18.2%
  • Other (Post in the comments)

    Votes: 0 0.0%
Back
Top
Home
Post thread…
Market
What's new