Feeling Gutted - Suspected PBT with Ich

  • Thread starter Thread starter Lostoften
  • Start date Start date
  • Tagged users Tagged users None
Well my stupidity or bad luck strike again. Lost the gem tang this morning. Yesterday seemed fine, but salinity was high added RO water. Lowered it more than expected 1.029 to 1.025 all at once. This morning came down and gem was against the filter. Attempted water change but was too little too late. Hang on badge showed alert, 0.05 and Salifert <0.15. I didn’t take time to do Hanna test for ammonia.

This fish was in the same tank that I lost the carpenter. I had not started copper as have one fish remaining in display.

Will post videos of gem, and other tank to see if signs of anything else going on.
 
Gem has had stress marks since moving into the QT,

Gem Dying

The PBT and Clowns are on around day 20 of copper treatment
PBT and Clowns

These aren't in copper yet, was waiting to catch the last anthia
75G
 
Not likely that a salinity change from high to low killed your Gem. You should start copper treatment regardless of if you still need to add some fish later. Just extend the QT period.
 
Well my stupidity or bad luck strike again. Lost the gem tang this morning. Yesterday seemed fine, but salinity was high added RO water. Lowered it more than expected 1.029 to 1.025 all at once. This morning came down and gem was against the filter. Attempted water change but was too little too late. Hang on badge showed alert, 0.05 and Salifert <0.15. I didn’t take time to do Hanna test for ammonia.

This fish was in the same tank that I lost the carpenter. I had not started copper as have one fish remaining in display.

Will post videos of gem, and other tank to see if signs of anything else going on.

I can view the videos. I didn’t see much of note in the second and third one (I’m working on my phone with a small screen though).

The salinity drop didn’t cause this issue and likely wasn’t even a contributing factor. Fish handle salinity drops very well.

The gem tang has an acute parasitic infection of some sort. Could be flukes, velvet or brooklynella. Trouble is, there really isn’t a good way to tell these apart without a microscope to do a skin scrape.
 
The gem tang didn't make it much longer than when the video was taken. Possibly the stress of the QT allowed it to be susceptible to the disease.

I captured the last anthia, so the display tank is now fallow. Picked up a 100 gallon stock tank and drained the majority of water to catch him. 60 days fallow starting tomorrow. Will move some corals from QT since display will be fallow anyway.

Plan to dose the 75g with copper tomorrow, imagine will take right around 80ml of coppersafe to reach therapeutic. Will start with a 40ml dose and then do 2-3 smaller doses.

After copper, should I treat for flukes with prazi?
 
The gem tang didn't make it much longer than when the video was taken. Possibly the stress of the QT allowed it to be susceptible to the disease.

I captured the last anthia, so the display tank is now fallow. Picked up a 100 gallon stock tank and drained the majority of water to catch him. 60 days fallow starting tomorrow. Will move some corals from QT since display will be fallow anyway.

Plan to dose the 75g with copper tomorrow, imagine will take right around 80ml of coppersafe to reach therapeutic. Will start with a 40ml dose and then do 2-3 smaller doses.

After copper, should I treat for flukes with prazi?

Normally, I do suggest treating with prazi after copper, but since we don't know if the issue here is protozoan or flukes, you might have to consider dosing copper and prazi at the same time - if you do that, get pure prazi powder, not GC or Prazipro (as those two meds have more side effects).
 
Sigh, breaking down the qt to treat with vinegar and dry out before restarting. I never added the sponge pad from qt to HOB. Reasonable to think that the large top off changed pH resulting in an ammonia spike?
 
Sigh, breaking down the qt to treat with vinegar and dry out before restarting. I never added the sponge pad from qt to HOB. Reasonable to think that the large top off changed pH resulting in an ammonia spike?
Sorry - you kinda lost me here.

Typically, unless the pH was really depressed, a large water changes diluted the ammonia enough that the residual ammonia is not too toxic, despite the rise in oh.
 
Well, unfortunately looks like the PBT has ICH again. Unless, this is signs of stress from fighting/aggression with the other fish.

All fish were removed from fish tank, for more than 60 days. The tang was run through 30 days of copper, never below 2.2 usually closer to 2.5 measured by Hanna. The other fish came back to tank well before the PBT and Bristle tooth tang. They remained in a separate 29gallon tank while the new yellow tang finished the qt protocol. All tanks in basement are greater than 6 feet apart. No equipment is shared between tanks, and hands are washed between all tanks. No fish showed any issue in display until the PBT.

The three tangs went into the tank on 12/19. I noticed markings on the PBT 7-10 days later.

The PBT is eating fine and appears to breathing fine. I have noticed him tail whipping the back of the tank/side of tank but no darting or smacking the sand bed. He also has been the only fish allowing the cleaner shrimp to "clean" him.

The tank still has LCA dino's that I have been dealing with and phosphates are higher than would like 0.2-0.3. Nitrates are 15-20. Feeding: 2-4 sheets of Nori per day (3 tangs and foxface), mysis at least once a day, rotation of reef frenzy, TDO pellets, fish frenzy, ROE or artic pods.

Ich again

2nd Video

3rd video

4th Video

Appreciate any insights or thoughts. Imagine I will attempt Ich management strategy as obviously I have some gap/failure point in the qt process as most of these fish have been through QT twice now.
 
Well, unfortunately looks like the PBT has ICH again. Unless, this is signs of stress from fighting/aggression with the other fish.

All fish were removed from fish tank, for more than 60 days. The tang was run through 30 days of copper, never below 2.2 usually closer to 2.5 measured by Hanna. The other fish came back to tank well before the PBT and Bristle tooth tang. They remained in a separate 29gallon tank while the new yellow tang finished the qt protocol. All tanks in basement are greater than 6 feet apart. No equipment is shared between tanks, and hands are washed between all tanks. No fish showed any issue in display until the PBT.

The three tangs went into the tank on 12/19. I noticed markings on the PBT 7-10 days later.

The PBT is eating fine and appears to breathing fine. I have noticed him tail whipping the back of the tank/side of tank but no darting or smacking the sand bed. He also has been the only fish allowing the cleaner shrimp to "clean" him.

The tank still has LCA dino's that I have been dealing with and phosphates are higher than would like 0.2-0.3. Nitrates are 15-20. Feeding: 2-4 sheets of Nori per day (3 tangs and foxface), mysis at least once a day, rotation of reef frenzy, TDO pellets, fish frenzy, ROE or artic pods.

Ich again

2nd Video

3rd video

4th Video

Appreciate any insights or thoughts. Imagine I will attempt Ich management strategy as obviously I have some gap/failure point in the qt process as most of these fish have been through QT twice now.

My thoughts are that these are mucus plugs. They are very large and raised up, I also don't see any spots on the fins. With ich, the spots are usually smaller, not as raised and are more frequently seen on the fins.

The PBT has good body condition, but it is a bit dark in color and breathing fast. Was that because it was spooked by your presence while videoing it?

The posturing in front of cleaner shrimp often signals skin flukes. Are you seeing any fish flashing or scratching?

Mucus plugs come about due to some stressor. Trouble is, ich can be one of those stressors.


I also don't see any spots on the other fish.
 
How quickly does Ich typically progress? I leave on the 22nd and not back until the 28th.

When I lost the initial stocking, it progressed pretty quickly.
What does that lost the initial stocking mean?

Did you have an ich problem previously in the tank?
 
I have seen the leopard wrasse flash against the sand bed a couple of times, but assumed this was just looking for food. I haven't seen any fish exhibit repetitive flashing or darting. The fish were definitely startled and hiding more as I increased the white light percentage and dropped blue for the video. I do see some opaque marks on the PBT fins, however not sure if this is more injury than ICH. However, I don't see any other markings on other fish.
 
It’s always good to qt so as to not introduce anything new into the tank, but it’s my understanding that if you’ve had ich, and you don’t go fallow in the tank or start over completely, your tank has ich and you are like most of us and have to go with an ich management approach.


Sorry you lost your gem tang. Nice fish.
 
What does that lost the initial stocking mean?

Did you have an ich problem previously in the tank?
I had a total loss of all the fish in the tank, roughly 18 months ago. Unfortunately videos weren't able to confirm the cause, and symptoms didn't really point to one specific disease.

I then quarantined the whole restocking of the tank following the current protocol. This thread starts off with the problems the PBT experienced, which was believed to be mucus plugs/ICH. I removed all fish for 60 days and ran them through 30 days of copper. I lost a Gem tang and carpenters wrasse in the process. I replaced them with the yellow and mystery wrasse, all which went through the current qt protocol.

@Jay Hemdal the color may be darker as this is a hybrid PBT with the white cheek tang.
 
I have seen the leopard wrasse flash against the sand bed a couple of times, but assumed this was just looking for food. I haven't seen any fish exhibit repetitive flashing or darting. The fish were definitely startled and hiding more as I increased the white light percentage and dropped blue for the video. I do see some opaque marks on the PBT fins, however not sure if this is more injury than ICH. However, I don't see any other markings on other fish.
Leopard and other wrasses will do this at times. The PBT is susctible to skin irritations as well as Hepatus blue tangs. Often other fish will show No signs. At times, these are mixed in with ich and again you will notice other occupants show no signs but recommended is to remove all fish and treat them as well using coppersafe or copper power for a full 30 days at 2.25ppm which they respond to well and add an air stone and monitor copper level with a reliable Copper Test kit such as Hanna Brand- No API brand. Also monitor Ammonia levels while in quarantine with a reliable test kit and add aeration during treatment using an air stone.
 

TOP 10 Trending Threads

HOW WOULD YOU FEEL ABOUT RECEIVING A FISH OR CORAL AS A HOLIDAY GIFT?

  • I’d love one, as long as it’s a species I chose

    Votes: 14 35.9%
  • I’d trust someone who knows my tank to choose

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • I’d rather get a gift card and pick it myself

    Votes: 14 35.9%
  • I’d prefer gear or supplies instead

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • Please don’t surprise me with livestock

    Votes: 11 28.2%
  • Other (Post in the comments)

    Votes: 0 0.0%
Back
Top
Home
Post thread…
Market
What's new