Fish hiding in live rock, stuck?

[Saul T]

I think my royal gramma may be sick or stuck in the live rock, if that’s possible.

I saw his tail yesterday sticking out of a hole, but today no sign. He usually comes out for feeding but was a no show yesterday. He was swimming vertical the other day. I did a water change the day before he started hiding.

Obviously want to avoid harming any other fish, but should I try to get in there and find him or just leave him be?

 

[MnFish1]

How old is the fish? What are your Parameters? Do you have other fish in the tank? Did you quarantine it? Did the fish have any other symptoms? Generally speaking it's not that helpful to try to find a fish - However, If you have a small tank - and you're worried about the possibility that it could mess up your parameters if it dies, I would consider trying to remove it if you don't see it for a couple days. Could it be being chased by another fish - Check at different times in the day. Hope this helps - and hope he pops out!

 

[Saul T]

Hi @MnFish1! I’m not sure how old he is as I got him at the pet store. But was fine for about a month. There are two other fish in the tank a clownfish and cardinal, they all get along well (what I’ve seen at least

Parameters are all within acceptable range, I have no coral so I just test basic attributes.

The only other thing that happened is the vertical swimming a day after water change, and of course the hiding. But may be unrelated? I’ll update if he pops out

 

[Saul T]

It’s a Fluval 13.5

 

[MnFish1]

It’s a Fluval 13.5

How difficult would it be to get out of the tank? Have you checked to make sure it didn't jump - or somehow get into the filter?

 

[Saul T]

How difficult would it be to get out of the tank? Have you checked to make sure it didn't jump - or somehow get into the filter, it is possible due to an opening in my lid. Luckily I didn’t find him outside. I did see his tail in the live rock yesterday and I still believe he’s there.

It’s possible he could jump through a hole in my lid, but luckily I didn’t find him outside.
I saw his tail yesterday, so I think he’s still in a live rock.

 

[KrisReef]

How many hours do you have the light on in the tank? It might be trying to get some shut eye?

 

[Paul B]

If he is alive he is not stuck. Fish don't really get stuck and if he is in a rock it's because he wants to be in there. If he dies, he was going to die anyway.

 

[Saul T]

Yeah the light has been off. If he is dead I need to get him out of that live rock so the others aren’t affected. Sucks. How long should I wait?

 

[Saul T]

I don’t want to overreact, like if hes just hanging out or needs alone time (if that’s a thing). But it’s unusual based on past behavior.

 

[Jay Hemdal]

I don’t want to overreact, like if hes just hanging out or needs alone time (if that’s a thing). But it’s unusual based on past behavior.

That vertical swimming could be a clue - it can be normal for this species (they like to follow surfaces, so it could have just been hugging the tank wall) but it also could have been a sign of stress called “piping”. Did you happen to notice if it was breathing fast when it was swimming vertically?

Jay

 

[MnFish1]

I would try to take it out

 

[Saul T]

I just tested all parameters and it still seems good. I didn’t notice it breathing hard, I should have looked closer. I guess I should get in there and lift up live rock and see what happens. If he’s still alive I’ll give a description… thanks for all the support and advice!

 

[MnFish1]

I just tested all parameters and it still seems good. I didn’t notice it breathing hard, I should have looked closer. I guess I should get in there and lift up live rock and see what happens. If he’s still alive I’ll give a description… thanks for all the support and advice!

Agreed

 

[Saul T]

update: sorry to say he didn’t make it. I pulled him out of the hole and put the rock back.

But thanks again for helping out. Awesome community here

 

[EeyoreIsMySpiritAnimal]

So sorry for your loss.

 

[Saul T]

Thank you