Flow! Why is this the hardest part?

DesktopDiver

Community Member
View Badges
Joined
Nov 12, 2024
Messages
38
Reaction score
16
Location
London, UK
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
I'm really struggling with flow in my Fluval Evo 52l.



I have a sicce as the return pump, and have just added a 8w hygger wavemaker.



The wavemaker is on flow level 1 (out of 20) and the sicce pump is at the lowest option.



The mushrooms look like they're being battered! And I'm worried about the blue striped pipefish. Will he get used to it? Or is this too much flow?



Should I take the wavemaker out? Reposition it?



I can see the sand is a lot cleaner, so that's good at least.



Help me please



 
Looks good to me. You should see the flow in my tank. :)

However, I didn’t really see the mushroom or pipefish in the video. Maybe others with more experience will have different opinions.
 
You shouldn’t change the flow for one coral, you are very unlikely to get everything in the tank at the perfect flow, if everything else is happy you can move the coral that is unhappy.

When you say mushroom, do you mean toadstool?

A mushroom if happy with flow should have its edges flat against a rock or sand, if the edges are slightly tucked under then it is trying to hold on so is in too much flow.

You can always point the power head up towards the water surface more to reduce flow if you feel its needed.
 
You will need to watch your flow especially with the pipe fish. Pipefish and seahorses prefer low flow tanks. They typically are not "aggressive" feeders and are easily out competed for food by other species like the clown i think i saw in your video.. also looks like you have a dragonet in there which competes with the pipe for the pod population in your tank. Mushrooms can adapt to a tank with higher flow as long as they are not being hit directly.

My 30 gallon had 2 flow pumps moving close to 1000gl per hour. The one on mushroom side pushed water over the top to miss them and hit bottom the other directed at surface so flow was broken up by time it came down the other wall on top of shrooms. Not sure how long youve had the pipe and dragonet but you may want to make sure pumls are off when you feed and try to target feed to make sure they get enough.
 
You shouldn’t change the flow for one coral, you are very unlikely to get everything in the tank at the perfect flow, if everything else is happy you can move the coral that is unhappy.

When you say mushroom, do you mean toadstool?

A mushroom if happy with flow should have its edges flat against a rock or sand, if the edges are slightly tucked under then it is trying to hold on so is in too much flow.

You can always point the power head up towards the water surface more to reduce flow if you feel its needed.
It's a green furry mushroom coral, has split from one to four since I got it 5 weeks ago. They're all currently cupped up like a goblet. Which they've been doing the last few days, before I added the extra flow. I think they're still healing from the split.
 
You will need to watch your flow especially with the pipe fish. Pipefish and seahorses prefer low flow tanks. They typically are not "aggressive" feeders and are easily out competed for food by other species like the clown i think i saw in your video.. also looks like you have a dragonet in there which competes with the pipe for the pod population in your tank. Mushrooms can adapt to a tank with higher flow as long as they are not being hit directly.

My 30 gallon had 2 flow pumps moving close to 1000gl per hour. The one on mushroom side pushed water over the top to miss them and hit bottom the other directed at surface so flow was broken up by time it came down the other wall on top of shrooms. Not sure how long youve had the pipe and dragonet but you may want to make sure pumls are off when you feed and try to target feed to make sure they get enough.
I've had the pipe and dragonet two months now, they were my first fish :smiling-face-with-smiling-eyes: Both eat frozen and freeze dried foods. And I seed the tank with copepods and freshly hatched brine shrimp every couple of days for them. I will make sure the pump is off for feeding.

Having just turned the pump off for the evening feed, and the pipefish coming straight out his little cave, I think I'm going to leave the pump off overnight, and just run it during the day. Gives him a chance to come out and hunt at night, and then daytime flow to get all the crap off the sand.

Now to work out how to do that with the Hygger, thinking a wifi plug.
 
One of the most challenging aspects of "mixed" tanks (ie any tank that isn't aimed specifically to recreate one area of the reef) is keeping everyone happy. It gets much more difficult as the tank gets smaller.

I would personally have that powerhead blowing into something - for example that large rock on the left. that will disperse the flow. You could also put the wavemaker on a timer but it will likely decrease the lifespan of the unit. My main concern is that the pipefish is happy, as he is the toughest to provide for and will be most prone to discomfort.

Adding more rock might help break up the flow too and allow for some more dead zones, but I know that can be tough in a small tank where you want to maintain open areas. The softies will appreciate the flow while mushroom coral will prefer the the quieter zones.
 
The flow looks good, can even turn it up a notch. Don't mess with the flow, instead, move the mushroom to a spot that has low flow.

But I do agree, getting the flow right for every inhabitant in the tank is extremely difficult.
 
OK, as I'm on the office all next week, I think I'm going to wait to play with the flow till next weekend, when I can sit and watch.

More rock is a good idea, to help break it up. Will have a think.

Thank you all, and thank you for confirming that it's hard! Makes me feel like I'm not completely failing
 

TOP 10 Trending Threads

HOW WOULD YOU FEEL ABOUT RECEIVING A FISH OR CORAL AS A HOLIDAY GIFT?

  • I’d love one, as long as it’s a species I chose

    Votes: 21 25.6%
  • I’d trust someone who knows my tank to choose

    Votes: 8 9.8%
  • I’d rather get a gift card and pick it myself

    Votes: 30 36.6%
  • I’d prefer gear or supplies instead

    Votes: 2 2.4%
  • Please don’t surprise me with livestock

    Votes: 21 25.6%
  • Other (Post in the comments)

    Votes: 0 0.0%
Back
Top
Home
Post thread…
Market
What's new