Help me choose a UV filter

[vanguard]

I'm waiting on the arrival of a 150 gallon tank. I want to run a UV filter on it for clear water and maybe some parasite or bacteria help, depending on the flow I send to it.


My primary choices are the 40 watt pentair and the 40 watt ice cap filters:

Smart UV Sterilizer 40 Watt

Emperor Aquatics is now Pentair Aquatic Eco-Systems. Why does BRS recommend this? When it comes to UV most other companies will recommend a small UV for a large tank which in reality won’t do much more than make your water look a bit clearer. If your ultimate goal is to keep bacteria...

www.bulkreefsupply.com

40 Watt High Output UV Sterilizer

The IceCap UV sterilizers can be used on saltwater, freshwater, and ponds to help control and even eradicate parasites, algae, fungi, bacteria, and protozoa without any harmful chemicals or biocides. When set up, maintained, and properly operated; free-floating microorganisms will be killed by...

www.bulkreefsupply.com

The ice cap is smaller and cheaper but seems to have the same filtering strength. I'm kind of wondering why anybody would choose anything else. Do you have any good reasons to go with one over the other?

 

[Derrick0580]

I was running a 25 watt aqua uv on my 120 but recently upgraded it to a 57 watt since the bulbs are the same length. Just had to buy the 57 watt ballast and bulb and fit perfectly into the 25 watt body.

 

[vtecintegra]

I would say pentair, but there are too many negative reviews. I've got an 57 watt aqua uv, but they are insanely expensive for basically a pvc tube. I would try to find a used one unless money is not an issue. Take a look at bulb cost. You will need a new one every year. I found a generic bulb for the aqua uv on amazon. Otherwise, the bulbs can be ridiculously expensive.

 

[vanguard]

Take a look at bulb cost. You will need a new one every year.

Thanks for the good advice.

UV Sterilizer Replacement Lamp

Keep your IceCap UV sterilizer performing its best With time, UV sterilizers can become less effective as the UV lamp inside degrades. To keep your UV sterilizer operating at peak performance, the lamp should be replaced every 10,000 hours, or about once per year. 27w UV Lamp Compatible with...

www.bulkreefsupply.com

Replacement UV Lamp

Pentair replacement UV Lamps are made of high quality quartz glass and offer 13 months (9,000 hours) of continual operation of lamp life. Available in three sizes 18W Replacement UV Lamp for Aquarium 18W SMART UV Sterilizers. 25W Replacement UV Lamp for Aquarium 25W SMART UV Sterilizers...

www.bulkreefsupply.com

It's $40 vs $75. Neither of those is TOO bad considering the overall cost of the hobby but it still leaves me wondering why anybody would get something other than the IceCap?

 

[Enderg60]

Id go for the Pentair unless you have space issues.

Ive used AquaUV (had a single then a daul 57w) as well as Pentair( had a 40w, made a broken 40w into an 80w, and had a 150w).

Both brands have bad reviews. I can say over the last 15 years I never had an issue with any of them.

I would also advice against "cheap" bulbs. UVs are the one thing that no one can test and compare like we can with other lights and PAR meters. You simply have no idea if the off brand bulb is producing the same amount of light or if its even the right wavelength.

Also look at radiation vs flow rates to make sure youre getting what you want out of your UV. For example the dual 57w AquaUV needs 150 gph to be effective with ich.