In light of the recent concern with Vibrant containing polyquat and a massive usage, it might be a good idea to discuss how it works.
I have studied this pretty hard and asked some experts, even though very little about saltwater and nothing about aquariums seems to exist beyond anecdotes. I am not positive that any of this is correct, but I will lay it out as a starting point and we can edit it later.
What seems to be...
Some past discussion:
https://www.reef2reef.com/threads/polyquat-stability-in-reef-tank.872904/
I have studied this pretty hard and asked some experts, even though very little about saltwater and nothing about aquariums seems to exist beyond anecdotes. I am not positive that any of this is correct, but I will lay it out as a starting point and we can edit it later.
What seems to be...
- It has different results in freshwater than in saltwater, but lets focus on saltwater
- Polyquat is a strong flocculant - it can make water clear
- It will bind to any negatively charged surface seemingly indiscriminately - most live tissue is negatively charged and perhaps even rock and sand
- It will stay bound until either absorbed into the organic tissue or perhaps just stay bound forever, or at least quite a while - polyquat is very stable
- Water column will be free of the polyquat quickly, but it will be in the aquarium still bound to who-knows-what
- Does not target algae over any other organic compound
- Seems to have different/faster effect on newer tanks with less diversity - seemingly less bio material for it to be bound to outside of the desired algae
- Reported to have effects long after dosing
- If bound to something in the water column, might be skimmed out or removed by GAC or other media
- With the amount of organic material, rock and sand varying from tank to tank, this is why results (both good and bad) have such a wide range of dosages and time required for things to work
Some past discussion:
https://www.reef2reef.com/threads/polyquat-stability-in-reef-tank.872904/
Last edited:
