ICP test - high iodine?

[AquAttila]

I usually perform an ICP test every 3 months on my aquariums. This time around both, my 210 gal and 65 gal RSM showing high levels of IODINE. I know that it is difficult to test for Iodine and I do have a Salifert kit and it is actually showing "0" - so not sure what to make of this or if anyone has run into this... I am not even sure how I would go about trying to lower this and get accurate result. Do I trust the Iodine results from ICP?

Take a look at the results... 210 gal. showing a ".23" and my red sea is "1.28"!

Any feedback is greatly appreciated.

Thanks!

 

[AquAttila]

Sorry, I did forget to mention that I am dosing tropic marin A and K elements. Not sure if that would cause any elevated levels of Iodine.

 

[Randy Holmes-Farley]

That is very high. Never seen one that high.

perhaps fortunately, I do not have confidence in that company. I'd suggest asking them to double check because it is so unusual, and maybe consider either a kit test or an ICP by a different company.

Nothing except dosing could get it that high, IMO. The product you mention would not unless it was mismade or seriously overdosed.

 

[AquAttila]

Thanks you for the quick response! everything looks good in the tank too, so another reason why I think it must be inaccurate. I have never contacted ICP, but will see if they have a number or at least e-mail them.

Regards,
Attila

 

[AquAttila]

Randy, do you recommend another company to do water testing? I hate to continue using them if they don't calibrate equipment and results are off. The reason why I take the time and extra money is to fine tune my aquariums.

 

[Christoph]

Hello Attilak,

your phosphorus value is very high aswell.

Since ICP emission lines for phosphorus and iodine are very close together at 178 nm i think the iodine result will be an interference caused by the phosphorus concentration.

The analytical chemist must keep an eye on these spectral interferences when conducting ICP-OES.

Best regards,
Christoph

 

[Randy Holmes-Farley]

Randy, do you recommend another company to do water testing? I hate to continue using them if they don't calibrate equipment and results are off. The reason why I take the time and extra money is to fine tune my aquariums.

I don't have any data to go on to pick from the others, just technical reasons to not have confidence in this one.

 

[Randy Holmes-Farley]

Hello Attilak,

your phosphorus value is very high aswell.

Since ICP emission lines for phosphorus and iodine are very close together at 178 nm i think the iodine result will be an interference caused by the phosphorus concentration.

The analytical chemist must keep an eye on these spectral interferences when conducting ICP-OES.

Best regards,
Christoph

Thanks for the info, Christoph!

 

[madweazl]

Randy, do you recommend another company to do water testing? I hate to continue using them if they don't calibrate equipment and results are off. The reason why I take the time and extra money is to fine tune my aquariums.

I've had 5 or 6 run by ATI and Triton now and I've never had an oddball result. They're more expensive but they've always been consistent.

 

[normsreef]

I usually perform an ICP test every 3 months on my aquariums. This time around both, my 210 gal and 65 gal RSM showing high levels of IODINE. I know that it is difficult to test for Iodine and I do have a Salifert kit and it is actually showing "0" - so not sure what to make of this or if anyone has run into this... I am not even sure how I would go about trying to lower this and get accurate result. Do I trust the Iodine results from ICP?

Take a look at the results... 210 gal. showing a ".23" and my red sea is "1.28"!

Any feedback is greatly appreciated.

Thanks!

Did you ever find out if the test results were wrong? I just did my first ICP test with Triton and it came back with high Iodine, phosphorus and phosphate.

 

[Idech]

I always use Fauna Marin and my iodine is always low and needs dosing.

 

[Randy Holmes-Farley]

Did you ever find out if the test results were wrong? I just did my first ICP test with Triton and it came back with high Iodine, phosphorus and phosphate.

What levels?

 

[normsreef]

What levels?

I’ve since lowered my Po4 to .36

 

[Randy Holmes-Farley]

Based on Christoph’s comments, I would not assume you have high iodine. Even if real, it’s not super high.

 

[normsreef]

Based on Christoph’s comments, I would not assume you have high iodine. Even if real, it’s not super high.

I added few coral about a month ago and all bleached within a week. That’s why I sent out the icp test

 

[Randy Holmes-Farley]

Can you post the whole icp?

 

[normsreef]

I attached pdf of the icp test. Just realized they attached a note: Due to excessively high P/PO4 readings it has not been possible to accuratly test for lodine.