In need of help with GHA outbreak

FishtheShark

New Member
View Badges
Joined
Oct 19, 2024
Messages
21
Reaction score
5
Location
East Central
What state or country do you live in
Florida
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
As the title suggests, I have been battling a GHA outbreak for a few months now. I have tried everything from weekly manual removal, increasing my CUC, and reflux. I am still manually removing on a weekly (sometimes 2x a week) basis but it simply grows back within a week.

Parameters (Hanna):
0 Ammonia
0.0 Nitrates
0.01 Phos
8.4 Alk
420 Cal
1410 Mag
Temp: 79.4F
PH: 8.1-8.3
Na: 1.026
Light cycle: 1045am-715pm
Tank: 60 gal/ 20gal sump
8 fish
Handful of scarlet hermits
1 tuxedo urchin
1 tiger conch
6 turbo snails
10ish red banded trochus
5 cerith
40 dwarf cerith
3 Nassarius
10-15% weekly water changes
Weekly addition of microbacter7

I have been dosing Neonitro and Neophos, prior to the outbreak my nitrates were around 5, phos around 0.03. I realize the GHA is consuming the nutrients but I am unsure what to do to balance my nutrients. Would it be recommended I stop dosing and risk Dinos and starving my corals (a few of which are turning pale), continue dosing the same, or increase dosing as I have read from posts regarding similar situations? I did recently double the amount of macro algae in my refugium in hope of outcompeting the GHA. Quite honestly I am at my wits end and am considering Vibrant but would really like to avoid that option. If there is anything info I missed please let me know. I appreciate any help I might receive!
 
As the title suggests, I have been battling a GHA outbreak for a few months now. I have tried everything from weekly manual removal, increasing my CUC, and reflux. I am still manually removing on a weekly (sometimes 2x a week) basis but it simply grows back within a week.

Parameters (Hanna):
0 Ammonia
0.0 Nitrates
0.01 Phos
8.4 Alk
420 Cal
1410 Mag
Temp: 79.4F
PH: 8.1-8.3
Na: 1.026
Light cycle: 1045am-715pm
Tank: 60 gal/ 20gal sump
8 fish
Handful of scarlet hermits
1 tuxedo urchin
1 tiger conch
6 turbo snails
10ish red banded trochus
5 cerith
40 dwarf cerith
3 Nassarius
10-15% weekly water changes
Weekly addition of microbacter7

I have been dosing Neonitro and Neophos, prior to the outbreak my nitrates were around 5, phos around 0.03. I realize the GHA is consuming the nutrients but I am unsure what to do to balance my nutrients. Would it be recommended I stop dosing and risk Dinos and starving my corals (a few of which are turning pale), continue dosing the same, or increase dosing as I have read from posts regarding similar situations? I did recently double the amount of macro algae in my refugium in hope of outcompeting the GHA. Quite honestly I am at my wits end and am considering Vibrant but would really like to avoid that option. If there is anything info I missed please let me know. I appreciate any help I might receive!
Are you sure it is algae? If it is, you might have been unlucky and let the infestation grow too long before dealing with. Might have to restart aquarium. Also, the clean up crew might not like the stuff, another possible piece of bad luck. You might just keep doing what you are doing.
 
have been dosing Neonitro and Neophos, prior to the outbreak my nitrates were around 5, phos around 0.03. I realize the GHA is consuming the nutrients but I am unsure what to do to balance my nutrients.
Stop dosing….balancing nutrients doesn’t exist, it is hobby myth. Feed fish sparingly and maybe corals a couple of times a week very, very lightly directly with pumps off. Continue WC and manual removal with concentration on detritus not just water but filth. Don’t worry about dinoflagellates and hobby test kit zero mythology.
 
Hydrogen peroxide.

There are a couple good videos from BRS on using peroxide against algae.


Essentially cut off your flow and put the peroxide at the base of the coral and let it sit for a minute. It melts the algae. But t
You can only do a little at a time
 
I would stop the dosing and add a couple more tiger conchs and tux urchins. Do you have any herbivores? Yellow tang or foxface or blenny?
 
Pictures will help.
Please also tell us about your filtration system, and how much you feed and how often. In the end it comes down to import vs export. As mentioned above, stop dosing nitrate and phosphate, you are just adding to the import.
 
I would stop the dosing and add a couple more tiger conchs and tux urchins. Do you have any herbivores? Yellow tang or foxface or blenny?
Been hesitant to add another urchin as they do munch on the coralline, which the algae doesn’t grow on. The one I have seems to stick to the same path mostly. I also have a tomini tang which does eat the algae, but not as fast as it grows.
 
Pictures will help.
Please also tell us about your filtration system, and how much you feed and how often. In the end it comes down to import vs export. As mentioned above, stop dosing nitrate and phosphate, you are just adding to the import.
I use disposable filter socks, refugium with chaeto (and dragons breath as it was growing like crazy in my other tank), live rock, protein skimmer, and UV sterilizer. I feed twice a day with a mix of mysis and brine shrimp. I do melt the cubes and rinse. I give small portions and everything is gone in less than a minute. Coral is given reefroids on the morning of water change day.

20251019_181304_216790FC-427D-47CE-87A6-B3B0223086E2.png

20251019_181305_5BA5F153-C18B-4BED-A590-FBB307761127.png

20251019_181305_F4DE72B1-5A3A-4AEB-90D6-329094C4D443.png

20251019_181305_98DFF9F1-C2DE-4772-9FFA-7560AA831B9B.png
 
You can probably reduce the feeding to once a day and keep scrubbing the rock so you provide your CUC a helping hand. Change out filter sock more often. Give the tank more time to mature. If you dose Vibrant it will likely take out most of the algae but then you risk Dino’s followed by a turf algae that is resistant to Vibrant.

I would not worry about Urchins eating your coraline. Yes urchins can eat coraline but tanks grow so much coraline in the long run that urchins can barely make a dent.
 
I use disposable filter socks, refugium with chaeto (and dragons breath as it was growing like crazy in my other tank), live rock, protein skimmer, and UV sterilizer. I feed twice a day with a mix of mysis and brine shrimp. I do melt the cubes and rinse. I give small portions and everything is gone in less than a minute. Coral is given reefroids on the morning of water change day.

20251019_181304_216790FC-427D-47CE-87A6-B3B0223086E2.png

20251019_181305_5BA5F153-C18B-4BED-A590-FBB307761127.png

20251019_181305_F4DE72B1-5A3A-4AEB-90D6-329094C4D443.png

20251019_181305_98DFF9F1-C2DE-4772-9FFA-7560AA831B9B.png
Sounds good . For me basic algae fighting is increasing flow, blasting rocks nightly and before water changes with a turkey baster, changing filter socks frequently, wet skimming, stop all amino's and additives and reef roids, and increase the number of turbo snails. Algae and corals need the same things, so feeding the corals is also feeding the algae.

To me your problem is not too bad, I've had tanks worse than that which I've brought under control. How is the flow the in your tank?
 
Can you tell us more about the fish you keep?

What herbivorous fish in particular?
 
I use disposable filter socks, refugium with chaeto (and dragons breath as it was growing like crazy in my other tank), live rock, protein skimmer, and UV sterilizer. I feed twice a day with a mix of mysis and brine shrimp. I do melt the cubes and rinse. I give small portions and everything is gone in less than a minute. Coral is given reefroids on the morning of water change day.

20251019_181304_216790FC-427D-47CE-87A6-B3B0223086E2.png

20251019_181305_5BA5F153-C18B-4BED-A590-FBB307761127.png

20251019_181305_F4DE72B1-5A3A-4AEB-90D6-329094C4D443.png

20251019_181305_98DFF9F1-C2DE-4772-9FFA-7560AA831B9B.png
Sounds good . For me basic algae fighting is increasing flow, blasting rocks nightly and before water changes with a turkey baster, changing filter socks frequently, wet skimming, stop all amino's and additives and reef roids, and increase the number of turbo snails. Algae and corals need the same things, so feeding the corals is also feeding the algae.

To me your problem is not too bad, I've had tanks worse than that which I've brought under control. How is the flow the in your tank?
Photo was from today. This is after me having cleared a bunch from the rocks yesterday. Went back in tonight and cleared more. Currently I have the AI Nero 3 alternating at 75-100%. Return is 1300 gph.
 
Can you tell us more about the fish you keep?

What herbivorous fish in particular?
Only herbivore is a tomini tang
Other fish include 2 clowns, 2 cardinals, randles goby, melanarus and pintail fairy wrasse.
 
Been hesitant to add another urchin as they do munch on the coralline, which the algae doesn’t grow on. The one I have seems to stick to the same path mostly. I also have a tomini tang which does eat the algae, but not as fast as it grows.
I understand your concern, but has not been a problem in my tank. Additionally we have a plague of asterinas which also scrub the rocks of everything, with no gha recurrance.
The goal is to get the gha to a level the cuc can maintain, then reduce. More cuc gets there faster.
 

TOP 10 Trending Threads

HOW WOULD YOU FEEL ABOUT RECEIVING A FISH OR CORAL AS A HOLIDAY GIFT?

  • I’d love one, as long as it’s a species I chose

    Votes: 19 28.4%
  • I’d trust someone who knows my tank to choose

    Votes: 2 3.0%
  • I’d rather get a gift card and pick it myself

    Votes: 25 37.3%
  • I’d prefer gear or supplies instead

    Votes: 2 3.0%
  • Please don’t surprise me with livestock

    Votes: 19 28.4%
  • Other (Post in the comments)

    Votes: 0 0.0%

New Posts

Back
Top
Home
Post thread…
Market
What's new