Here are my thoughts:
1, The Carbon doser is a waste of money*. I've had my reactor up for a year now with a cheap old-school needle valve ($50), and never had to touch it - *this is only true if you're using the now so popular constant flow method, other wise it would be a PITA.
2, If you decide to go with the constant flow & regulate the pH in the chamber with a controller, then
a, You don't need a peristaltic pump, it can be done via a seperate cheap pump, or from the manifold (however it is recommended to add a filter inline, most people use fuel filters) - this gives pretty stable results, but needs some attention every 2-3 months. I'm not saying that a peri pump isn't better, I'm just saying that the results without it are adequate.
b, You don't want an oversized reactor, as it will need a lot of CO2 to melt the media & will lower your pH in the tank a lot (remember we're still talking about the constant flow method) & it will be hard to dial in the bubble count to keep the solenoid clicking all day. You don't want to melt the coral in your tank as well, do you?:D
If you want to go old-school and use the dripping method, then IMO the Carbon Doser and a Peripump (Kamoer being the cheapest, but it's chingchong at the end of the day, don't forget) is a must. You can get away with a bigger reactor with this method though.