WE have these conversations all the time about nutrients and algae, but the truth is that the algae doesn't care what your test kits read as they have a mind of their own. I have no idea what my nitrates are now but they have been running around 60 for decades.
I think thats what they were here and I had no algae.
I think my nitrates are around 10 now) I tested them last year and I have quite a lot of algae.
The algae just doesn't care. No one, and I mean no one can tell you why algae is growing although we all think we know. We don't.
If you put a glass of tap water on your sunny windowsill and an ant walks around the edge and gets a heart attack and croaks in the water, algae will grow.
Even if that ant was anorexic, very skinny and didn't know how to dance, algae will grow. I will even say that if the water doesn't have an ant in it, algae will grow. Or sometimes it won't. :)
Yes, algae needs some nutrients but it also needs some metals like iron and maybe a little Iodine but our tanks all have enough of what algae needs to grow to start a produce farm.
If you are in this hobby long enough, decades, not hours, you will see that algae, cyano, and volcanoes all grow in cycles. Some last a few months and some a few years and all the chemicals we add or remove won't help.
It grows the most in brand new tanks with few nutrients and my tank which is over 50 years old. It is normal and natural just like it is in the sea.
We don't see it in the sea due to the manatees, algae bleenies, tangs, sea hares, snails, urchins etc.If algae didn't grow in the sea, why are most of the creatures there algaevores?
Don't worry to much about it unless it covers your corals. Go out to dinner and have a nice bottle of Merlot.
I took these in the sea;
Here in Hawaii you don't see any algae, but what you do see is an urchin in every crevace.
