Here's some downsides of individual mentors, for me;
1) What happens when they aren't available?
One of the main advantages of the forums at large is that they are open and offering advice 24x7, 365 days a year. There are certainly slower times when things take longer to get answered, but there are active members around the globe - available at every hour. If there was a private mentorship program set up, those mentors would only be available during certain hours. Work, family, sleep, vacations - all of these things makes an individual less available than a group. When you set up a person as The Source For Answers, then the reefer needing help may have difficulty adapting to other sources of advice. This could mean that during a critical point when the reefer needs urgent help - they are left without. This could leave a bad impression on not only the mentor, but also R2R at large.
Sure; you could have a team of mentors that could act as backup to each other. But then - how is that different than the forums at-large?
2) People learn a lot by teaching others.
One of the main ways that I learned "how to reef" (such as it is) has been through trying to help other people find answers to their questions. If you look at my early posts and filter out all the questions I myself asked, you'll likely see a lot of posts that sound like, "I think so-and-so (tagged) said to do this in that situation..." or, "I've seen a bunch of other people do that, so you might want to try it too?". I was careful to always couch my early answers with a degree of self-doubt. But as time went on, others on the site both corrected - and eventually validated - my suggestions. I had learned things through this process.
But if, instead, those questions had never been made public, I would not have had the chance to chime in on them. Yes; a lot of them had been asked before and the answers could have likely been found with a search. But it wasn't about them being asked for the 100th time - it was about me answering them for the 1st time. The gain wasn't so much for the person asking, in other words, but it was for me - the person answering. These days, there's a whole library of reefing information in my head available to tap into. Not because I had to know the info for myself per-se, but because I have had enough opportunities to answer the questions of others.
3) Mentors are individual people too.
Individual people make mistakes. Individual people get it wrong. Not because they are bad people or poor at their effort, but simply because they are people. Even professionals make mistakes - and that's OKAY. They should be allowed that opportunity. Especially for something that they are volunteering their time and energy for. Yet when that person is given responsibility for someone else's property, then they may not feel as free to make those mistakes. Their levels of stress will increase beyond that which they would normally feel. This stress may impact their enjoyment of the hobby at large in a negative way. I would - personally - hate to think that an R2R user of any type would be negatively impacted by something this site offered. That's antithesis to the goals of R2R.