My Euphillya are not extending anymore! Please help!

Tested both:
Nitrates around 15 ppm, phosphates still 0.03 or lower.
I will check tomorrow, giving a day to the tank without PO4 resin to see if something is changed.

What do you suggest to use to zero the refractometer?

Thanks.
DIY refractometer solution with some table salt and rodi
 
Thank you so much, I will read the articles this evening!
 
35ppt solution
“This 3.65 weight percent sodium chloride solution can be made by dissolving 3.65 grams of sodium chloride in 96.35 grams (mL) of purified fresh water”
 
Just a side thought. Not scientific.

I have a similar problem with my forgspawn. It does well for weeks. But after a while the branches begin to recede tissue and then open up less and less until gone.
I had tried everything from changing carbon, i maintain kalk, kh, mg, ph, salinity, changing filter socks 2 x per week, running skimmer, etc. etc. Nothing worked. I couldn't lay my finger on it.

I have a LOT of soft corals, palythoa, green star polyps.

One thing consistently works for me. A small water change, of 10 percent. Maybe every 2 to 3 weeks. The amount seems negligible, and it shouldn't be able to do much, like lower nitrates, phosphates considerably. But it works every time for me and it has worked for many years (tank has been going for 20 years) The colony is a foot across (started with 2 polyps) and even fully receded polyps that were shaded underneath and moved have recovered.

Of course you need to still figure out the problem. I am not trying to discourage you from following the other great/better suggestions. And the tank size might not allow it. But for a quick bandaid to allow them to heal, a small water change? To give you more time to figure it out. And check your make-up water quality.
 
Thank you so much for your reply and for sharing your experience.
I do regular weekly 10% water changes every Sunday with Red Sea Salt.

I must investigate more!
 
Do you happen to use coral snow?

I just did my 1st coral snow addition a week ago, and ever since, one of my hammers has one of the heads that has closed up.

No idea if it’s the cause or just a coincidence. Im assuming it’s the cause of my closure. All other hammers and torches are not showing any signs of distress.
 
Thank you so much for your reply and for sharing your experience.
I do regular weekly 10% water changes every Sunday with Red Sea Salt.

I must investigate more!
Good to hear and sorry to hear. You are more under the gun trying to figure it out. I also use red sea (coral pro).

If it is true that the soft corals are also closing up, I doubt it is Mg. Also, am I correct that you indicated that the last major change you made to your aquarium was adding an ATS 3 weeks ago? Might need to work your way backwards. Rule out the most recent change/addition.

It sounds like you have a skimmer, PO4 remover, carbon, nitrate remover, ATS. Are you trying to run a nutrient poor system? What are you putting back in to feed system? Many soft corals need "dirtier" water to thrive.

Mine is LPS and Softcorals, 80 gallons. I have skimmer, carbon and refugium. I started adding Phyto last couple of weeks each day to feed a small clam and the caulerpa in refugium started dying. Could also be the clam effectively filtering the water (added him 2 months ago). Point is seemingly minor changes can create a cascade.

Anyway, thinking out loud about things I wouldn't discount.
 
Do you happen to use coral snow?

I just did my 1st coral snow addition a week ago, and ever since, one of my hammers has one of the heads that has closed up.

No idea if it’s the cause or just a coincidence. Im assuming it’s the cause of my closure. All other hammers and torches are not showing any signs of distress.

Yes sir, I dose coral snow once a week, never had a problem before tbh.
 
Good to hear and sorry to hear. You are more under the gun trying to figure it out. I also use red sea (coral pro).

If it is true that the soft corals are also closing up, I doubt it is Mg. Also, am I correct that you indicated that the last major change you made to your aquarium was adding an ATS 3 weeks ago? Might need to work your way backwards. Rule out the most recent change/addition.

It sounds like you have a skimmer, PO4 remover, carbon, nitrate remover, ATS. Are you trying to run a nutrient poor system? What are you putting back in to feed system? Many soft corals need "dirtier" water to thrive.

Mine is LPS and Softcorals, 80 gallons. I have skimmer, carbon and refugium. I started adding Phyto last couple of weeks each day to feed a small clam and the caulerpa in refugium started dying. Could also be the clam effectively filtering the water (added him 2 months ago). Point is seemingly minor changes can create a cascade.

Anyway, thinking out loud about things I wouldn't discount.

Thank you for your answer.

Yes, my major change was adding an ATS 3D printed and crafted by me 3 weeks ago and it was running with light 24/7 to try to grow algae fast.

At the moment I have the current setup:
Filter roller, skimmer, ATS, active carbon.

I'm starting to think that my problem is with nitrates and phosphates, they are not in balance.
I tested them and I have nitrates at 15/20 ppm and phosphates at 0 ppm or very very close to it!

Yesterday I removed the anti - phosphate resin, today I replaced the active carbon and tuned the ATS to run with light only for 12 hours in the night.
I also started to feed a bit more to try to increase PO4 (I feed granular or flakes for herbivorous).

My skimmer is still running a lot, never saw it removing so much skimmate (It's not a wet skimmate).

To be honest, I was scared about having NO3 and PO4 in the tank from our LFS, here in Italy there still is the idea that a saltwater tank must be without NO3 and PO4.
That's why I aimed to remove them, probably it was a real error.

I will keep you updated.
Thank you so much for your time.

Stefano.
 
What did you use to print your ATS? Are you sure it's not leeching anything into the water?
 
What did you use to print your ATS? Are you sure it's not leeching anything into the water?

I used PETG printed with stainless steel nozzle, I read that is safe for the aquarium.
By the way I thought that too, but first PETG is claimed as safe and second, after 3 weeks already leeching?
 
The base PETG itself should be fine but not every roll of PETG is guaranteed to be 100% reef safe. The primary concern is that some color dyes are made from unsafe metals and can leech. I try to stick to natural clear, white, carbon black, or grey as these generally use either no dye or just carbon for the pigment.

Some PETGs are not pure as well, PETG blends or with additives could be potentially unsafe so I generally stick to a few brands for the filament I use for aquarium printing, like Overture and Atomic Filament
 
The base PETG itself should be fine but not every roll of PETG is guaranteed to be 100% reef safe. The primary concern is that some color dyes are made from unsafe metals and can leech. I try to stick to natural clear, white, carbon black, or grey as these generally use either no dye or just carbon for the pigment.

Some PETGs are not pure as well, PETG blends or with additives could be potentially unsafe so I generally stick to a few brands for the filament I use for aquarium printing, like Overture and Atomic Filament
Thank you for your reply.

Mine is white, PETG from Bambulab.

TBH I don’t know what to do, should I remove it?
 
If I went backwards to the last change, and the ATS is it, and so close to when the problem started, I would start there. Maybe it is connected to the skimmer as well. It certainly wouldn't hurt to try, do a water change, activated carbon and see see what happens. At this point you are just trying to rule things out.

Are the softies still not expanding as much? If thisnis the issue, it might take a bit for them to slough off the irritant before expanding back to normal. You should start to see Euphylia expanding faster, but will take a while to regrow tissue If it is recessed toward tip of skeleton. I have had them regrow after all the septae were completely exposed. It just continues to grow, with septae showing lower down the branch where the problem was (time capsule). Just takes patience.

I have been there before, many times, and it can be aggrevating. But hang in there and chalk it up to lessons learned - which will probably not be the last time.
 
Last edited:
If I went backwards to the last change, and the ATS is it, I would start there. Also your skimmer is acting up. Don't know if there is a connection. But it certainly wouldn't hurt to try, do a water change and see what happens. At least rule it out. Just my 2 cents.
Yes, today I will remove ATS and do a water change.

I will keep you updated, thank you so much for your help!
 
I wouldn’t expect white to be a problem but I haven’t used bambulabs’ filament so I can’t vouch for it one way or the other

Overture clear PETG has proven to be invert safe in my wife’s freshwater aquaria for years though so that’s what I tend to use most often
 
I wouldn’t expect white to be a problem but I haven’t used bambulabs’ filament so I can’t vouch for it one way or the other

Overture clear PETG has proven to be invert safe in my wife’s freshwater aquaria for years though so that’s what I tend to use most often
Ok, I saved the overture clear PETG in my Amazon list for the future.
For now, I just remove the ATS to check if I see any difference.
 
Update:

One day without ATS and PO4 resin, my PO4 are still zero.
I’m running only with filter roller and skimmer.

In your opinion, how much time is needed, on average, to increase PO4 again?
I feed one pinch of flakes at midday and one pinch in the evening as always, should I increase it?

Thank you so much.
Stefano.
 

TOP 10 Trending Threads

HOW WOULD YOU FEEL ABOUT RECEIVING A FISH OR CORAL AS A HOLIDAY GIFT?

  • I’d love one, as long as it’s a species I chose

    Votes: 19 28.4%
  • I’d trust someone who knows my tank to choose

    Votes: 2 3.0%
  • I’d rather get a gift card and pick it myself

    Votes: 25 37.3%
  • I’d prefer gear or supplies instead

    Votes: 2 3.0%
  • Please don’t surprise me with livestock

    Votes: 19 28.4%
  • Other (Post in the comments)

    Votes: 0 0.0%
Back
Top
Home
Post thread…
Market
What's new