Good to hear and sorry to hear. You are more under the gun trying to figure it out. I also use red sea (coral pro).
If it is true that the soft corals are also closing up, I doubt it is Mg. Also, am I correct that you indicated that the last major change you made to your aquarium was adding an ATS 3 weeks ago? Might need to work your way backwards. Rule out the most recent change/addition.
It sounds like you have a skimmer, PO4 remover, carbon, nitrate remover, ATS. Are you trying to run a nutrient poor system? What are you putting back in to feed system? Many soft corals need "dirtier" water to thrive.
Mine is LPS and Softcorals, 80 gallons. I have skimmer, carbon and refugium. I started adding Phyto last couple of weeks each day to feed a small clam and the caulerpa in refugium started dying. Could also be the clam effectively filtering the water (added him 2 months ago). Point is seemingly minor changes can create a cascade.
Anyway, thinking out loud about things I wouldn't discount.
Thank you for your answer.
Yes, my major change was adding an ATS 3D printed and crafted by me 3 weeks ago and it was running with light 24/7 to try to grow algae fast.
At the moment I have the current setup:
Filter roller, skimmer, ATS, active carbon.
I'm starting to think that my problem is with nitrates and phosphates, they are not in balance.
I tested them and I have nitrates at 15/20 ppm and phosphates at 0 ppm or very very close to it!
Yesterday I removed the anti - phosphate resin, today I replaced the active carbon and tuned the ATS to run with light only for 12 hours in the night.
I also started to feed a bit more to try to increase PO4 (I feed granular or flakes for herbivorous).
My skimmer is still running a lot, never saw it removing so much skimmate (It's not a wet skimmate).
To be honest, I was scared about having NO3 and PO4 in the tank from our LFS, here in Italy there still is the idea that a saltwater tank must be without NO3 and PO4.
That's why I aimed to remove them, probably it was a real error.
I will keep you updated.
Thank you so much for your time.
Stefano.