New torch coral is dying

VintageReefer

7500 Club Member
View Badges
Joined
Nov 16, 2023
Messages
9,121
Reaction score
14,365
Location
USA
Rating - 100%
2   0   0
Okay will monitor display for now. I attached a photo but color of the container makes it difficult to see. Jelly seems to be in center where it looks darker and you can see some of the melting tissue on the periphery. Smelled the frag prior to placing in this container and smelled like rotten fish.

The smell is a tell tale sign of infection. And this goes internally inthe skeleton
 
OP
OP
S

slik419

New Member
View Badges
Joined
Apr 3, 2024
Messages
18
Reaction score
12
Location
Miami
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
Probably too far gone. Happened to me last week

Bright neon yellow on the left. Had it a week. Everyday open like this
A9E3A943-36B3-4E91-BD7D-7F1959B17FE7.jpeg


Then notice on day 8 it’s half size
DE4A9131-55FF-4814-9100-71CFD0BC3B70.jpeg


Inspect and see skeleton in an area. I cleaned and did h2o2 dip then lugols dip and return to display cleaned
2CE3E4D0-19EE-40D5-968C-FF83C09A3230.jpeg
43F9B806-FFE7-4AE1-90F9-2A8A23C5CACF.jpeg


Next day bjd showing. I get aggressive and do kfc dip / procedure
4E6EA16F-2735-4D67-8468-7FBFC146D3C7.jpeg

552E4375-2F30-4A9B-BC35-4ED8A55D7A38.jpeg


Died during dip. Too far infected
32D83880-CE33-4000-A875-8223835A79C0.jpeg
86018BC8-B709-4C1B-A5E1-BE577D19E34E.jpeg
3799BB8F-6F74-47B2-9FCD-88EABEBCD021.jpeg
795F81FA-2DBA-40FC-90A5-FE0294CDF4BD.jpeg
7EC92F61-EA1B-4756-B864-C2A6481C8349.jpeg
E8E7E1E9-114A-451E-8D0E-F73AC7E760CA.jpeg
4D32164E-BBE8-4C17-A0D0-5E5133CC366D.jpeg
177095E2-B8FE-4410-B456-D41D8FEA839E.jpeg
21C1CF94-B9BD-4E26-996E-B7F0DE7CF301.jpeg
4DBCAEA3-A302-4F5A-AD1C-5326C858B1DE.jpeg
Hadn’t heard of KFC dip. I’m worried this torch is also too far infected at this point but will try it tonight. I could tell it was unhappy 24h into receiving it but the last 24h has been so quick.
 

VintageReefer

7500 Club Member
View Badges
Joined
Nov 16, 2023
Messages
9,121
Reaction score
14,365
Location
USA
Rating - 100%
2   0   0
 

VintageReefer

7500 Club Member
View Badges
Joined
Nov 16, 2023
Messages
9,121
Reaction score
14,365
Location
USA
Rating - 100%
2   0   0
Also my system did not become infected. Only the torch that displayed the issue and it was removed before it got really bad. Everything else is ok

26E4A39F-86BA-4FD2-9BE8-DA66FE6B9176.jpeg
 

SudzFD

Well-Known Member
View Badges
Joined
Feb 24, 2014
Messages
528
Reaction score
411
Location
Southern California
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
Hey guys,
New to reefing. I have 36 gal bow front tank that has been cycled for about 6 months. Lighting is an AI prime 16. I have a mixed reef tank with frogspawn, hammers, and a few other LPS, SPS, soft corals. Everyone else is doing well and growing. Tank parameters are the following: specific gravity is 1.026, Ca 420, alkalinity 8.6, pH 8, nitrates 10, phos 0.2. Chemistry has been consistent. I had only 1 dragon soul torch and it’s been doing well and last week I received a holy grail, Malaysian, and Indo gold torch. I dipped all coral in an iodine dip for 15 min and placed in an area with decent flow and light. All except the holy grail is doing well. Shortly after first 24h I noticed that the holy grail started to bubble up on tissue, then tissue receded from both base and up near the head and tentacles started to slough off exposing the septa and corallite structure. I don’t see brown jelly like I’ve seen on pictures, just that the tentacles shrivel up and turn a little brown. But I’ve also never had BJD so ‍♂️ . The area most affected is away from the other torches I have in the garden. The new torches have been in for 8 days now. I have been feeding reef chili/mysis shrimp soaked in brightwell restor. There is a dead head next to it on other side of pic (hard to get image on that side and it’s how it arrived). Is this stress from new arrival? Any suggestions to save this coral?

IMG_2466.jpeg IMG_2464.jpeg IMG_2465.jpeg
In my opinion, all you can do is leave it alone and wait and see. I wouldn’t do anything as it will only further stress it. The fact that this happened within 24 hours, lends me to believe it’s not disease lighting flow or water parameters. Those would develop over longer time frames. This is likely stress from transport/acclimation, or something that occurred to it prior to arrival.

Good luck.
 

Formulator

Valuable Member
View Badges
Joined
Apr 14, 2024
Messages
2,436
Reaction score
2,510
Location
Saint Louis, MO, USA
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
If you are trying to heal a torch or if it has no flesh and you want to get the flesh growing you put them in low light low flow
Even if the reason it is losing tissue is due to insufficient light? Not saying that is definitely the issue here, but it was a hypothesis we were exploring when I recommended moving it up in the tank.
 

SudzFD

Well-Known Member
View Badges
Joined
Feb 24, 2014
Messages
528
Reaction score
411
Location
Southern California
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
Even if the reason it is losing tissue is due to insufficient light? Not saying that is definitely the issue here, but it was a hypothesis we were exploring when I recommended moving it up in the tank.
Not enough light would be something to explore if this happened weeks or months later. Since it’s a new addition, less light is ideal under normal conditions as it acclimated to the lights. In this case where it’s distressed even more so that it have less light to rule out bleaching/over lit.

Storms can cover the reefs in dim lights for weeks without issue to the corals and even our tanks can go dim for significant periods without killing our corals.
 
OP
OP
S

slik419

New Member
View Badges
Joined
Apr 3, 2024
Messages
18
Reaction score
12
Location
Miami
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
By the time I got home and did the pre wash it’s pure skeleton. Hoping the others in the shipment stay healthy. Another torch I received has a short tissue band and similarly had a dead head next to it on arrival. That one seems to be okay for now.
 
OP
OP
S

slik419

New Member
View Badges
Joined
Apr 3, 2024
Messages
18
Reaction score
12
Location
Miami
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
The smell is a tell tale sign of infection. And this goes internally inthe skeleton
Went from a faint smell this afternoon when I spotted the brown streak and sniffed it to full blown house smelled like rotten fish when I got home. I knew it could progress quick but experiencing it was still shocking.
 

Moe K

Active Member
View Badges
Joined
Jul 16, 2018
Messages
247
Reaction score
190
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
I have been feeding reef chili/mysis shrimp soaked in brightwell restor

Have you been feeding your torches this?

IME it's best to stop target feeding torches. Only let them get what is broadcasted. Also aminos can contribute a lot to infection.

Also the only thing I would dip a torch in to clean it is reef primer. It's gentle and cleans off infections better than anything else I tried with the least stress. H202 wrecks torches when I tried it and Iodine dip didn't work nearly as good as reef primer.
 

VintageReefer

7500 Club Member
View Badges
Joined
Nov 16, 2023
Messages
9,121
Reaction score
14,365
Location
USA
Rating - 100%
2   0   0
Have you been feeding your torches this?

IME it's best to stop target feeding torches. Only let them get what is broadcasted. Also aminos can contribute a lot to infection.

Also the only thing I would dip a torch in to clean it is reef primer. It's gentle and cleans off infections better than anything else I tried with the least stress. H202 wrecks torches when I tried it and Iodine dip didn't work nearly as good as reef primer.

The food he was using is a great combination.

However the issue at hand was not nutritional nor parameter related, the torch had a bacterial infection and the only methods to save were prolonged antibiotic baths. Since we don’t know what strain of bacteria. A multitude of products are suggested. You have little time to act. It’s throw everything together in a Hail Mary, do nothing, or do incorrect things. Only one of these has the possibility of survival

Torches should be fed. Broadcast vs target is dependent on your tanks setup. Your flow allows broadcast feeding? Great. I have high flow environments. If I Have 100 corals and frags and broadcast feed, about 10 will get food directly. I have to kill flow and target feed everything by hand.

If a coral needs extra nutrition for whatever reason, target feeding is more efficient and allows interaction and observation, and keeps you from dumping excess product into the tank. It really depends on your setup and you shouldn’t broadly generalize and advise against target feeding. The bigger picture is making sure the coral gets food, regardless of method
 

VintageReefer

7500 Club Member
View Badges
Joined
Nov 16, 2023
Messages
9,121
Reaction score
14,365
Location
USA
Rating - 100%
2   0   0
By the time I got home and did the pre wash it’s pure skeleton. Hoping the others in the shipment stay healthy. Another torch I received has a short tissue band and similarly had a dead head next to it on arrival. That one seems to be okay for now.

If bagged individually then it is possible the remaining one is unaffected
 

codycolina707

Well-Known Member
View Badges
Joined
Jun 9, 2019
Messages
516
Reaction score
427
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
Already doing it when I received the corals. First time using it so I’ll let you know how it goes
If you like torches I'd looking into kfc dip I will just sometimes randomly dose my tank with ciprofloxacin seems to help keep brown jelly away
 

Moe K

Active Member
View Badges
Joined
Jul 16, 2018
Messages
247
Reaction score
190
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
The food he was using is a great combination.

However the issue at hand was not nutritional nor parameter related, the torch had a bacterial infection and the only methods to save were prolonged antibiotic baths. Since we don’t know what strain of bacteria. A multitude of products are suggested. You have little time to act. It’s throw everything together in a Hail Mary, do nothing, or do incorrect things. Only one of these has the possibility of survival

Torches should be fed. Broadcast vs target is dependent on your tanks setup. Your flow allows broadcast feeding? Great. I have high flow environments. If I Have 100 corals and frags and broadcast feed, about 10 will get food directly. I have to kill flow and target feed everything by hand.

If a coral needs extra nutrition for whatever reason, target feeding is more efficient and allows interaction and observation, and keeps you from dumping excess product into the tank. It really depends on your setup and you shouldn’t broadly generalize and advise against target feeding. The bigger picture is making sure the coral gets food, regardless of method

Maybe I shouldn't have generalized against target feeding but I would say that depends on what exactly you plan on feeding it and how often. I stay away from target feeding torches powdered foods as that most times has a big reaction with my torch corals evident when they excessively slime. I used to think that was a good feeding response but when they would begin to get receding dark flesh I changed course on that thought. Feeding something like oyster feast or just plain mysis usually has a less intense slime reaction and would think that is a good indicator it is a proper food for the specific coral. I am now more inclined to believe that the intense slime reaction is more a defense mechanism and expends a lot of energy for the coral leaving it more susceptible to illness. So I would also not generalize target feeding is safe specifically for torch corals either and it just depends on what you feed it and how often. Mr. Chili is something I personally would not feed them or target them with a high concentrations of amino acids (because it's pathogen fuel).

But either way sadly OP's torch was in bad shape when he made this post and agree an antibiotic dip could have helped but for the other torches in his tank reef primer tends to be enough as a preventative dip. I mention the feeding because he still has new torches in the tank he was concerned about. At the least I suggest staying away from target feeding powdered foods and amino acids until things settle down.
 

VintageReefer

7500 Club Member
View Badges
Joined
Nov 16, 2023
Messages
9,121
Reaction score
14,365
Location
USA
Rating - 100%
2   0   0
Maybe I shouldn't have generalized against target feeding but I would say that depends on what exactly you plan on feeding it and how often. I stay away from target feeding torches powdered foods as that most times has a big reaction with my torch corals evident when they excessively slime. I used to think that was a good feeding response but when they would begin to get receding dark flesh I changed course on that thought. Feeding something like oyster feast or just plain mysis usually has a less intense slime reaction and would think that is a good indicator it is a proper food for the specific coral. I am now more inclined to believe that the intense slime reaction is more a defense mechanism and expends a lot of energy for the coral leaving it more susceptible to illness. So I would also not generalize target feeding is safe specifically for torch corals either and it just depends on what you feed it and how often. Mr. Chili is something I personally would not feed them or target them with a high concentrations of amino acids (because it's pathogen fuel).

But either way sadly OP's torch was in bad shape when he made this post and agree an antibiotic dip could have helped but for the other torches in his tank reef primer tends to be enough as a preventative dip. I mention the feeding because he still has new torches in the tank he was concerned about. At the least I suggest staying away from target feeding powdered foods and amino acids until things settle down.

Great explanation and I do agree with the clarification.

I find my torches also prefer a meatier food vs powder based foods. Surprisingly they also sent to like flake food I offer, but it could be because I use PE Mysis flake food, the flake version of the frozen product.

I also think feeding torch 2-3x a week max is best, they need time to digest and process food before taking in another meal.

Hopefully op notified vendor as soon as a problem was detected and they are willing to agree upon a solution.

The better vendors out there (I’m thinking of SBB and Vivid offhand) offer a 14 day guarantee on corals
 
OP
OP
S

slik419

New Member
View Badges
Joined
Apr 3, 2024
Messages
18
Reaction score
12
Location
Miami
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
The food he was using is a great combination.

However the issue at hand was not nutritional nor parameter related, the torch had a bacterial infection and the only methods to save were prolonged antibiotic baths. Since we don’t know what strain of bacteria. A multitude of products are suggested. You have little time to act. It’s throw everything together in a Hail Mary, do nothing, or do incorrect things. Only one of these has the possibility of survival

Torches should be fed. Broadcast vs target is dependent on your tanks setup. Your flow allows broadcast feeding? Great. I have high flow environments. If I Have 100 corals and frags and broadcast feed, about 10 will get food directly. I have to kill flow and target feed everything by hand.

If a coral needs extra nutrition for whatever reason, target feeding is more efficient and allows interaction and observation, and keeps you from dumping excess product into the tank. It really depends on your setup and you shouldn’t broadly generalize and advise against target feeding. The bigger picture is making sure the coral gets food, regardless of method
Out of curiosity, since torches are prone to bacterial infections it seems then is it appropriate to perform a culture/sensitivity if acute tissue loss is noted? Then start on a less aggressive antibiotic dip protocol until results are in?
 
OP
OP
S

slik419

New Member
View Badges
Joined
Apr 3, 2024
Messages
18
Reaction score
12
Location
Miami
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
Great explanation and I do agree with the clarification.

I find my torches also prefer a meatier food vs powder based foods. Surprisingly they also sent to like flake food I offer, but it could be because I use PE Mysis flake food, the flake version of the frozen product.

I also think feeding torch 2-3x a week max is best, they need time to digest and process food before taking in another meal.

Hopefully op notified vendor as soon as a problem was detected and they are willing to agree upon a solution.

The better vendors out there (I’m thinking of SBB and Vivid offhand) offer a 14 day guarantee on corals
I don’t want to get into many details but the corals were sent accidentally lol so I don’t expect any credit for a free coral lol just sad that it died. I was so excited for my bright green torch, definitely one of my favorites.
 
OP
OP
S

slik419

New Member
View Badges
Joined
Apr 3, 2024
Messages
18
Reaction score
12
Location
Miami
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
IMG_2475.jpeg

Came home to this. Miami Malaysian has severe tissue recession with septa exposed. This is the other torch that also had a dead head and short tissue band. Will be dipping later. Very sad

IMG_2476.jpeg image.jpg
 
Last edited:

TOP 10 Trending Threads

IF YOU HAD A CAREER IN REEF-KEEPING, WHAT WOULD YOU BE DOING? AND WHY?

  • Selling and distributing livestock!

    Votes: 50 32.7%
  • Selling and distributing equipment!

    Votes: 15 9.8%
  • Breeding and Aquaculture!

    Votes: 73 47.7%
  • Livestock Disease and Treatment!

    Votes: 6 3.9%
  • Chemistry!

    Votes: 15 9.8%
  • Designing and Maintenance of tanks!

    Votes: 31 20.3%
  • Research and Education!

    Votes: 37 24.2%
  • Reefing Equipment and Dry Goods Creation and Manufacturing!

    Votes: 18 11.8%
  • Conservation!

    Votes: 38 24.8%
  • Other (please explain)!

    Votes: 6 3.9%
Back
Top