Organo-MS - results and evaluations

  • Thread starter Thread starter Lasse
  • Start date Start date
  • Tagged users Tagged users None
The ChatGPT was just an example. It was generated by making an aggregate approximation derived from multiple broad proteomic surveys, primarily those that examined average amino acid frequencies across large sets of eukaryotic (including invertebrate) proteomes. I have a detailed list, but again, it's an example.
The experiment to do may probably add a known concentration of all AAs and take samples over time, and see the uptake. But that is for a lab with a budget. A step further will be with Radioactive aas and then to analyze the coral flesh. Many companies sell AA mixtures, but they do not disclose the content, and I doubt that they do serious experiments. So what is left is to use these mixtures for the dual purpose of a general nitrogen source and actual coral food.
 
The ChatGPT was just an example. It was generated by making an aggregate approximation derived from multiple broad proteomic surveys, primarily those that examined average amino acid frequencies across large sets of eukaryotic (including invertebrate) proteomes. I have a detailed list, but again, it's an example.
The experiment to do may probably add a known concentration of all AAs and take samples over time, and see the uptake. But that is for a lab with a budget. A step further will be with Radioactive aas and then to analyze the coral flesh. Many companies sell AA mixtures, but they do not disclose the content, and I doubt that they do serious experiments. So what is left is to use these mixtures for the dual purpose of a general nitrogen source and actual coral food.
I have access to amino acids of decent quality so I don't have to rely on any numbers of commercially available products:
1765122369558.png

I hope to get some analytical insight through the Organo-MS analysis, as well as other experiments or studies, but that's something we can discuss in a dedicated thread, for now I'm more interested in how stable the amino acids remain in the test vial.
 
Last edited:
Corals (together with their zooxanthellae) can absolutely biosynthesize all those named amino acids (Histidine is a bit special because some corals can and other can't produce it). The amino acids that are essential to humans are different from those that might be essential to other organisms.

If they can biosynthesize sufficient amounts of these amino acids isn't well studied as far as I know. However, there are some studies that show the uptake rate of some amino acids, so we know at least that they are consumed. Either just for the nitrogen, or because they are actually helpful and the organisms have to spend less energy to synthesize these amino acids themselves.
Yes there seems to be that in a general context there is not any amino acids that can been seen as essential (the coral can´t synthesize it at all) as we know it for the moment. There can be species of corals that can´t biosynthesize certain amino acids - but in general - we can´t transform the same essential concept from us to corals.

, but that's something we can discuss in a dedicated thread,

Yes please

for now I'm more interested in how stable the amino acids remain in the test vial.

I do not know this but the sample is filtered with 0.2 µ - it means that there will be a very low - if none - bacterial breakdown during transport but @Christoph maybe can answer this question in detail

Sincerely Lasse
 
Corals (together with their zooxanthellae) can absolutely biosynthesize all those named amino acids (Histidine is a bit special because some corals can and other can't produce it). The amino acids that are essential to humans are different from those that might be essential to other organisms.

If they can biosynthesize sufficient amounts of these amino acids isn't well studied as far as I know. However, there are some studies that show the uptake rate of some amino acids, so we know at least that they are consumed. Either just for the nitrogen, or because they are actually helpful and the organisms have to spend less energy to synthesize these amino acids themselves.
Yes there seems to be that in a general context there is not any amino acids that can been seen as essential (the coral can´t synthesize it at all) as we know it for the moment. There can be species of corals that can´t biosynthesize certain amino acids - but in general - we can´t transform the same essential concept from us to corals.

, but that's something we can discuss in a dedicated thread,

Yes please

for now I'm more interested in how stable the amino acids remain in the test vial.

I do not know this but the sample is filtered with 0.2 µ - it means that there will be a very low - if none - bacterial breakdown during transport but @Christoph maybe can answer this question in detail

Sincerely Lasse
Sorry @Lasse,

I didn't mean to hijack your thread so I wanted to move/delay the discussion. Once the amino acids arrive and I have taken a closer look at Dan's data I will open a new thread to discuss some possible experiments :)

I hope Christoph will see my question regarding Histidine in the Organo-MS thread. I would be really interested in his reasoning why it isn't part of the analysis yet. I assume it is nearly never detectable, but there must be some reason why robust corals have kept the Histidine biosynthesis pathway and complex corals didn't.
 
Thank you for keeping the data updated @Dan_P!

Christoph already analyzed that amino acids have a very short half-life in a mixed reef tank, but what do you guys think about the sample's stability once in a test vial? How close do you think are these results to the actual levels in our tanks at the time the sample was taken?

I'm asking because I'm considering to create a DIY amino acid solution using the gathered information. I will probably make a thread soon so the community can discuss what exactly we might want to try/test, and how to do this properly and evaluate results. Right now aspartic acid, taurine, glutamic acid, glutamine, and tryptophan have the highest standard deviation relative to the target level provided by Oceamo, which makes me wonder if we can even properly dose them in reef tanks without having levels all over the place.

This becomes evident when looking at the graphs Dan_P was so nice to prepare and update. Alternatively the one below shows minimum and maximum measured value, the median (orange line) and average (color change from light blue to dark blue) relative to the target value provided by Oceamo.
Overview.jpg

Since the aquarium samples are sterile filtered, there is a good chance the amino acids are not degraded during shipping and the Organo-MS results could reflect the concentrations in the aquarium.
 
Hello all,

regarding the latest questions

1) Histidine, due to its chemical nature is difficult for us to measure in the current test setup. This is why it is not part of the Organo-MS test yet. Im confident that we will manage in the mid future to also measure histidine. There is also mroe analytes we are aiming to add: A next step will be biogenic amines such as putrescine, cadaverine, tyramine & Co - im personally very interested if there is a correlation between tank issues and the levels of these compounds. But this is also work in progress..

2) Regarding the stability of amino acids in the sample: The 0.2 µm filtration at the time of sampling reduces biological activity to almost zero in the sample. Within our initial sample storage stability tests we have not seen significant changes in the amino acid levels. Recently we conducted some more stability tests with samples from different tanks - and have observed signs of instability in some of the samples (also temperature dependent). I can only speculate about the reason, but my guess would be that some enzymes still pass the filter. We found a (LC-MS compatible) way of chemically preserving the sample, so soon all Organo-MS tests will also come with a stabilizer that is added to the sample at the time of sampling, eliminating the risk of sample degradation further.

All the best, Christoph
 
I didn't mean to hijack your thread so I wanted to move/delay the discussion. Once the amino acids arrive and I have taken a closer look at Dan's data I will open a new thread to discuss some possible experiments :)
Sorry - it wasn't directed at your posts but I didn't want the thread to be derailed using ChatGPT's opinions, Due to the fact that most of the "knowledge" on the internet about amino acids is based on the thinking and beliefs of saltwater aquarists and not on mainly scientific research (there are few of them), things can go very wrong if you use AI.

Feel free to share any dosage experiments here - especially if you succeed (or fail) in achieving OCEAMOS recommended levels.

But these are also such important experiences that they deserve their own thread - but feel free to link

Sincerely Lasse
 
@areefer01 @Lasse @EnterName
Here is the latest contribution from areefer01. The aquarium is dosed with amino acids but the dosing schedule is not a strict one.

The first plot shows all the amino acid results in our database. A dashed line passes through the areefer01 results. The low concentrations of aspartic and glutamic acids are noteworthy. The total amino acid pool view is in the second plot. The low concentrations of aspartic and glutamic acids also stand out in this plot. I wonder what activity the glutamic acid concentration is tied to? The very large amounts we see are coincidental with the presence of fluconazole.


image.png

image.png
 
Thank you @areefer01 & @Dan_P for sharing!

The very large amounts we see are coincidental with the presence of fluconazole.
Were there multiple analysis results with Fluconazole? I can't remember.

The low concentrations of aspartic and glutamic acids are noteworthy.
Maybe more or less regular dosing feeds microbes which are consuming these amino acids and therefore dosing can sometimes have the very opposite effect mid-term?
 
Thank you @areefer01 & @Dan_P for sharing!


Were there multiple analysis results with Fluconazole? I can't remember.
Yes, Static416 had a second test that showed no flucanozole and much lower glutamic acid. Doesn’t prove anything but might serve as a lead for a future study.
 
Like bacteria that become amino acid junkies and don’t eat harder to digest DOC? :-)
😁

It doesn't have to be bacteria, but we already observe that amino acid dosing boosts growth of algae, dinos, and cyanos in some tanks. In other tanks you might simply feed other organisms that don't become a visible nuisance and therefore you increase the demand for amino acids artificially by adding them until their population dies down to normal levels again.
 
I’d also point out that aspartic acid and glutamic acid will bind to calcium carbonate surfaces, much more so than most amino acids, and that may be why they are low, and possibly even why aspartic acid is reported to slow calcification by corals.
 
😁

It doesn't have to be bacteria, but we already observe that amino acid dosing boosts growth of algae, dinos, and cyanos in some tanks. In other tanks you might simply feed other organisms that don't become a visible nuisance and therefore you increase the demand for amino acids artificially by adding them until their population dies down to normal levels again.
My world view :-) is that bacteria are the best at vacuuming up organic nutrients (Christoph’s study of amino acid half seems to support bacteria dominance). I cannot deny other organisms share in the bounty, but as a first approximation, it’s all about bacteria. Just their size gives them a huge advantage for amino acid uptake, not to mention that being all over in the water means they get first pick of the amino acids. If we are discussing inorganic nitrogen and phosphate, it’s all about micro algae.
 
I’d also point out that aspartic acid and glutamic acid will bind to calcium carbonate surfaces, much more so than most amino acids, and that may be why they are low, and possibly even why aspartic acid is reported to slow calcification by corals.
To what extent does biofilm modify binding, the rate, the equilibrium?
 
To what extent does biofilm modify binding, the rate, the equilibrium?
I think the biofilm simply acts like a barrier that prevents the necessary chemical processes, but Randy will know better than I do. Local pH changes caused by biological activity could be another factor.

My world view :-) is that bacteria are the best at vacuuming up organic nutrients (Christoph’s study of amino acid half seems to support bacteria dominance). I cannot deny other organisms share in the bounty, but as a first approximation, it’s all about bacteria. Just their size gives them a huge advantage for amino acid uptake, not to mention that being all over in the water means they get first pick of the amino acids. If we are discussing inorganic nitrogen and phosphate, it’s all about micro algae.
My knowledge in this area is very limited, and I have no other option than to trust your intuition :)

What does stand out to me is just how quickly bacteria can reproduce and consume stuff. I've recently added a bunch of dinoflagellates and diatoms to a sample tube and it didn't take 24h until most of them were completely dissolved and only a chaos of tiny little dots, rods, and spirals was zooming around the slide :D
 
To what extent does biofilm modify binding, the rate, the equilibrium?

Biofilms will slow binding, but not entirely prevent it for things that have high affinity for calcium carbonate surfaces, such as phosphate or aspartic acid.
 
@areefer01 @Lasse @EnterName
Here is the latest contribution from areefer01. The aquarium is dosed with amino acids but the dosing schedule is not a strict one.

The first plot shows all the amino acid results in our database. A dashed line passes through the areefer01 results. The low concentrations of aspartic and glutamic acids are noteworthy. The total amino acid pool view is in the second plot. The low concentrations of aspartic and glutamic acids also stand out in this plot. I wonder what activity the glutamic acid concentration is tied to? The very large amounts we see are coincidental with the presence of fluconazole.


image.png

image.png

Thank you @Dan_P - appreciate your time with data analysis and correlation.
 

TOP 10 Trending Threads

HOW DO YOU HANDLE HOLIDAY DECORATING AROUND YOUR REEF?

  • I decorate the tank or stand

    Votes: 1 8.3%
  • I decorate AROUND the tank or stand

    Votes: 1 8.3%
  • I add one small seasonal touch but keep it very basic

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • I take a holiday photo, but don’t decorate the space

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • I leave the reef area as it is

    Votes: 9 75.0%
  • We don’t decorate for the holidays

    Votes: 1 8.3%
  • Other (Post in the comments)

    Votes: 0 0.0%
Back
Top
Home
Post thread…
Market
What's new