Overrated Corals in the Hobby

Any coral over $100, lol.
Was going to do high end corals but only have one. I actually prefer coras with unique structure over color.
One of my favorite ones, on the bottom, with a unique growth pattern.
20261028_163536.jpg
Same. I buy what I like. I don’t chase names, etc. I will spend $100 or more on a frag if its growth structure or color are unique or what I am specifically looking for. But when I can get the exact same thing for half the price from another vendor, I’ll take the cheaper option. I don’t pay for names, I pay for how the coral looks.
 
Gotta say I’m part of the group who’s a fan of bounce shrooms, very nice og!
me too. My once tiny mushroom is now huge with 2 dozen bubbles. They really glow. That’s said, I had a 7-8 godzilla bounce mushrooms that were flourishing and they all died.
 
me too. My once tiny mushroom is now huge with 2 dozen bubbles. They really glow. That’s said, I had a 7-8 godzilla bounce mushrooms that were flourishing and they all died.
sorry to hear about your godzillas, ive been sorrt of on the hunt for them locally but it seems theyve actually surpassed the og bounce's price tag for a baby at least where i live
 
sorry to hear about your godzillas, ive been sorrt of on the hunt for them locally but it seems theyve actually surpassed the og bounce's price tag for a baby at least where i live
thanks i got an og bounce 8 months ago and its tripled in size. Hoping that one hangs on.
 
sorry to hear about your godzillas, ive been sorrt of on the hunt for them locally but it seems theyve actually surpassed the og bounce's price tag for a baby at least where i live
thanks i got an og bounce 8 months ago and its tripled in size. Hoping that one hangs on.
Awesome to hear! I’m thinking about getting myself another og once the next show rolls around, mine mysteriously melted away, it had a ton of bubbles
 
Are there certain corals in this hobby that you feel are overrated? Maybe ones that fetch a hefty price, but don't really seem worth it. Or maybe ones that constantly get recommended to beginners and you are tired of seeing in everyone's tank. Or maybe just coral that you don't like in general for no definable reason. While I don't have a lot of coral that I dislike, ones that I don't want to keep in my future tanks are green and pink sinularia. I just feel that they spread too fast, and don't show a lot of vibrant color. Don't get me wrong they are great for beginners and I've had many in my previous tanks, but they just don't appeal to me anymore personally.
IMO Bounce mushrooms – Some sell for ridiculous prices just because they have oversized bubbles. Cool, but not thousands-of-dollars cool.
 
Awesome to hear! I’m thinking about getting myself another og once the next show rolls around, mine mysteriously melted away, it had a ton of bubbles
that worries me. That’s why as soon as it splits i will sell the baby so i can get some return on investment
 
A lot of the “high end” anything. The colors are often no different than other corals you can buy. It often feels like they are throwing a special tag on it to charge more.
oh they absolutely are doing that. It is the Apple marketing way. put a name on it and make people think it makes them cool while doing absolutely nothing for you.
take fancy named whatevers, they might be rarer in the ocean but they grow in the same tank, same water, same nutrient pools, same lights as the other less fancy named anything you are selling. So what makes them so expensive? ID10Ts paying rediculous prices to brag to their "friends" they got a king kong godzilla super max dot of a coral.....
 
Awesome to hear! I’m thinking about getting myself another og once the next show rolls around, mine mysteriously melted away, it had a ton of bubbles
That's one of the corals I've been wanting to try. I just haven't gotten around to trying one yet!
 
Awesome to hear! I’m thinking about getting myself another og once the next show rolls around, mine mysteriously melted away, it had a ton of bubbles
That's one of the corals I've been wanting to try. I just haven't gotten around to trying one yet!
Thankfully their prices have come down a ton, imo one of the best looking shrooms is a nice bubbled up bright og bounce
 
Thankfully their prices have come down a ton, imo one of the best looking shrooms is a nice bubbled up bright og bounce
That's what has drawn me to those specific ones. I love the color contrast on them. Still don't know if I trust myself to cough up that kind of coin for one of those corals rn
 
Thankfully their prices have come down a ton, imo one of the best looking shrooms is a nice bubbled up bright og bounce
That's what has drawn me to those specific ones. I love the color contrast on them. Still don't know if I trust myself to cough up that kind of coin for one of those corals rn
Yeah definitely understandable, especially when some vendors sell them at the size of your thumbnail with very little bubbles lol, I definitely recommend looking for them at shows and taking your time to really compare bubbles and prices, what do they usually go for around you?
 
Yeah definitely understandable, especially when some vendors sell them at the size of your thumbnail with very little bubbles lol, I definitely recommend looking for them at shows and taking your time to really compare bubbles and prices, what do they usually go for around you?
Honestly, I have no clue 😅

The two stores that are relatively close to me don't sell much in terms of coral (they are those fresh/saltwater stores)
I would need to drive up to another store that is an hour away from me to see the price. Funny enough I have never been to that store
 
Yeah definitely understandable, especially when some vendors sell them at the size of your thumbnail with very little bubbles lol, I definitely recommend looking for them at shows and taking your time to really compare bubbles and prices, what do they usually go for around you?
Honestly, I have no clue 😅

The two stores that are relatively close to me don't sell much in terms of coral (they are those fresh/saltwater stores)
I would need to drive up to another store that is an hour away from me to see the price. Funny enough I have never been to that store
I would definitely wait for a show if you go to any then lol, I’m wishing you luck in your search!
 
Are there certain corals in this hobby that you feel are overrated? Maybe ones that fetch a hefty price, but don't really seem worth it. Or maybe ones that constantly get recommended to beginners and you are tired of seeing in everyone's tank. Or maybe just coral that you don't like in general for no definable reason. While I don't have a lot of coral that I dislike, ones that I don't want to keep in my future tanks are green and pink sinularia. I just feel that they spread too fast, and don't show a lot of vibrant color. Don't get me wrong they are great for beginners and I've had many in my previous tanks, but they just don't appeal to me anymore personally.
I have yet to have any success with cheap ones that supposedly need easy care . I am seriously thinking of throwing in the Towel with Coral. And finding fish that don't kill one another is a challenge as well. Over All getting fed up , but too stubborn to give up
 

TOP 10 Trending Threads

HOW WOULD YOU FEEL ABOUT RECEIVING A FISH OR CORAL AS A HOLIDAY GIFT?

  • I’d love one, as long as it’s a species I chose

    Votes: 11 37.9%
  • I’d trust someone who knows my tank to choose

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • I’d rather get a gift card and pick it myself

    Votes: 10 34.5%
  • I’d prefer gear or supplies instead

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • Please don’t surprise me with livestock

    Votes: 8 27.6%
  • Other (Post in the comments)

    Votes: 0 0.0%
Back
Top
Home
Post thread…
Market
What's new