Placed a Petco order

  • Thread starter Thread starter Reefing102
  • Start date Start date
  • Tagged users Tagged users None
Quality marine has an actual website. Huh. I'll be keeping a watch on updates.
Speaking from experience dealing with them directly when I worked at the LFS, we never had issues with the stuff we got from them. They’re, I think, one of the biggest wholesalers in the US.

A large chunk of my LFS’s order from them.
Nice! Are you in the east coast?
Eastern Midwest - Ohio
 
So as was brought up in a previous thread, they ship UPS Next Day Saver so this is what I have for a delivery time frame
DA3E8D75-F8E2-4598-9893-4316B0A9E7AF.jpeg
You can see what time they picked the package up to determine how long it’ll be in transit by clicking on “details” and then clicking on “progress”.
 
Speaking from experience dealing with them directly when I worked at the LFS, we never had issues with the stuff we got from them. They’re, I think, one of the biggest wholesalers in the US.

A large chunk of my LFS’s order from them.

Eastern Midwest - Ohio
You a buckeye fan?
 
You can see what time they picked the package up to determine how long it’ll be in transit by clicking on “details” and then clicking on “progress”.
Just at label created at 1:50pm and label scanned in Long Beach, CA at 5:30PM


You a buckeye fan?
Yes and No. I’m not a huge sports fan overall and I lived in Rochester Hills long before I moved to Ohio, so I’ll gladly say Go Blue just to tick people off around me (and I can “justify” it)but in actuality I really don’t care either way lol Just don’t charge me double if you ever sell me anything lol
 
Just at label created at 1:50pm and label scanned in Long Beach, CA at 5:30PM



Yes and No. I’m not a huge sports fan overall and I lived in Rochester Hills long before I moved to Ohio, so I’ll gladly say Go Blue just to tick people off around me (and I can “justify” it)but in actuality I really don’t care either way lol Just don’t charge me double if you ever sell me anything lol
Don't worry it won't be double but triple. Jsk. I have friends and customers who are Ohio State fans. Just busting your chops.
 
Just at label created at 1:50pm and label scanned in Long Beach, CA at 5:30PM



Yes and No. I’m not a huge sports fan overall and I lived in Rochester Hills long before I moved to Ohio, so I’ll gladly say Go Blue just to tick people off around me (and I can “justify” it)but in actuality I really don’t care either way lol Just don’t charge me double if you ever sell me anything lol
That means it was probably picked up around 5:30 PM. The drivers have those portable scanners.
 
Alright. So everything came in alive at 1:03 PM. So less than 24 hours from label creation to receipt.

The good:

The bags are labeled (including species) and potentially collection area

The Sea Hare came in nice and large (3-4 inches)

The Diamond Gobies - came in on the smaller to medium side - 2-3 inches. Appear fairly plump.

The Red Goniopora - came in fairly good size - took up most of the 1.5” frag plug

The Bad:

The hairy mushroom - based on the pic online and answers to questions - appears it should have been 2-3 polyps on a small rock. While not fully expanded, what came in was a single dime size mushroom on a 1.5 inch frag plug.

The Goniopora - I have hope but it’s pretty retracted. Does look pink vs red but that’s okay for me. I’m guessing from the below shipping style - @Mibu

The coral shipping - Each coral was packed loose in the bag with a another bag loosely wrapped around it. It left some to be desired but everything appears to have arrived alive.

All in all, I’ve reached out to Petco to see what they can do about the mushroom. Definitely would not have paid what I paid for something like what I received. Fish wise I wouldn’t hesitate to order from again. Coral wise…it’s a gamble I’d say. I’d probably take it again

Here’s the unboxing:

0C82F1E6-811E-4C6A-858C-B7A1BB5255A3.jpeg


9AC1992B-BC60-4AE2-8F06-07BB0451C777.jpeg

CAE0C122-11BF-4B93-8BA8-509DCCB4BBBA.jpeg

AB308FF7-8968-4ADA-80DD-3BD6EE4A7750.jpeg

0198F8B5-195C-41ED-9671-B6BF161150D6.jpeg

1477AEDB-0ACC-44B6-943B-A6F7B3B3B2EF.jpeg

61C7C561-CFC6-48E2-B7E5-1BABCFE4146B.jpeg

5EE618E6-6256-4383-AB18-BE81C4D6A091.jpeg

6D6D585C-91E6-48FE-BA19-1F3FC4BA003F.jpeg

D02079B5-7D32-49E4-AC5E-7EAACCC8CE47.jpeg
 
So in the time it took me to create the above post, the goniopora has opened up. Appears to be a short polyp version (or could just still be adapting (also very likely)) Sorry for the crappy pics and a bit of cyano
A6C8EB5B-5277-4747-9019-AE256E6D9F06.jpeg
E2E6554A-80AC-44C7-8CC5-33296BD0B16F.jpeg
 
So in the time it took me to create the above post, the goniopora has opened up. Appears to be a short polyp version (or could just still be adapting (also very likely)) Sorry for the crappy pics and a bit of cyano
A6C8EB5B-5277-4747-9019-AE256E6D9F06.jpeg
E2E6554A-80AC-44C7-8CC5-33296BD0B16F.jpeg
Pretty much an encrusting goni. Also, looks to be short polyp. So, they were all frags :(
 
Pretty much an encrusting goni. Also, looks to be short polyp. So, they were all frags :(
Correct. All frags. I anticipated that for the Goni since shows on a frag plug. Not so much for the mushroom. For me, I think the Goni was worth it. The mushroom not so much.
 
Color looks pretty dull on the gonipora. Not the vibrant pink you see from other vendors. Reefchaser live sale had bright pink goni for $30-$40.
 
Color looks pretty dull on the gonipora. Not the vibrant pink you see from other vendors. Reefchaser live sale had bright pink goni for $30-$40.
It is dull, but I'm satisfied with it.

An update though. Petco has stood by their 100% satisfaction guarantee. They refunded the mushroom with no requirement to return it to a store. Based on my conversation with them, will "forward my recommendation" to their web team to update the hairy mushroom description to show comes as a single mushroom on a frag plug
 
So far the sea hare is doing great work on the hair algae. Slow and steady but noticeable. Found it just laid eggs this afternoon. I’ve read they usually die shortly after laying eggs so I definitely need to keep an eye out

F7CE2112-A5CB-4CD2-89AB-BE2FB3748551.jpeg
7D87D8AC-7D29-4DF9-B921-B063F3B14CB9.jpeg
A0DF1252-0A28-48D1-A6FC-B601E9AF8935.jpeg
Sea hares are hermaphrodites and they are unable to furtilize thier own eggs.

My first sea hare laid eggs but they weren't viable out they came. Nothing tried to eat them.
Lived another 4 months or so.
 
I think it’s funny people talking about live sale prices vs what you paid.
Do they realize they gotta sit there for hours to save the $5 they talk about? Or HOPE they win it? I can’t stand the live sale hype, it’s a clever way to offload stock so the vendor can keep buying more stuff to push.

Don’t worry about what people say…
 
I think it’s funny people talking about live sale prices vs what you paid.
Do they realize they gotta sit there for hours to save the $5 they talk about? Or HOPE they win it? I can’t stand the live sale hype, it’s a clever way to offload stock so the vendor can keep buying more stuff to push.

Don’t worry about what people say…
100%

I think it's cool that the purchase was made through Petco. This thread has been fun to read.
 
Sorry to interject into this thread but...

Do sea hares really eat hair algae WELL?

None of the inverts I have that are supposed to eat GHA actually seem like they do anything to it. (Urchin, turbo snails, etc)

It's not too bad but I am getting tired of trying to pull GHA out of little pockets/holes in one of my rock structures every week or two ... yes, I'm lazy.

P.S. all of the oldest "stuff" in my tank came from PetCo (before I knew anything)
 

TOP 10 Trending Threads

WHAT KIND OF REEFING DEAL ARE YOU HOPING TO PICK UP THIS BLACK FRIDAY?

  • A whole new aquarium or complete system

    Votes: 5 16.1%
  • Lighting, pumps, or other major equipment

    Votes: 4 12.9%
  • Controllers, testing, dosing, or automation gear

    Votes: 4 12.9%
  • Dry goods and restocks, like salt, media, or food

    Votes: 3 9.7%
  • Corals! Must...Have...CORALS!!!

    Votes: 8 25.8%
  • Fish or other livestock

    Votes: 1 3.2%
  • Rock, sand, or other aquascaping supplies

    Votes: 1 3.2%
  • I’m browsing, but don’t have a specific target

    Votes: 4 12.9%
  • I’m not shopping for reef deals this year

    Votes: 1 3.2%
  • Other (Post in the comments)

    Votes: 1 3.2%
Back
Top
Home
Post thread…
Market
What's new