Red Sea Aquarium Failure Incident Tracker

Definitely create a ticket and send the pics to RedSea. So this is a G2 and not the V3 that added armor seams?

These two spots look like it’s about to have algae penetrate the actual seam.
IMG_9425.jpeg


Here you can see the silicon for the armor vs the silicon that makeup the actual seam.
This is a G2 300 xl but it does have armored seams. Once it starts deteriorating like this it just continues. At least the many failures I have seen images of and my own experience has shown that.
I've been seeing a quite a few lately failing in the upper right corner where earlier they were blowing out a lower front seam usually the right, again from what I have seen. My 170 failed in upper right front and this 300 is showing issues in the same area. I suppose it doesn't mean anything but its enough to have me considering a replacement.

Added image if the armor
PXL_20250505_233123302.jpg
 

That looks like a terrarium to me. Sorry. Reptiles and amphibians are fun too, if you would like to use if for that.
I was moreso thinking of taking it apart to get some very expensive 5/8” starphire glass for a custom patio window I have in mind! — the only good use for a Red Sea tank it seems…

Maybe someone will take a few apart and use just the glass to make a monster tank? That seems like the perfect use for the material!
 
I was moreso thinking of taking it apart to get some very expensive 5/8” starphire glass for a custom patio window I have in mind! — the only good use for a Red Sea tank it seems…

Maybe someone will take a few apart and use just the glass to make a monster tank? That seems like the perfect use for the material!
We took ours apart. Front panel came off very easy, not much silicone a bit in the middle bottom seam. The two sides were even easier to remove, they were the leaking seams, just barley hanging on thanks to the clamps. The real problem was the back panel. If the whole tank had been done like this no problem would have occurred.
Just FYI. We had to take it apart to dispose of it. Here we tried to get it recycled or give it away, no luck. The cabinet of course is beautiful but an odd size. Great garage cabinet and table. It was so sad the glass was without any blemishes.
Just no room to keep it anywhere. This tank was purchased in March 2024 and died Oct. 2024, it was only supposed to have been 1 year.
 
I don’t see the Reefer 450 on the list of models… is that an oversight? Or is it not one of the tanks with known issues?
That was an oversight. I've added it to the list. Thanks and good luck on your tank!
 
That was an oversight. I've added it to the list. Thanks and good luck on your tank!
Would you like an update here once I move forward with my experimental full bottom glass eurobrace/seam reinforcement, and corner seam glass rod reinforcements?

I’d also like to add that my LFS forwarded me yesterday to another customer whom has a Red Sea Reefer 425 XL (G1) with a ~1.5” bubble on the top left corner of the front viewing pane seam (started two weeks ago, has water/algae ingress already). — I did the typical emergency bar clamps last night, and am progressing today.
 
Would you like an update here once I move forward with my experimental full bottom glass eurobrace/seam reinforcement, and corner seam glass rod reinforcements?

I’d also like to add that my LFS forwarded me yesterday to another customer whom has a Red Sea Reefer 425 XL (G1) with a ~1.5” bubble on the top left corner of the front viewing pane seam (started two weeks ago, has water/algae ingress already). — I did the typical emergency bar clamps last night, and am progressing today.
Yes please update us! Good luck!
 
I just don't understand the exercise or purpose. Just as we can't know how many tanks are sold or how many fail based on anecdote, a "tracker" like this adds even more uncertainty because we don't know how many affected people see it, let alone wanted to be included in the report.
 
I just don't understand the exercise or purpose. Just as we can't know how many tanks are sold or how many fail based on anecdote, a "tracker" like this adds even more uncertainty because we don't know how many affected people see it, let alone wanted to be included in the report.
The purpose is to have a centralized record of the details of these failures instead of having to scan through different posts about failures on R2R, FB groups, IG and other message boards.

I'm not really trying to find out the percentage of failure since we can all assume Red Sea sells thousands of tanks per year and the failure rate is probably less than 5%.
 
The purpose is to have a centralized record of the details of these failures instead of having to scan through different posts about failures on R2R, FB groups, IG and other message boards.

I'm not really trying to find out the percentage of failure since we can all assume Red Sea sells thousands of tanks per year and the failure rate is probably less than 5%.

Both of those numbers are pulled out of thin air. (thousands and 5%) -- through I would say logically and given the anecdotal record. that their failure rate is likely very high compared to other brands.

I guess my point was, that I don't see the point in the attempt compile a record of some tiny fraction of those that have failed. We know they fail and we know that the failure mode is seam delimitation. There is nothing more to glean from such a small sample size. If you see 17 left hand seam fails and 2 bottom seam fails that (in no way) means that left hand seams fail at a higher rate than bottoms, as there are too may variables in reporting.
 
Both of those numbers are pulled out of thin air. (thousands and 5%) -- through I would say logically and given the anecdotal record. that their failure rate is likely very high compared to other brands.

I guess my point was, that I don't see the point in the attempt compile a record of some tiny fraction of those that have failed. We know they fail and we know that the failure mode is seam delimitation. There is nothing more to glean from such a small sample size. If you see 17 left hand seam fails and 2 bottom seam fails that (in no way) means that left hand seams fail at a higher rate than bottoms, as there are too may variables in reporting.
Agreed, small sample size at the moment, but I think it's important to capture the details. Without the details would we know which model? Original owner? Tank was bought used? What was the results from contacting Red Sea.....etc....

The biggest complaint from reefers that have experienced seam failures is Red Sea deletes posts on their FB group, lack of customer service and resolution is laughable. I think it's important to keep a record of all these details in the event a class action lawsuit does come to fruitition.
 
Agreed, small sample size at the moment, but I think it's important to capture the details.
It will always be a small sample size. the chances of any given Red Sea tank owner finding or participating is an extremely limiting factor.

Without the details would we know which model? Original owner? Tank was bought used? What was the results from contacting Red Sea.....etc....
What does any of that matter, at all? Being honest here and not trying to diminish the effort. As I said, I just don't see the point in the effort or how it helps you or anybody any more than a genera google or thread search. Sure, it may be interesting, but I don't see the benefit for the trouble. That said it is not my undertaking 🙃

The biggest complaint from reefers that have experienced seam failures is Red Sea deletes posts on their FB group, lack of customer service and resolution is laughable. I think it's important to keep a record of all these details in the event a class action lawsuit does come to fruitition.
All of that data would be collected by the firm representing the class.

I don't see a class action happening. From where I set, there just isn't enough money to make it worth the trouble. Too few class members, to small of a target with far too high burden of proof that there is some negligence or extraordinary cover up or issue.
 
It will always be a small sample size. the chances of any given Red Sea tank owner finding or participating is an extremely limiting factor.


What does any of that matter, at all? Being honest here and not trying to diminish the effort. As I said, I just don't see the point in the effort or how it helps you or anybody any more than a genera google or thread search. Sure, it may be interesting, but I don't see the benefit for the trouble. That said it is not my undertaking 🙃


All of that data would be collected by the firm representing the class.

I don't see a class action happening. From where I set, there just isn't enough money to make it worth the trouble. Too few class members, to small of a target with far too high burden of proof that there is some negligence or extraordinary cover up or issue.
Why do you care? You’re not the one putting in the time or effort or being asked to. Just ignore it and move on if you don’t think it’s of benefit. The OP isn’t trying to impress you or get your approval.
 
I was moreso thinking of taking it apart to get some very expensive 5/8” starphire glass for a custom patio window I have in mind! — the only good use for a Red Sea tank it seems…

Maybe someone will take a few apart and use just the glass to make a monster tank? That seems like the perfect use for the material!
We took ours apart. Front panel came off very easy, not much silicone a bit in the middle bottom seam. The two sides were even easier to remove, they were the leaking seams, just barley hanging on thanks to the clamps. The real problem was the back panel. If the whole tank had been done like this no problem would have occurred.
Just FYI. We had to take it apart to dispose of it. Here we tried to get it recycled or give it away, no luck. The cabinet of course is beautiful but an odd size. Great garage cabinet and table. It was so sad the glass was without any blemishes.
Just no room to keep it anywhere. This tank was purchased in March 2024 and died Oct. 2024, it was only supposed to have been 1 year.
The fact the silicone comes of easily confirms that RedSea is using either the wrong type of silicone glue(two part fast curing) or there’s a contamination during the gluing process ie glass not properly prepared and bad batch of glue. IMHO it’s more likely the wrong kind of silicone used. Just too many failures to be the later issues
 
It will always be a small sample size. the chances of any given Red Sea tank owner finding or participating is an extremely limiting factor.
I kept the survey to 10 questions on purpose to increase participation and not be too time consuming. You'll be surprised how quick things pick up pace by word of mouth. It's very easy to copy and paste this thread on any of the social media post about another failed Red Sea tank.

What does any of that matter, at all? Being honest here and not trying to diminish the effort. As I said, I just don't see the point in the effort or how it helps you or anybody any more than a genera google or thread search. Sure, it may be interesting, but I don't see the benefit for the trouble. That said it is not my undertaking 🙃
Nice thing about this survey is I don't have to put much effort into collecting this data myself besides copy & paste the link every once in awhile. This tracker is just to save time. I don't think you'd be able to extract as much information from a Google search in a timely manner. This thread won't benefit you at all, but it will benefit other reefers in the market for a new tank to think twice about buying a Red Sea tank. It will benefit LFS owners to think twice before offering Red Sea tanks in their LFS. It will benefit those that have been unlucky enough to have a seam failure to negotiate a better offer from Red Sea for a replacement.

All of that data would be collected by the firm representing the class.

I don't see a class action happening. From where I set, there just isn't enough money to make it worth the trouble. Too few class members, to small of a target with far too high burden of proof that there is some negligence or extraordinary cover up or issue.
Red Sea Group is a multi-million global company selling in 13 countries. There's definitely enough money. It only takes 40 people to be considered a class. It just takes one person with enough determination, time and money to pursue a class action lawsuit. Don't worry about the details, let the attorney handle that part lol
 
The purpose is to have a centralized record of the details of these failures instead of having to scan through different posts about failures on R2R, FB groups, IG and other message boards.

I'm not really trying to find out the percentage of failure since we can all assume Red Sea sells thousands of tanks per year and the failure rate is probably less than 5%.
IMHO just having a list like this and disseminating it as widely as possible as possible will inform any newcomers or anyone contemplating a redsea tank to realize that redsea tank failures are quite common.
 
It will always be a small sample size. the chances of any given Red Sea tank owner finding or participating is an extremely limiting factor.


What does any of that matter, at all? Being honest here and not trying to diminish the effort. As I said, I just don't see the point in the effort or how it helps you or anybody any more than a genera google or thread search. Sure, it may be interesting, but I don't see the benefit for the trouble. That said it is not my undertaking 🙃


All of that data would be collected by the firm representing the class.

I don't see a class action happening. From where I set, there just isn't enough money to make it worth the trouble. Too few class members, to small of a target with far too high burden of proof that there is some negligence or extraordinary cover up or issue.
Are you by any chance an attorney specializing in class action lawsuits?
 
Why do you care? You’re not the one putting in the time or effort or being asked to. Just ignore it and move on if you don’t think it’s of benefit. The OP isn’t trying to impress you or get your approval.

Why do you care what I care? Moreover, the conversation was not directed at you and maybe your own advice would best be headed? just ignore and move on? And, by the same logic, I am not here to impress you or get your approval. On the other hand you appear to be responding for the sake of a personal attack or dislike and not the topic at hand.

As it were, ziggy, I don’t care how the OP spends his time or what he tracks. That does not prevent me from being interested in the conversation or having an opinion, or discussing that opinion.
 
I’ve been seeing a lot on Instagram! I’d recommend you constantly check social media and reach out to more people this has happened to. There is power in numbers!
 
. I don't think you'd be able to extract as much information from a Google search in a timely manner.
I think our views on what information matters differs greatly. Not to be confused with what is interesting 🙃

I am not against what you are doing, as I said, I just think it is rather pointless.

. It will benefit LFS owners to think twice before offering Red Sea tanks in their LFS.
I would suggest that it has no bearing - and there is a rather high likelihood most LFS owners are not R2R or "reef" social media users. I would also say that most of this (R2R, forums, etc.) is a bubble where those inside don't realize how many aquarium owners are on the other side.

It will benefit those that have been unlucky enough to have a seam failure to negotiate a better offer from Red Sea for a replacement.
No, RedSea’s legal and business teams set those guidelines based on insurance, legal exposure and business impact.

Red Sea Group is a multi-million global company selling in 13 countries. There's definitely enough money. It only takes 40 people to be considered a class. It just takes one person with enough determination, time and money to pursue a class action lawsuit. Don't worry about the details, let the attorney handle that part lol

I think you may not fully understand the scale and mechanics of the moving parts here.

Even if these tanks are failing at scale -- and I’d agree that they probably are -- I still don’t see a class action coming together. The economics just don’t support it. Red Sea is likely a sub-$50 million company. Even if it was closer to $100 million -- No firm is going to spend years navigating discovery, hiring experts, and building a complex case unless the return is virtually guaranteed. That return has to pay for all of that and the class. I think your jaw would drop if you understood the money and reasoning behind most class actions.

The smaller class actions you’re referring to are typically low-hanging fruit: clear liability, minimal cost to litigate, and a fast path to settlement. Think something like a vendor using the same admin password for every garage door opener, resulting in dozens of break-ins. Liability is obvious, the damage is quantifiable, and there’s insurance money ready to pay. That’s not what this is.

This issue might be serious within the hobby (I think it is), but that doesn’t mean it translates into a viable class action.

I am not against what you are compiling, but as I said I just don't think it matters 😀
 

TOP 10 Trending Threads

HOW WOULD YOU FEEL ABOUT RECEIVING A FISH OR CORAL AS A HOLIDAY GIFT?

  • I’d love one, as long as it’s a species I chose

    Votes: 17 30.4%
  • I’d trust someone who knows my tank to choose

    Votes: 2 3.6%
  • I’d rather get a gift card and pick it myself

    Votes: 22 39.3%
  • I’d prefer gear or supplies instead

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • Please don’t surprise me with livestock

    Votes: 15 26.8%
  • Other (Post in the comments)

    Votes: 0 0.0%
Back
Top
Home
Post thread…
Market
What's new