which return pump is the quietist and best option

Lots of good options already listed, I’ll add one more and say I’m running an AI Axis return pump and it’s been silent
how do you like it? the reviews are mixed on bulk reef supply. I like those from a features and price standpoint, plus they integrate into the ai app.But it seems like they are not that dependable.
Yeah I really like it, app integration and silent running are great - but have only had it for a few months - so really time will tell
 
I have a Reef Octopus pump and two Sicce pumps. The Reef Octopus is very clearly the most quiet when run at similar flow rates (ie, I tested by putting all three to max). I don’t run any of the pumps at max so they are all pretty quiet but Reef Octopus is at a whole different level when running at higher flow rate.

If you want to save money then Jebao is well regarded.
 
So when you ask about quiet, do you mean at full throttle? Most pumps are quiet at low settings, but some stand out as staying quiet when pushed harder. So if you buy a small cause it fits, it will have to work harder and it could be louder than a medium that fits that only needs to run at a lower setting.
 
So when you ask about quiet, do you mean at full throttle? Most pumps are quiet at low settings, but some stand out as staying quiet when pushed harder. So if you buy a small cause it fits, it will have to work harder and it could be louder than a medium that fits that only needs to run at a lower setting.
that's a great differentiation. At medium operation preferably, but also at full load, because if I ever needs to run at full power, last thing I was it for it to be loud.
 
that's a great differentiation. At medium operation preferably, but also at full load, because if I ever needs to run at full power, last thing I was it for it to be loud.
My maxspect pumps are a bit noisy after mid settings, but my sicce is dead quiet. My Jecod is dead quiet until it gets to 75%, then it’s noticeable.
I will say that the wave pattern dictates the noise level IME. Meaning if you go with a random or sine wave, it tends to be louder than a constant flow. My guess is that the pump hits different Hertz and decibels which the ear picks up on easier than a nominal hum.
 
that's a great differentiation. At medium operation preferably, but also at full load, because if I ever needs to run at full power, last thing I was it for it to be loud.
At medium settings Reef Octopus still quieter fl than both of the Sicce pumps I have. That said, the Sicce pumps are still quiet whereas the Reef Ocotpus you could not even tell it is on if to put your ear right next to the sump glass.

In addition to just listening with my ears, I also used a decibel meter when I got these thrrr pumps straight out of the box’s. They were brand new. The Sicce pumps got quieter over time as they broke in. The Reef Octopus was dead silent straight out of the box. When I say silent I mean you cannot tell it is on. I don’t think anybody who owns a Sicce would complain (particularly after it breaks in) but they are blown out of the water in comparison to Reef Ocotpus when you compare head to head. That said this is like comparing a mosquito painlessly sticking its needle in you vs someone blowing a thin stream of air on your arm. You can barely feel anything either way.
 
Last edited:
the only way to know what the “most silent pump” is to have many many years and /or multiple reef tanks set up. You don’t need to spend crazy money on a $500 return pump but pumps that have wifi and added features like temp and long warranties are very much worth the extra money.

2 that I have used are old Mag drive pumps, a Sicce syncra sdc wifi (very cool), and a current USA 1900gph on my current tank. Sicce is very quiet. The currentUSA isn’t loud but you can hear the motor but in a cool way. Never thought return pumps i’ve used were even an issue with noise.

Overflows- they can be very noisy

If you can swing it- go with a DC pump that can be adjusted speed.
 
Same setup here...
20251215_113201.jpg
Jebao 8000 with a lifereef vs3-24.
Every pump I have is Jebao.
Run a reactor with a 2500, return pump is a 3500.
Cannot hear any of them.
The venturi is louder on the skimmer than the pump.
 
both of those sound and look great, but the return pump has to be able to go in the return chamber of an all in one. these look like extras return pumps, right?

I run one of these little jebao in my IM20 AIO that's about 6ft from our bed. It replaces the 2 stock pumps.

Screenshot_20251215-144146.png
 
Jebao mdp pumps are quieter than my Tunze or Sicci. I run a mdp 8500 on a LifeReef skimmer and you can not hear it run.
I run Tunze and Sicci returns on 4 systems and the Jebao dcp is as silent as they come.
20251211_065919.jpg

Great skimmer - nice club to be in.
 
I run two Sicce SDC 3.0 on my 90g reef. I only run them at 65% to keep my overflow at 600-700 gallons/hour. Even at higher speeds they are completely silent. I love their adjustability, and the WIFI performs flawlessly.
 
A cautionary tale ..........

In my new aquarium I installed a Jebao mdp 2500. Works wonderfully , until whilst doing more wiring and neatening I inadvertently unplugged the DC power supply to the control unit. I immediately plugged it back in (jack plug )and on doing so heard an electrical spark. The result is my control unit is wiped out !

Ahh well at least I have a spare pump when the new pump arrives !

Thankfully nothing in the tank yet !
 
A cautionary tale ..........

In my new aquarium I installed a Jebao mdp 2500. Works wonderfully , until whilst doing more wiring and neatening I inadvertently unplugged the DC power supply to the control unit. I immediately plugged it back in (jack plug )and on doing so heard an electrical spark. The result is my control unit is wiped out !

Ahh well at least I have a spare pump when the new pump arrives !

Thankfully nothing in the tank yet !

A good rule of thumb is to have a spare. I would also recommend a spare powerhead. It doesn't matter what brand the hobbyist is using - spares are a good idea for critical components.

Few reasons:
  • Failure - either while running or during an action (feed mode, changing intensity, similar) or even maintenance
  • Product change or discontinue - manufacture makes a change, supply chain parts issues or availability, or just end of life and something is built better
  • Maintenance - having a spare makes maintenance tasks easier. Turn off, swap with clean, turn on, clean dirty as time allows. Maintenance also tests the functionality of the emergency spare
  • Bonus points - spare can be a different model, or vendor, if the installed, current, plumbing fits without modification. They use the same plumbing size and unions or the hobbyist can install such that they can be interchanged.
 

TOP 10 Trending Threads

HOW WOULD YOU FEEL ABOUT RECEIVING A FISH OR CORAL AS A HOLIDAY GIFT?

  • I’d love one, as long as it’s a species I chose

    Votes: 26 22.8%
  • I’d trust someone who knows my tank to choose

    Votes: 10 8.8%
  • I’d rather get a gift card and pick it myself

    Votes: 45 39.5%
  • I’d prefer gear or supplies instead

    Votes: 3 2.6%
  • Please don’t surprise me with livestock

    Votes: 30 26.3%
  • Other (Post in the comments)

    Votes: 0 0.0%
Back
Top
Home
Post thread…
Market
What's new