Witch of these scapes looks the best?

PizzaIan339 · Oct 28, 2023

I have created 3 options for a scape witch is the best?
Option 1

Option 2

Option 3

EricR · Oct 28, 2023

Doesn't look like you have a lot of room to work with.
Option 2 looks best (visually) to me but I'd worry that it's too straight up so not a lot of horizontal mounting space for corals without being shaded from above.
I voted option 3 just since it seems like it has the most spread out room for mounting corals.
*but what do I know

PizzaIan339 · Oct 28, 2023

EricR said:
Doesn't look like you have a lot of room to work with.
Option 2 looks best (visually) to me but I'd worry that it's too straight up so not a lot of horizontal mounting space for corals without being shaded from above.
I voted option 3 just since it seems like it has the most spread out room for mounting corals.
*but what do I know

Thanks for voting I personally like number 3 the most and it looks way better in person. I just wanted to see what other thought about hiding spots

hexcolor reef · Oct 28, 2023

Option 3 looks best, depending on what you plan to put on top of the rock option 2 could be tricky with that height and back wall and shape of rock

PizzaIan339 · Oct 28, 2023

hexcolor reef said:
Option 3 looks best, depending on what you plan to put on top of the rock option 2 could be tricky with that height and back wall and shape of rock

Thank you!

KrisReef · Oct 28, 2023

So far everyone has voted for option 3. I think it’s the best because I can see your beautiful lips. I wonder if that’s subliminally impacting the voting?

Otherwise it is the best scape so far.

Hopefully no one will report me for this scandalous post

I couldn’t stop myself.

blecki · Oct 28, 2023

If option 3 is how it's currently stacked up then option 3. Even if you like 1 and 2 no amount of pictures are going to get you that rock in that exact configuration ever again...

Also you'll just change it the first time you have to pull out rock to catch a fish or to recover a knocked over frag or something. Just think, have you ever seen a 'pile of rock in the middle' scape that didn't look good in a tank this size?