Yeh, I think they got yelled at because it was misleading, though I could be mistaken. I really liked the shapes of that rock when I was looking at it. I also really like the CaribSea Moani (Mined Rock) shapes.I ordered in December, some of their new rock they developed. I was looking at it again a few days ago. One odd thing is originally the rock was labeled as Pukani (man made) and shortly after, they renamed it.