Does my new Flameback Angel have velvet?

The photos of the fish post mortem are literally within a minute of passing. I was recording a video of him in the QT tank and those are stills from the video.

He was whiting very aggressively for three hours. When I first saw heavy breathing, the white dusting was only pea sized.

How long had you had the angelfish?

I looked at the post mortem picture again this morning and it jumped out at me - there is a discolored vertical band. It is wider than usual, so that threw me off, but I think the issue was Uronema. This is an internal protozoan that infects some species of newly acquired fish (so if you had this angel for more than a month, it isn't that).

If it was Uronema, it has a very low cross-infection rate. Here is an article I wrote about it:

https://www.reef2reef.com/ams/uronema-red-band-disease-hemdal.788/
The angelfish was introduced to the tank Sunday at noon and died Monday just before midnight. Roughly 36 hours.

One of the reasons I originally thought it was velvet was due to light sensitivity. I turned off all the lights in the room to catch the fish; when I started raising the light level in the room with my dimmer, the fish seemed to suffer more for the brief moment he was in the QT tank.

He also seemed to suffer less when I brought the air stone closer to him.
 
Update: Just got back from my work trip and all the other fish seem to be doing ok. Could this have been brooklynella, not marine velvet? No heavy breathing — everyone else is eating well.

https://www.reddit.com/r/ReefTank/s/TGADVuWlsr

Welcome and sorry to hear all of this.

Here is a fish with aggressive brook. This was at an LFS. Sadly it did not make it. These wild PNG’s really have stuff on them. Was able to get two that I put in QT right away. They are both eating now and healthy as can be!

IMG_1647.png
 
How long had you had the angelfish?

I looked at the post mortem picture again this morning and it jumped out at me - there is a discolored vertical band. It is wider than usual, so that threw me off, but I think the issue was Uronema. This is an internal protozoan that infects some species of newly acquired fish (so if you had this angel for more than a month, it isn't that).

If it was Uronema, it has a very low cross-infection rate. Here is an article I wrote about it:

https://www.reef2reef.com/ams/uronema-red-band-disease-hemdal.788/

Jay I was about to type this. It just didn’t make it out on the surface fast enough. I have seen it on a golden I had that passed like this. The only reason I knew for sure, considering the other flames that had it and passed it made it to the surface big time, with the golden I had to physically scrap off scales to get to the core of the damage. Then under the microscope the scrape went. Sure enough uronema.
 
The angelfish was introduced to the tank Sunday at noon and died Monday just before midnight. Roughly 36 hours.

One of the reasons I originally thought it was velvet was due to light sensitivity. I turned off all the lights in the room to catch the fish; when I started raising the light level in the room with my dimmer, the fish seemed to suffer more for the brief moment he was in the QT tank.

He also seemed to suffer less when I brought the air stone closer to him.

I have had about 6 angles sadly pass due to uronema. And it’s all been the same. A matter of days, if that, and gone. Some died within 24 hours. And I know it was this disgusting disease, to which we literally have no successful fix, because I do scrapings and put them under a microscope.
 
Last edited:
IMHO, velvet is much more rare - especially when not affecting all fish. Another cause (and even with the picture out of the water) - agree with others that Uronema is the issue, The question might be - can Uronema act between Sunday and Monday - yes, and the stress of travel/shipping may be part of the problem. Second. Uronema is present in many tanks, which have no symptoms or issues in the fish - so there is no need to re-quarantine or treat any disease in your tank. However, since you are in front of your tank and we aren't - please carefully watch the fish for other diseases - including velvet. If they have any other symptoms please report them! Sorry about your fish.
 
I have had about 6 angles sadly pass due to uronema. And it’s all been the same. A matter of days, if that, and gone. Some died within 24 hours. And I know it was this disgusting disease, to which we literally have no successful fix, because I do scrapings and put them under a microscope.
Sorry to hear about your lost angel fish — that is so sad.

Thank you for sharing your thoughts and insights. R2R’s community has been extremely helpful for me.
 
IMHO, velvet is much more rare - especially when not affecting all fish. Another cause (and even with the picture out of the water) - agree with others that Uronema is the issue, The question might be - can Uronema act between Sunday and Monday - yes, and the stress of travel/shipping may be part of the problem. Second. Uronema is present in many tanks, which have no symptoms or issues in the fish - so there is no need to re-quarantine or treat any disease in your tank. However, since you are in front of your tank and we aren't - please carefully watch the fish for other diseases - including velvet. If they have any other symptoms please report them! Sorry about your fish.
Thank you — very informative!
 
Quick update: after four days, all the other fish (2 clownfish, 1 Midas blenny, 1 royal gramma) are doing great. Eating well, behaving normally, etc. Tank parameters were 0 ammonia, 0 nitrite, 8.1 gallons pH, 0 nitrate (always working on that), 0.06 phosphate, 380 calcium, 1520 magnesium (always working on that as well).

Thank you all for the advice and guidance — this community is extremely helpful as always.
 

TOP 10 Trending Threads

WHAT DO YOU ALWAYS RUN OUT OF AT THE WORST TIME?

  • Salt mix

    Votes: 17 17.7%
  • Fish or coral food

    Votes: 5 5.2%
  • Test kits or reagents

    Votes: 10 10.4%
  • Filter media or replacement fleece

    Votes: 5 5.2%
  • RO/DI filters or supplies

    Votes: 15 15.6%
  • Fragging and repair supplies, like glue or epoxy

    Votes: 12 12.5%
  • I keep a backup of everything

    Votes: 25 26.0%
  • Other (Post in the comments)

    Votes: 7 7.3%
Back
Top
Home
Post thread…
Market
What's new