Emerald crab ? Worth the risk ?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Barb0713
  • Start date Start date
  • Tagged users Tagged users None
I've seen a few comments here on the pithos crab, and I think I might have that type of crab, but they were called "mithrax" crabs when I bought them (sick name, I know. I imagine their shells are mithril plate armor) but when researching them I saw they're also called pithos crabs I believe. Anyway on to my experience with them:

I believe that they will possibly try to eat small hermits out of their shell, but I'm not certain. They may have only been picking it apart because it had already died in a fight over a shell with a bigger hermit, or just due to a failed molt. (Scavenging, not killing, again unsure, but they live with my slightly larger hermits fine.)

I have not seen them go after hammers, zoas, palythoas, or any of my encrusting corals. I've seen them eat nuisance algae. They don't bother peppermint shrimp, a tuxedo urchin, or turbo snails. I got 3 when I ordered them and two are males (I believe) with small claws, and one has massive claws on massive arms and is slightly larger in size overall which I believe to be the female. She will beat and chase away the males only if they get near her when she's found something to munch on or if they attempt to crawl over her when she's just sitting still somewhere. I've seen the two smaller males grapple with eachoher but they just break it up after a while. I think aggression between the three of them is largely dissipated by almost nightly small nori sheets in a clip down by the gravel.

I was worried they'd eat my decorative dragons breath macroalgae, but the worst thing they do to it is cut off very small tufts, about the size of a dime or smaller, and they wear it around as stylish hats (sometimes). Other times tiny rocks are in season, or they'll use a tuft of hair algae off the back wall as a hat.

Silly little creatures that I'd recommend for most tanks. I've heard people keep them in sumps, as well.
 
I've had two emerald crabs. One was nice and didn't bother anything. The other grew ginormous and would threaten me every time I put my hands in the tank. He was picking at my duncan coral every night, then started on my goniopora. My husband loved him too much so I let him remain in the tank and hand fed him to try to convince him to stop attacking my corals (he never did.)

Eventually both crabs slowed down and passed after about 9-10 months. They were cute and great at eating algae, but I'd never do it again!
Thanks. I currently am missing a chunk of meat from my hand from a tiny little clownfish. She’s mean. I have to take her out to work on the tank.
 
Naughty girl I have no idea how it got to the nursery either. Sorry bout the crummy cinematography. The taping is my Corgy Agatha rear paws. Lol.
 

Attachments

  • PXL_20250531_001631414.mp4
    90.1 MB
Hi guys. We got emerald and within 4 days it killed hermit and then been killed next night. Don’t know if it was crab fight but we have very stable tank and nothing else but emerald and hermit could have fought. No more emeralds in our tank tho.
 
I caught my emerald scraping my rainbow monti down to the rock it had been encrusted onto. I’ve still got it but will not replace it i loose it.
 
I really want an emerald crab to complete my CUC I have everything else I need. I’m scared that he will hurt my 💯 peaceful , big knobby brown brittle starfish and I’m scared he will pick at my coral. So, real experience , should I try it. I have a 20 gallon nano
I have 3 in my display of varying sizes, they have never picked at any of my coral. They do love to knock frags out of holes in my rock if thats where I have them. They move stuff around that isn't glued.
 
I caught my emerald scraping my rainbow monti down to the rock it had been encrusted onto. I’ve still got it but will not replace it i loose it.
See that’s why. No. I’m not doing it.
 

TOP 10 Trending Threads

ARE YOU READY TO CONFESS TO CRAZIEST, DUMBEST, FUNNIEST THING YOU’VE EVER DONE IN REEFING?

  • Yeah, I'll confess! (Share your story in the comments!)

    Votes: 71 54.6%
  • Nah, I'll keep mine a secret...(Don't be like that, share with the class!)

    Votes: 59 45.4%
Back
Top
Home
Post thread…
Market
What's new