How do you run a tank without GFO/Phosphate Reactor?

Fisherman Joe

Well-Known Member
View Badges
Joined
Jun 2, 2015
Messages
751
Reaction score
235
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
Hi all.

I have a 4 month old, 600L (130g) tank. I have a refugium that’s about 12% the total volume with an AI fuge light on it (red LED’s).

Currently I have two options, run a GFO and get 0.0ppm phosphate or take it off and have 1.0ppm phosphate.

I would love to transition to a stable system without running GFO in a phosphate reactor. The transition to this is something I have difficulty imagining.

Any advice?
 
May I ask what type of rock you are using? Some rocks leach phosphate and require a remover like chemi pure, nopox or lanthium chloride in order to get all the phosphate out of the water column after it has leached from the rocks. Once the phosphate has come to a managable level the fuge should keep your numbers in check. Imho
 
Hi all.

I have a 4 month old, 600L (130g) tank. I have a refugium that’s about 12% the total volume with an AI fuge light on it (red LED’s).

Currently I have two options, run a GFO and get 0.0ppm phosphate or take it off and have 1.0ppm phosphate.

I would love to transition to a stable system without running GFO in a phosphate reactor. The transition to this is something I have difficulty imagining.

Any advice?
I think you have a great goal. Running 0 phosphates could end up really bad. And certainly swings are not good either. What test kit are you using for phosphates? Do you have anything (chaeto, etc.) in that fuge?
 
That was it 6 weeks ago at its best.

I’ve since had a Cyano outbreak and lost 6 corals. Now I’ve turned the flow up and my waters really cloudy with particulate but the sand isn’t being blown around. Odd. But that’s another issue. Patience is needed here I feel.

29F8B873-4A53-4121-86CD-35492CDBA736.jpeg
 
Hmmm. I’ve never used a ceramic rock. I would be tempted to put a piece of it in some rodi water and test phosphates to see if it’s the source.
 
I have a Hanna Checker and I have ceramic rock that was man made.
Might be benificial to add a brightwell brick or 2 to the sump to give bacteria more places to colonize. Nothing good happens fast. And I wouldnt change more than one thing at a time per monthish time frame. The tank is still in its new phase, you will have these ups and downs for the first year or two when you start a fresh tank, unless you utilize established rock or filtration media.
 
Either way, some chaeto in a lighted fuge should help. I’m not a proponent of gfo. But if you use it, I would cut the amount that you use to about 1/4 of the original and replace it more often. Don’t let your phosphates get close to zero or dinos might take over and then you’d have real problems.
 
Hmmm. I’ve never used a ceramic rock. I would be tempted to put a piece of it in some rodi water and test phosphates to see if it’s the source.
Sound hypothesis but even if it did show phosphate, it wouldn’t prove anything really. It’s been in the tank 4 months. Don’t know if it’s the rock of the things living on it.

I did migrate some live rock, could test them side by side but I would have to break my rock work so not going to do that.

I had a similar problem in my last tank. With GFO - zero. Without, PO4 goes through the roof.

Anyone else similar?
 
I also have some brightwell equivalent rocks in the sump and a couple of plates and balls too that I took from my last tank.

I used live sand from Caribsea, live water from my last tank and rock. I don’t think it’s a bacteria issue but it will take time to stabilise I know.

Let’s assume in another 9 months it’s stable, how would you transition from GFO to just running a fuge?
 
The problem is, phosphate removers work way too well most of the time. So you can bottom out easily. But of course, if you remove them, your phosphates can skyrocket. But the way I approach phosphates is - what negativity do they bring my tank in the end? If algae is under control and SPS are growing well and have good coloration, I don’t try to fix it. If I get lots of algae, I’ll tackle other problems before attacking phosphates
 
Phosphates of 1.0ppm have killed my clam before and my Duncan’s LPS etc. Also I worry it won’t stop at 1.0ppm.
 
My P04 is 3... yes 3 pukani rock been in the tank for 4 years. I run a fuge with cheato, and recenlty added a brightwell brick maybe a month back. Ill have to test p04 again. But I will be using some type of remover to get it to a managable number if the brightwell brick doesnt seem to have made an effect.
 
I run an algae turf scrubber and it got my phosphates to 0. Whatever method you use, unless it's gfo, you need nitrates for phosphates to go down.
 
Phosphates of 1.0ppm have killed my clam before and my Duncan’s LPS etc. Also I worry it won’t stop at 1.0ppm.
I’ve run phosphates way higher than that before and nothing died (couldn’t keep SPS). Are you sure it’s the phosphates that killed them? Could be a hundred other reasons.
 
I also have some brightwell equivalent rocks in the sump and a couple of plates and balls too that I took from my last tank.

I used live sand from Caribsea, live water from my last tank and rock. I don’t think it’s a bacteria issue but it will take time to stabilise I know.

Let’s assume in another 9 months it’s stable, how would you transition from GFO to just running a fuge?
Very slowly. Just like when I weaned off nopox. I had to go very slow like .5 mil less a week subsequently each week or the algae exploded. I made the mistake of only running nopox for the first 3 months of the tank. I should have carried it on for a year or better.
 
Reduce the flow through the GFO reactor, it only needs enough that it looks like it has liquefied (if that makes sense?).
 
**** GFO. Almost ruined my beautiful tank lol. Keep it all natural with a large fuge, lots of live rock, live sand. Maybe Chemi pure blue when needed. GFO is too effective. 0 phosphates is a no no. Dinos will almost always come next. My tanks looks best around .25
 
I never mastered GFO reactors and suspect it (and me) killed my corals...instead I run a well lite fuge and hand dose Phosphate-E along with my weekly testing regime ...its been working waaaay better for me
 
I have a dosing pump and NO3:PO4 X.

GFO is like heroine and hard to get off once you’re on it lol.

How would you transition to using NO3:PO4 X in that case?
 

TOP 10 Trending Threads

HOW WOULD YOU FEEL ABOUT RECEIVING A FISH OR CORAL AS A HOLIDAY GIFT?

  • I’d love one, as long as it’s a species I chose

    Votes: 13 34.2%
  • I’d trust someone who knows my tank to choose

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • I’d rather get a gift card and pick it myself

    Votes: 14 36.8%
  • I’d prefer gear or supplies instead

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • Please don’t surprise me with livestock

    Votes: 11 28.9%
  • Other (Post in the comments)

    Votes: 0 0.0%
Back
Top
Home
Post thread…
Market
What's new