Zionas
5000 Club Member
- Joined
- Mar 6, 2020
- Messages
- 5,630
- Reaction score
- 3,501
Specifically the Azures, Yellowtails, Talbot’s etc.? If I get two of them about 0.75”-1”, will they eventually pair up like most Clownfish or will they fight?
How to pair Chrysiptera damsels?
- Thread starter Zionas
- Start date
- Tagged users None
FangsAndGames
Well-Known Member
It’s hard to get a pair. If you must get 1 per 10 gallons and as many as you see fit. If a pair establishes hooray! You can remove the other ones. Be careful about buying pairs as some are not legitimate.
Guess I won’t be pairing them after all. What about mixing species and getting one of each?
FangsAndGames
Well-Known Member
I’m not saying you can’t keep them together either. Plenty of people have done so with success just done expect them to pair up. You can house many in a 30-40 gallon you just have to be careful about it.
FangsAndGames
Well-Known Member
You could fit each one in a cubic foot. I’d do 2-3 personally
Haydn
Active Member
Unlike species like clownfish, wrasse and angelfish, damsels are born either male or female and do not change sex so unless you happen to get a male and female you will not get a pair.
You can certainly mix different species of damsels, and keep them in groups. Many folks do. Just stick to the Chrysiptera genus.
I tried to pair two yellow tails in my 125. One killed the other. The lone one is the wimpiest fish in my tank. I would go with 1, or a group.
I tried to pair two yellow tails in my 125. One killed the other. The lone one is the wimpiest fish in my tank. I would go with 1, or a group.
ichthyogeek
Valuable Member
- Joined
- Jun 26, 2020
- Messages
- 2,072
- Reaction score
- 2,056
Wow....sooooo I'm going to push back on a loooooooot of the stuff here because I've done it. Here's how:
Buy a group of 6 damsels. They'll spend some time establishing a pecking order, and then a pair will form. I did it in a 29 gallon tank. The important part is to get a group of 6 or more, so that any aggression is evened out within the group. This also conveniently gives you a 99% chance of having at least one male and one female within the group fish can't change sex. You will see aggression, but this is normal. If any one of the fish starts to look super torn and tattered, then remove it from the tank (give it back to the fish store, nurse it back to health, whatever). If you see a pair of fish consistently swimming near each other/nesting together, then you have your pair.
A lot of people seem to forget about this method in the hobby, even though it's one of the oldest ones out there. People see "oh, they're all going to change sexes! I'll only buy 2!" while failing to take into account intraspecies aggression, and other factors necessary for determining if a fish is going to change sex or not. Yeah, saltwater fish are expensive, but this method works. I've used it on firefish and yellowtail demoiselles, and have plans to use it on randall's gobies next. Bidirectional hermaphroditism does exist, but if they're protandrous/protogynous, once they're reached their final sex, that's it; no more sex changes. And we don't know nearly enough about some fish to know "oh, they're juveniles at this stage, females at that stage, and males at that stage" especially when there's no sexual dimorphism at all.
Buy a group of 6 damsels. They'll spend some time establishing a pecking order, and then a pair will form. I did it in a 29 gallon tank. The important part is to get a group of 6 or more, so that any aggression is evened out within the group. This also conveniently gives you a 99% chance of having at least one male and one female within the group fish can't change sex. You will see aggression, but this is normal. If any one of the fish starts to look super torn and tattered, then remove it from the tank (give it back to the fish store, nurse it back to health, whatever). If you see a pair of fish consistently swimming near each other/nesting together, then you have your pair.
A lot of people seem to forget about this method in the hobby, even though it's one of the oldest ones out there. People see "oh, they're all going to change sexes! I'll only buy 2!" while failing to take into account intraspecies aggression, and other factors necessary for determining if a fish is going to change sex or not. Yeah, saltwater fish are expensive, but this method works. I've used it on firefish and yellowtail demoiselles, and have plans to use it on randall's gobies next. Bidirectional hermaphroditism does exist, but if they're protandrous/protogynous, once they're reached their final sex, that's it; no more sex changes. And we don't know nearly enough about some fish to know "oh, they're juveniles at this stage, females at that stage, and males at that stage" especially when there's no sexual dimorphism at all.
No. Clownfish are damselfish...we forget this too...Chrysiptera in particular are known to be a protogynous (i.e. juvenile->female->male) hermaphrodites.
Similar threads
