My take is that trace element dosing should be fun for those that really like to experiment and any perceived benefits would probably be more noticeable with colors of certain SPS. In these terms, I think it will be tough to get past anecdotal evidence. It would be fun to see someone run a controlled experiment with two identical tanks then dose an individual supplement to one tank to see the effect on color and growth and then have it repeated...wishful thinking on my part.
Overall I agree with Randy. Now when you're wading through the anecdotal evidence (increased coloration, growth, health, etc) I think it is important to understand that some of these perceived benefits may be due to a number of factors other than the trace dosing, not limited to tank maturity, corals further acclimated to the system, stability of doing major elements, overall skill of the reefer. So is it really the trace element that's making things look better and grow faster? That said, I like the idea of dosing trace elements for fun and do feel that there is a benefit to certain SPS in terms of color (how much definitely can be debated). I think lighting plays a more important role, however. Some trace elements (ie copper) I am very leery of dosing haphazardly even if colors improve.
You can see gorgeous SPS tanks with beautiful colors on both sides of the spectrum so that tells me that dosing does not have a huge benefit. FWIW, I do not currently dose trace elements and just maintain the big 3 :). If I were to experiment, it would be for the goal of maintaining Strontium, Potassium, and Iodine.