- Joined
- Jun 29, 2026
- Messages
- 476
- Reaction score
- 648
- Location
- Antigonish, Canada
- What state or country do you live in
- Canada
Theres a lot of interesting discussion and debate on this site. One of the most interesting debates to me is feeding and it's role in fish health.
Based on the track record of people like Paul B I wonder if many of our issues with new introductions avoiding feeding may be as follows
A hypothesis:
Prolonged fasting and transportation-associated stress in wild-caught marine ornamental fish disrupt intestinal microbial community composition and colonization resistance. Subsequent exposure to nutritionally and microbiologically dissimilar captive diets may impede restoration of the native microbial community, favor the persistence or proliferation of opportunistic taxa, and contribute to prolonged post-transport anorexia in otherwise acclimated fish.
Please give this hypothesis feedback I would like honest opinions. Do you believe the above is supported by current literature? Do you believe it incorrect? Opinion based on anecdotal evidence is still appreciated. This isn't for a research paper this is just curiosity.
Based on the track record of people like Paul B I wonder if many of our issues with new introductions avoiding feeding may be as follows
A hypothesis:
Prolonged fasting and transportation-associated stress in wild-caught marine ornamental fish disrupt intestinal microbial community composition and colonization resistance. Subsequent exposure to nutritionally and microbiologically dissimilar captive diets may impede restoration of the native microbial community, favor the persistence or proliferation of opportunistic taxa, and contribute to prolonged post-transport anorexia in otherwise acclimated fish.
Please give this hypothesis feedback I would like honest opinions. Do you believe the above is supported by current literature? Do you believe it incorrect? Opinion based on anecdotal evidence is still appreciated. This isn't for a research paper this is just curiosity.

. I believe if the above hypothesis is correct that yes that would be likely. The fasting would likely cause a big enough shift in the intestinal community that it would likely affect opportunistic taxa if this above stands as correct. Although there's variables there ie tank raised fish would already be eating prepared food and may have less diversity in the microbiome, different dominant species, less opportunistic taxa, etc.

. That sure would simplify things. I live in the middle of nowhere so all the fish I buy for my new system need to be shipped it would be a convenient time to test some of these concepts