Microbe communities and shipping

keagan

Active Member
View Badges
Joined
Jun 29, 2026
Messages
476
Reaction score
648
Location
Antigonish, Canada
What state or country do you live in
Canada
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
Theres a lot of interesting discussion and debate on this site. One of the most interesting debates to me is feeding and it's role in fish health.

Based on the track record of people like Paul B I wonder if many of our issues with new introductions avoiding feeding may be as follows

A hypothesis:

Prolonged fasting and transportation-associated stress in wild-caught marine ornamental fish disrupt intestinal microbial community composition and colonization resistance. Subsequent exposure to nutritionally and microbiologically dissimilar captive diets may impede restoration of the native microbial community, favor the persistence or proliferation of opportunistic taxa, and contribute to prolonged post-transport anorexia in otherwise acclimated fish.

Please give this hypothesis feedback I would like honest opinions. Do you believe the above is supported by current literature? Do you believe it incorrect? Opinion based on anecdotal evidence is still appreciated. This isn't for a research paper this is just curiosity.
 
I'm going to tag the #reefsquad crew on this one as there are some smart people in it, and could provide good feedback
 
Following due to interest, but the gut microbiome topic usually ends up in a very ugly, often unscientific discussion so for now I keep a safe distance 😅

Cat Popcorn GIF by Basecat
 
Following due to interest, but the gut microbiome topic usually ends up in a very ugly, often unscientific discussion so for now I keep a safe distance 😅

Cat Popcorn GIF by Basecat
Hopefully this will just be a few responses to the above hypothesis and doesn't turn into that 😅. I'm not emotionally invested I welcome people saying I'm wrong especially if they provide evidence of why.
 
Hopefully this will just be a few responses to the above hypothesis and doesn't turn into that 😅. I'm not emotionally invested I welcome people saying I'm wrong especially if they provide evidence of why.
I don't think you'd be the problem 🤣

I don't have much here off the top of my head, but you may be on to something, so following along.

Would you think something similar might happen even with tank raised fish since most fish are fasted before shipping?
 
This is an interesting idea, and I could see it working both ways. Here are my thoughts:

1. Indeed, many studies have demonstrated that a healthy gut microbiome can confer benefits to immunity. The gut is also a major potential entry point for pathogens. So if the handling conditions could cause stress that disrupts the microbiome, then perhaps fasting could help prevent the proliferation of harmful microbes. Feeding could do that too - I could just see potential for either scenario. Maybe pro/pre/synbiotics could help too.

2. Weaning a fish onto a new diet is ideal (instead of an abrupt change) but you're right - that's often not an option for wild-caught fish. In aquaculture typically you would start mixing in some of the new diet with the old diet gradually to wean them.

3. I personally don't think I've seen healthy fish refuse to eat solely because of transport. There has always been some sort of issue present, or at the very least they're just stuck on live feed. Refusal to eat is something you hear about a lot with wild marine fishes, but you rarely hear about it with aquacultured fishes. I've seen/heard a lot less about it with wild freshwater fishes too. Saltwater species seem to be tougher to get to eat IME. I've heard many people attribute this to collection methods but it could be something else too.

4. The main issue with shipping is the water quality. I've seen what happens when you don't let the fish purge before shipping (much more mortality). Of course this is related to fish density, water volume, shipping time, etc. The ammonia buildup and oxygen depletion are major factors, and they become much bigger issues when the fish aren't purged.

In summary, you may be right, but I think in practice it's a matter of weighing the lesser of two evils, and maintaining water quality usually prevails. We actually just finished some fish shipping experiments at work, but the data won't be published for a while.
 
I don't think you'd be the problem 🤣

I don't have much here off the top of my head, but you may be on to something, so following along.

Would you think something similar might happen even with tank raised fish since most fish are fasted before shipping?
Thanks 😂. I believe if the above hypothesis is correct that yes that would be likely. The fasting would likely cause a big enough shift in the intestinal community that it would likely affect opportunistic taxa if this above stands as correct. Although there's variables there ie tank raised fish would already be eating prepared food and may have less diversity in the microbiome, different dominant species, less opportunistic taxa, etc.

I think some of this may be easy to test at hobby level but I have never weighed a fish and that would be necessary.
 
Some questions for the community

Do fish that arrive in particularly poor condition tend to have longer-lasting feeding problems, even after their physical condition improves?

Have you ever had a fish that appeared completely settled, behaved normally, and maintained normal respiration but still refused all food?

Do you notice differences in feeding recovery between wild-caught and captive-bred specimens of the same species?

Have you noticed that some wild-caught fish refuse food for extended periods even after appearing to recover from shipping stress?

How long does it typically take newly imported wild-caught fish to begin eating consistently?

Have you noticed differences in feeding recovery between fish shipped overnight and those that spend several days in transit?
 
I have never weighed a fish and that would be necessary.
It's not easy, from what I understand, but there are methods, and Jay Hemdal would know those methods; we can tag him if you'd like help with that.

In my mind, I don't see why you can't place the fish in a known volume of water, note how much the water level rises due to the fish, and then from that calculate the mass of the fish. That makes sense to me and maybe only to me, but I know Jay would know for sure how to weigh a fish.
 
Wait, could you not simply place a small container of water on a larger sized scale, tare it, add the fish, and that should give you the weight of the fish, right? I must be oversimplifying that 🤪
 
Wait, could you not simply place a small container of water on a larger sized scale, tare it, add the fish, and that should give you the weight of the fish, right? I must be oversimplifying that 🤪
Now that you mention it I can't see why that wouldn't work 🤔. That sure would simplify things. I live in the middle of nowhere so all the fish I buy for my new system need to be shipped it would be a convenient time to test some of these concepts

Edit: for the sake of sample size I could do up questionnaires and possibly get feedback from people here on newly shipped fish
 
Do fish that arrive in particularly poor condition tend to have longer-lasting feeding problems, even after their physical condition improves?

IMO a fish that not eat in a week or two after arriving will not improve their physical condition. That´s the reason why I always try to get my fish in the bag when it arrive to the LFS in order to minimize the time with low or no food.

ow long does it typically take newly imported wild-caught fish to begin eating consistently?

Whit the way I do - it normally takes some days before they start to eat or seek food. I always have my newcomers in my refugium or in an observation box in the DT

Have you noticed differences in feeding recovery between fish shipped overnight and those that spend several days in transit?

I have experiences of more than 25,000 fish shipped during + 48 hours (direct import) and it takes a lot of time and efforts to get them to eat as fast as possible.

In my opinion, a refusal to eat is caused by the transport process itself, regardless of the actual duration of the journey. I have encountered just as much difficulty getting fish to eat even when I know for a fact that they were eating beforehand (for example, when receiving them from friends or these days after a one-hour trip from my local fish store).

The issue is more about their nutritional status immediately prior to transport. If that status is good—meaning the fish are well-fed—they will handle the introduction process much better. However, for long-distance transport, a fasting period of a couple of days is recommended to prevent water quality from deteriorating too much during the journey.

Generally, fish can withstand fairly long periods of fasting, as they are able to utilize both the fat and protein stored in their bodies to sustain themselves. But if they begin to rely too heavily on their protein stored in muscles and other places, it can lead to damage from which it is difficult to recover.

What my point is

Wild-caught fish—with varying health statuses—are held at collection points, transported to exporters, and kept there pending orders. They are then transported to retailers, held until ordered, transported to a local fish store (LFS), and kept there until you purchase them—followed by transport, acclimatization, and introduction into your display tank (DT).

This entails at least six acclimatization phases following transport. Shortening this chain—or keeping the fish for longer at each stage (to the point where it has begun to feed during one or more of these steps)—results in a fish with a better chance of starting to eat once it reaches an aquarist.

On the other hand, with farmed fish, we know that they generally have a good nutritional status, as the producer has a strong interest in ensuring the fry reach a marketable size as quickly as possible. Furthermore, the transport chain is typically shorter, meaning the fish that will undergo the adaptation process are in a good and known nutritional condition.

My conclusion is likely that it has less to do with the bacterial flora and more to do with the nutritional status at the beginning of the supply chain—and, in some cases, whether that status is maintained to a greater or lesser extent throughout the transport process.

Sincerely Lasse
 
Theres a lot of interesting discussion and debate on this site. One of the most interesting debates to me is feeding and it's role in fish health.

Based on the track record of people like Paul B I wonder if many of our issues with new introductions avoiding feeding may be as follows

A hypothesis:

Prolonged fasting and transportation-associated stress in wild-caught marine ornamental fish disrupt intestinal microbial community composition and colonization resistance. Subsequent exposure to nutritionally and microbiologically dissimilar captive diets may impede restoration of the native microbial community, favor the persistence or proliferation of opportunistic taxa, and contribute to prolonged post-transport anorexia in otherwise acclimated fish.

Please give this hypothesis feedback I would like honest opinions. Do you believe the above is supported by current literature? Do you believe it incorrect? Opinion based on anecdotal evidence is still appreciated. This isn't for a research paper this is just curiosity.
I find this quite interesting and will forge a proper and more in-depth reply in a little bit when I get a break.

However, to me this makes sense.

You have a fish that is collected from the wild, it gets placed in a holding tank that is probably overcrowded awaiting to be bagged and shipped halfway across the world. It arrives at a wholesaler, who again dumps it in a holding tank to be shipped to let's say a LFS. It arrives there, again gets dumped in with other fish, then comes the copper treatment, people walking by, pretty much bare tanks, etc.

The stressors keep adding up.
 
@Paul B I'd like to read your thoughts on this sir
His recorded experiences I read on here coupled with other members here are the reason I started pondering this hypothesis. Along with the study done on sailfin tang gut fauna post shipping and the study on sea bream gut fauna. I'll list references later on.
 

TOP 10 Trending Threads

HOW WOULD YOU FEEL ABOUT RECEIVING A FISH OR CORAL AS A HOLIDAY GIFT?

  • I’d love one, as long as it’s a species I chose

    Votes: 20 26.3%
  • I’d trust someone who knows my tank to choose

    Votes: 6 7.9%
  • I’d rather get a gift card and pick it myself

    Votes: 28 36.8%
  • I’d prefer gear or supplies instead

    Votes: 2 2.6%
  • Please don’t surprise me with livestock

    Votes: 20 26.3%
  • Other (Post in the comments)

    Votes: 0 0.0%
Back
Top
Home
Post thread…
Market
What's new